Monday, October 11, 2004

The Avenging Conscience


D. W. Griffith: The Avening Conscience (1914). Poster from IMDb.

Having recently seen this I did not visit the Sacile screening, but I include the Russell Merritt essay to have a complete run of the Griffith Project 8 program notes.

THE AVENGING CONSCIENCE (Majestic Motion Picture Co., US 1914)
The Avenging Conscience: or 'Thou Shalt Not Kill'
    Dir.: D. W. Griffith; cast: Henry B. Walthall, Spottiswoode Aitken, Blanche Sweet, Josephine Crowell, George Siegmann, Ralph Lewis; 35 mm, 5078 ft, 85’ (16 fps), The Museum of Modern Art.
    English intertitles.
    Grand piano: David Drazin.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): The Griffith Project 8, 11 Oct 2004.

Russell Merritt [DWG Project # 510]: "Customarily, Griffith’s chroniclers treat The Avenging Conscience as a transitional work, the hurried contract picture finished in June 1914, just before The Birth of a Nation was put into production. Or it becomes yet another example of Griffith the forerunner, in this case with a film that anticipates the mise-en-scène and montage of French Impressionist cinema, the irrational psychology of Das Cabinet des Dr. Caligari, or the more elaborate subjective and allegorical sequences in Griffith’s own later work. Yet The Avenging Conscience can also be seen as an anomalous Griffith film, a rich one-of-a-kind, long overdue for serious critical study in its own right."

"Those who write about the film have, for good reason, invariably singled out the sequences dramatizing the Nephew’s mental breakdown. Those scenes represent a new direction for Griffith, who, for all his interest in dramatizing mental crises and subjective states at Biograph, had never before depicted a dream or vision; nor, for that matter, had he worked much with flashbacks. Access to the inner life of Biograph characters came from different sources, as we’ve seen in one-reelers as diverse as Sweet Revenge, The Summer Idyll, and What Shall We Do With Our Old? True, portraying characters in the midst of bad dreams, hurtful memories, and ecstatic visions were staples for Biograph leading players, but Griffith never before showed what the dream or memory-images themselves looked like. Even flashbacks, when they started appearing in his last year at Biograph, are unattached to a character’s mental projection. Judith of Bethulia marks the first and last Griffith Biograph to deploy a flashback that is unambiguously derived from a character’s thought process. And even that is a brief, conventional precursor to the flamboyant, diverse renderings of character psychology that erupt in The Avenging Conscience."

"What we see in The Avenging Conscience is Griffith drawing upon tactics he had deliberately avoided in his short films, devices that had become associated with the increasingly archaic practices of the non-continuous cinema – the tableau, allegorical characters, apparitions, and Biblical figures often rendered in multiple exposure, slow-motion, or with matte special effects. These were tools recently given new life by the spectacular success of the recent Italian imports, particularly Guazzoni’s Quo Vadis? and Caserini’s Gli ultimi giorni di Pompei (Cabiria would follow shortly). But, as if to accentuate the melodramatic excess of these older protocols, Griffith also creates psychological sequences driven by montage where the mise-en-scène is unmarked by any obvious form of graphic or optical distortion. Scenes of fire and brimstone co-exist with startling montage sequences where the mind responds to external stimuli. These latter are the sequences that, unsurprisingly, critics have found progressive and “cinematic”. When Mitry refers to the sophisticated psychological tension in the film, he has in mind Walthall responding to the micro close-ups of murderous ants or reacting nervously to close-ups of piercing eyes and pulsating objects (a swinging pendulum, a thumping foot, and a tapping pencil) during his interrogation."

"But highlighting the inner visions and dream symbolizations works a subtle distortion on the film, oversimplifying Griffith’s distinctions between fantasy and reality. The closer we get, the less stable and determinate the narrative in this strange film appears. The waking, so-called “real” world in the film is itself forever fragmenting, occupied by characters with unfixed identities who wander through ambiguous time zones. Even when taken as a film structured around the associative consciousness of a single character – Henry Walthall’s Nephew – The Avenging Conscience falls into a kind of epistemological vortex."

"We can start with the relationship between the Nephew and Edgar Allan Poe. Poe is introduced as the historical source for the story, the author of “The Tell-Tale Heart” and “Annabel Lee”. The Nephew is initially represented as a great admirer of Edgar Allan Poe, but as the story unfolds, he becomes a character within a Poe story, and at times a surrogate for Poe, the sensitive neurotic artist par excellence who creates poetry out of his nightmares. The outside world works in similar flux. When we first meet the Nephew as an adult, the historical beaver hats and morning coats indicate an 1830s setting contemporaneous with Poe; but we move to an up-to-date village with a restaurant advertising for “Automobile Parties” and a garden party that combines allegorical dancing and a slang-talking American waitress with guests arriving in Victorian formal wear."

"And when we meet Annabel, the woman the Nephew loves, objective reality altogether blurs with assorted stages of projection. She is a woman with no name other than the one the Nephew has given her, taken from Poe’s famous poem. We are introduced to her as a mental projection, as complex as Griffith ever designed. The Nephew, in the midst of reading “The Tell-Tale Heart,” stares hard at the frontispiece picture of Poe and pauses to think. We cut to Annabel in her room, who sits at a table to fondle and kiss a framed portrait of the Nephew. Back and forth between Nephew and Annabel until the Nephew puts down Poe’s picture and now starts to write his sweetheart a letter."

"By 1914, Griffith had long made a specialty of ambiguous cutaways that blended subjective with objective action, images that signaled mental projections as well as events that were actually taking place. But here Griffith ups the ante: Annabel, seen in the cutaway as a possible thought projection, reciprocates by projecting back to the Nephew, staring at his picture. The subject of a mental projection is caught in the act of having a mental projection of her own. But both characters operate inside a bell jar, seen as extrapolations from Poe’s pre-existing texts. What is the Nephew’s Annabel caught doing when he conjures her up? Re-enacting thoughts that Poe’s poet claimed his Annabel had for him: “And this maiden she lived with no other thought / Than to love and be loved by me.” The Nephew’s Annabel will continue to follow the formula Poe has devised for her literary prototype: live in a kingdom by the sea and separate from her love when the Nephew’s highborn kinsman comes, and eventually jump to “… her tomb by the sounding sea”."

"Likewise, the Nephew is not merely inspired by the demented narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart” to murder his Uncle and brick him up in a wall. He is re-enacting, apparently with no recognition, the events invented in his literary idol’s imagination. He sits in his study reading the first paragraph of “The Tell-Tale Heart” – “I think it was his eye!” – while his one-eyed Uncle sits glaring at him after scrutinizing his account books. In fact, it is not the Uncle’s eye that does him in. But by surrounding the Nephew with born-again Poe characters and actions, Griffith has given the Nephew’s sensitivities, actions, thoughts, and dreams a derivative, pre-patterned cast. What are the lines he reads? “The disease had sharpened my senses – not destroyed – not dulled them. Above all was the sense of hearing acute. I heard all things in the heaven and in the earth.” Sharpened hearing, we soon learn, defines the Nephew, first italicized when Annabel stands outside, and he responds to a close-up of her foot tap-tapping at his chamber door. The murder – an act that is portrayed as both premeditated and spontaneous – gives way to fantasies that are themselves all secondhand, visions based on Poe writings and Victorian Bible illustrations. But more to the point, the representational blur between Poe and the Nephew gives The Avenging Conscience an uncanny aspect long before the Nephew starts hallucinating."

"The film is permeated by a crisis of perception that may bring it into the orbit of Caligari and the German unheimlich universe, or at least make comparisons between the two films useful. Like Caligari and its models, The Avenging Conscience is saturated with doubles and mirrors, characters existing as variations, their identities subject to a constant slippage. But in Caligari, the narrative instability is triggered by the characters doubling each other and events being set up as reflections and variations of prior events. Our inability to distinguish clear and fixed identities comes from the seemingly infinite variability and displacement of Caligari, Cesare, Jane, and Francis. In The Avenging Conscience, on the other hand, the confusing psychological constellations derive from the shifting relationships the fictional characters have with their Author and his Word, and between the shifting relationship between the Author and the unfolding story."

"Poe’s words, as we might expect from the Biograph director who sometimes constructed entire films around famous poems and song lyrics, are given a quasi-religious hagiographic status. The first quotation is photographed from an actual page of a Poe work, followed by an engraving of the author himself. From then on, the intertitles that quote Poe are set off from all other intertitles by a special typeface and unique border design. Further, the images that follow the Poe titles are almost invariably hyper-images: elaborate double exposures or mattes that not only highlight the fantastical in Poe’s writings, but also underscore their cultural importance. A quotation from “Annabel Lee” precedes the shot of Annabel posed beside a matted image of a moonlit sky seen through a window frame; the ghouls are models caught behind smoke effects – visualizations of a quotation from “The Tell-Tale Heart”. The hallucinations themselves, with their heavily moralistic tone and fiend imagery (Dante’s seventh circle as seen by the Iowa-stubborn residents of River City), actually have little to do with Poe. But Griffith co-opts and absorbs them into Poe’s fantasmagoria, as though Poe’s nightmare visions now had scriptural force. One of the ways that Griffith doubles Poe and the Nephew is by ending the film with the Nephew reading from his own newly published text. Now it is the Nephew’s Word that triggers the fantastical images. Inspired by his Poe-driven nightmare, the Nephew has finally attained Poe’s ability to conjure images with words of his own, images that counter the Biblical terrors of Golgotha and Hell with mythological images of pastoral rejoicing."

"It is not that Griffith has simply cobbled together a narrative from episodes in Poe’s stories. Poe’s authority is more elusive than that. Important plotlines and characters, ranging from the grocer and the maid to the blackmailing Italian, have nothing to do with Poe, any more than do the Uncle’s conversion scene with a baby or the shootout with the sheriff’s posse. It is more accurate to see Poe’s writings as pentimento traces that invade and control the film, then retreat and grow invisible, lurk and hide, or mutate and combine with other sources to create a protean vision of a hallucinatory world. As Claire Dupré la Tour (“The Written Word and Memory in Griffith’s Intolerance and Dreyer’s La passion de Jeanne d’Arc”, 1995–1996) and Miriam Hansen (“The Hieroglyph and the Whore: D. W. Griffith’s Intolerance”, 1989; Babel and Babylon, 1991) have shown, Intolerance – a film that begins with a hand opening a book – is the classic Griffith text governed by notions of deciphering and reading, where one text is superimposed over another to create resonating historical memory patterns. The Avenging Conscience provides a curious and heretofore unstudied precedent.
" – Russell Merritt [DWG Project # 510]

Operator Kaufman


Photo not from the film Operator Kaufman. Dziga Vertov: The Man With a Movie Camera (1929). A montage in Charles Silver's blog Inside / Out, MoMA, 20 April 2010.

OPERATOR KAUFMAN (Rasmus Gerlach, D 1999+)
    Dir: Rasmus Hamburg; ph: Irina Linke, Rasmus Hamburg; ed: Tim Tonstein; consultants: Thomas Tode, Aleksandr Deriabin; interviewees: Alexander Hammid, Jakov Tolchan, Elizaveta Svilova, Henri Storck, Jonas Mekas, Erik Barnouw, Mikhail Kaufman, Pierre Merle; DVD, 60’, bn e colore / b/w & color, sonoro / sound, Rasmus Gerlach, Hamburg.
    Versione inglese, con sottotitoli in inglese / English, Russian, German, & French dialogue, with English narration & subtitles.
    In the presence of Rasmus Hamburg.
    Viewed at Cinema Ruffo, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM) (Vertov), 11 Oct 2004.

Thomas Tode (GCM): "Rasmus Hamburg’s film Operator Kaufman is an experimental-style biopic about the lives and works of three famous avant-garde filmmakers, who also happen to be brothers. David, Mikhail, and Boris Kaufman were born to middle-class parents in Tsarist Russia, and came to prominence as filmmakers in the 1920s. The film takes the year 1929 as its starting point, when David, better known as Dziga Vertov, directed the classic Man with a Movie Camera. His cinematographer and star was his brother Mikhail, who went on to make the avant-garde film Vesnoi (In Spring) in the Ukraine the same year."

"Operator Kaufman is a work-in-progress which showcases the three brothers and their amazing contribution to the world of cinema. As Andrew Gilby of the Brisbane Film Festival wrote: "Rasmus Hamburg has done his best to make an avant-garde film modelled after the work of his famous subjects — including his own ‘man with a movie camera’ footage of everyday citizens in Russia today — but the real stars of the film are the brothers themselves, in interviews, and more especially in clips from their ground-breaking works." The film, still an ever-growing database, was awarded the Prix du Documentaire Historique by the 2000 UNESCO Film Festival for Art and Education in Paris, and recently won the documentary award at the 2004 Athens International Film and Video Festival in Ohio. Chris Marker called it a moving movie." – Thomas Tode (GCM)

AA: Vertovian documentaries form a fine sub-category of their own: in many, like here, the form of the movie has a Vertov touch.

Dziga Vertov V: Kino-Pravda No. 9–13, GCM Sacile 2004, narrated by Yuri Tsivian


Dziga Vertov: Kino-Pravda No. 9 (1922). Photo: Österreichisches Filmmuseum. The Kino-Pravda series is online on the Österreichisches Filmmuseum website.

DZIGA VERTOV V
Moderator, live translator, narrator and explicador: Yuri Tsivian
Grand piano: Neil Brand
Cinema Ruffo, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 11 Oct 2004
Prog. 5 (75’)

KINO-PRAVDA, NO. 9–11, 13 (Goskino, USSR 1922)
35 mm, (20 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 9 275 m., 12’
    AA: Österreichisches Filmmuseum: Issue Daten: August 25, 1922. Video Duration: 13 min 46 sec. Congress of the "Living Church" / Opening of the racing season / Demonstration of an American movie camera / Operation of mobile projection units.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 10 321 m., 14’
    AA: Österreichisches Filmmuseum: Issue Daten: Early September 1922. Video Duration: 15 min 38 sec. International Youth Day and demonstrations / All-Russian Olympiad / Streetcar collision / Construction of automobiles in a Petrograd factory

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 11 373 m., 16’
    AA: Issue Daten: October 5, 1922. Video Duration: 18 min 19 sec. All-Russian Congress of Trade Unions / Delegations and diplomats / Renaming of a confectionery factory / Unloading supplies / Komsomol Day / Red Army maneuvers.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 13 VCHERA, SEGODNIA, ZAVTRA. KINOPOEMA, POSVIASHCHENNAIA OKTIABRSKIM TOZRZHESTVAM / OKTIABRSKAIA KINO-PRAVDA [IERI, OGGI, DOMANI: CINEPOEMA DEDICATO A LENIN / KINOPRAVDA DI OTTOBRE; YESTERDAY, TODAY, TOMORROW. A FILM POEM DEDICATED TO THE OCTOBER CELEBRATIONS / OCTOBER KINO-PRAVDA]
Sc/montage: Dziga Vertov; intertitles: Aleksandr Rodchenko; 743 m, 33’
    AA: 3. reel missing. Issue Daten: November 1922. Video Duration: 36 min 32 sec. Fifth anniversary of the October Revolution

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "Vertov was a fast learner. Much as he said he despised fiction movies, he learned quite a bit from them. As was fashionable among young intellectuals in the early 1920s, Vertov found Russian and German films slow and portentous, but did admit that unpretentious American action movies were worth studying. In his first essay, "We: Variant of a Manifesto", published in August 1922, he wrote: "To the American adventure film with its showy dynamism and to the dramatizations of the American Pinkertons, the kinocs say thanks for the rapid shot changes and the close-up. Good… but disorderly, not based on a precise study of movement." (As translated in Annette Michelson, ed., Kino-Eye: The Writings of Dziga Vertov, 1984, p. 6.)"

"Keep this passage in mind as you watch Kino-Pravda No. 9, which came out in August 1922. Take a random half-minute sequence. The opening of the racing season in Moscow: people in cars and buses are heading for the Moscow Hippodrome. A routine bus ride — but what makes it interesting is that Vertov renders it in 10 shots: the conductor selling tickets (1.6 metres); the driver starting the engine (0.8 metres); the engine running (1.3 metres); a passenger’s hand holding onto the railing (0.5 metres); the driver’s foot pressing the accelerator (0.5 metres); and so on. Ten shots in half a minute, an average of 3 seconds per shot. The main thing is that there is no dramatic or narrative necessity to cut that fast. Pure experiment: speed for speed’s sake."

"In the new Russia, speed was a religion. Want to know how fast a mobile projection unit can be deployed in a Moscow square? A live experiment is staged to establish this — find the filmed record in issue 9 of Kino-Pravda. We see someone phoning the Photo-Kino Committee. Title: "Give a film show in Strastnaia Square." The request is transmitted to the mobile projection unit: "Take peredvizhkino no. 4 and depart for Strastnaia Square. Start the show at 9." Peredvizhkino (or "ambulkino," if we try to translate this Soviet acronym for mobile film-showing equipment) is taken out of the depot and hooked up to a horse-drawn cab. As the cabman reaches Strastnaia, the countdown begins. To the amazement of passers-by, a screen is stretched across the square, and the equipment is unloaded and set up. "Peredvizhkino can be deployed for a show in 8 minutes," the title announces. Don’t ask who on earth would ever need a movie show set up in 8 minutes. Speed for speed’s sake!"
 

"The new cult of speed and skill (two things considered lacking in "old" Russia) also explains why the bulk of Kino-Pravda No. 10 is taken up by the All-Russia Olympiad. Note the editing of the shots showing javelin-throwing and pole-vaulting. It appears to be experimenting with what Vertov’s writings call "a precise study of movement". Preparation — launch — flight — fall, one shot per each phase of the trajectory. Clarity and precision were as important as skill and speed. Vertov’s editing style here becomes athletic."

"Clarity and precision were also qualities cultivated by Constructivist art — the recently-born Soviet art movement which waved farewell to easel painting and welcomed engineering and design. Vertov was friends with the Constructivist artist Aleksandr Rodchenko, who agreed to design the titles for Vertov’s films. According to documents, their collaboration began with Kino-Pravda No. 7 (July 1922), but it is hard to confirm since only a fragment of issue 7 exists. But the proudly practical, deliberately uncomplicated, brick-like (or block-like, blochny) Constructivist lettering which we see in Kino-Pravda No. 10 (September 1922) is definitely by Rodchenko."

"Vertov never thought of his group or his films as Kino-Constructivist, but many did, including the Constructivist theorist and designer Aleksei Gan, whose review of Kino-Pravda No. 10 (in Kino-fot, 1922, No. 4) is worth quoting: "The 10th Kino-Pravda is valuable not only for the abundance of material; its value lies in the rhythm and tempo to which the film conforms, from the first shot to the last. The international festival of the union of youth, and assembling a car, and restoring a factory — in a word, people, machines, and the material environment — all this has been presented by means proper to cinema as such, without any touches of conventional film aesthetics. In it American montage is just a means for making it possible to construct sequences, shots, and individual scenes. The newsreel ceases to be illustrative material reflecting this or that place in our many-sided contemporary life, and becomes contemporary life as such, outside of territories, time, or individual significance. The whole tenth issue has screen-high intertitles. And here too Vertov has overcome the worn-out technique of horizontal writing. It is clear that words must be constructed on screen in a different way. I cannot call this attempt fully realized, but a word has been spoken. Now it will be shameful to write "in the old way”. I and all young filmmakers await the eleventh issue of Kino-Pravda.”"

"Kino-Pravda No. 11 is more like your regular newsreel, complete with delegations, diplomats, and speakers (be careful not to miss an astonishing close-up of a carafe of water sitting on the podium of one of the speakers, with the whole crowd of listeners and a nearby church reflected in it, upside down). Kino-Pravda No. 12 is the only issue that has not been found (although Aleksandr Deriabin assures me that he knows where to look for it, and knowing him, he knows)."

"Kino-Pravda No. 13 is a magnum opus. Originally 900 metres long, this issue was timed to be released for the fifth anniversary of the October Revolution, and had a separate title: "Yesterday, Today, Tomorrow. A Film Poem Dedicated to the October Celebrations." A celebration like all celebrations: Trotsky, speeches, demonstrations— and suddenly, a jewel: an extreme close-up of someone’s mouth shouting "Hurray!” The reason why Vertov called this film A Film Poem becomes clear in the second — Yesterday — reel. Its purpose is a replay, in retrospect, of the 5 years that have elapsed between 1917 and 1922. Its material is found-footage, often from Vertov’s own earlier films, mostly from the Civil War years."

"A large part of this footage, as you may recall from the selection of Kino-Week newsreel shown earlier, was about burials of heroes. What Vertov does here is to take various funerals, which took place at different times in different towns, and piece them together so that the result looks like a single funeral — some kind of simultaneous, over-arching funeral in which the whole country is participating. This is how Aleksei Gan describes the effect in his 1922 review (Kino-Fot, no. 5, 10 December 1922, pp. 6–7): "The graves in Astrakhan, the spades burying the bodies of our fallen heroes in Kronstadt, the banners lowered at the moment of burial in Minsk. We take off our hats. The Muscovites do the same on the embankment of the Moscow River."

"And this is how Vertov theorized it in his 1923 manifesto "Kinocs: A Revolution” (as translated in Annette Michelson, ed., Kino-Eye: The Writings of Dziga Vertov, 1984, pp. 16–18): "You’re walking down a Chicago street in 1922, but I make you greet Comrade Volodarsky walking down a Petrograd street in 1918, and he returns your greeting. Another example: the coffins of national heroes are lowered into the grave (shot in Astrakhan in 1918); the grave is filled in (Kronstadt, 1921); cannon salute (Petrograd, 1920); memorial service, hats are removed (Moscow, 1922) — such things go together, even with thankless footage not specifically shot for this purpose (cf. Kino-Pravda No. 14) … Freed from the rule of 16–17 frames per second, free of the limits of time and space, I put together any given points in the universe, no matter where I’ve recorded them. My path leads to the creation of a fresh perception of the world. I decipher in a new way a world unknown to us.”
" – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

On Dangerous Ground (1917)


Robert Thornby: On Dangerous Ground (1917) with Carlyle Blackwell and Gail Kane. Photo: IMDb.

Robert Thornby: On Dangerous Ground (1917) with Carlyle Blackwell and Gail Kane. Photo: Nitrateville.

ON DANGEROUS GROUND (World-Peerless, US 1917)
    Dir: Robert Thornby; ph: Lucien Andriot; adapted by Frances Marion from “Little Comrade, a Tale of the Great War”, by Burton E. Stevenson; cast: Carlyle Blackwell, Gail Kane, William Bailey; rel. 8.1.1917.
    35 mm, ? ft, Library of Congress.
    Grand piano: Donald Sosin.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM) / Fort Lee, 11 Oct 2004.   

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "Fort Lee filmmakers began dramatizing the Great War almost as soon as the first shots were fired. Ramo Films quickly adapted another project and staged The War of Wars, or the Franco-German Invasion in Grantwood, New Jersey, in August 1914. But most of the war films produced here over the next few years eschewed elaborate battle scenes in favor of more intimate melodrama involving spies, divided families, and cross-border romances. On Dangerous Ground was adapted by the prolific screenwriter Frances Marion from an intriguing John Buchan-style thriller, although the character of the aggressive heroine is clearly more indebted to Pearl White and other female action stars of the era." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: I only saw the beginning of this obviously interesting WWI drama with a strong female lead, written by Frances Marion.

The Vampire (1913)


Robert Vignola: The Vampire (1913). Alice Eis and Bert French doing the "Vampire Dance". Photo from Leonardo Pisani's blog, discovered in Wikipedia.



Robert Vignola: The Vampire (1913). Alice Eis and Bert French doing the "Vampire Dance". Photos 2-4 from the IMDb.

THE VAMPIRE (Kalem Company, US 1913)
    Dir: Robert Vignola; ph: George Hollister; cast: Harry Millarde, Marguerite Courtot, Alice Hollister, with Bert French and Alice Eis in their famous “Vampire Dance”; rel. 15.10.1913.
    35 mm, 2560 ft, George Eastman House.
    Grand piano: Donald Sosin.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM) / Fort Lee, 11 Oct 2004.

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "The Vampire, with its direct evocation of Burne-Jones’s signature image of voracious female sexuality, beat William Fox’s Theda Bara films into the market by over a year. But both Kalem and Fox were tapping into the general vampire-mania which had swept through various levels of popular culture since the turn of the century. This version was shot at Kalem’s open-air studio on Palisade Avenue in Cliffside Park, just south of Fort Lee. While the wind-blown interiors are somewhat distracting, the film makes good use of New York City locations, which it juxtaposes with the bucolic landscape of Hackensack, New Jersey." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: Reportedly the introduction of the vamp into the cinema. But similar man-eaters were already at large in Denmark (Asta Nielsen), Italy, Russia, Germany...

Qf. Griffith, Murnau... Country boy Harold comes to town, meets city woman. He is fired because of reporting late to work. The country sweetheart Helen is longing for a letter from him in vain. When the boy runs out of money, the vamp has had enough.

The vampire dance by Alice Eis and Bert French is fantastic. Harold recognizes himself in the victim.

Helen comes to the city as a prisoner. She uses the fire escape to flee. "From bad to worse". Harold has turned to alcohol and gets a gun to commit armed robbery.

Sober storytelling in a melodramatic narrative.

A beautiful print.

Dziga Vertov IV: Kino-Pravda No. 1–8, GCM Sacile 2004, narrated by Yuri Tsivian

Dziga Vertov: Kino-Pravda No. 5 (1922). Photo: Österreichisches Filmmuseum. The Kino-Pravda series is online on the Österreichisches Filmmuseum website.


DZIGA VERTOV IV
Moderator, live translator, narrator and explicador: Yuri Tsivian
Grand piano: John Sweeney
Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 11 Oct 2004

Prog. 4 (71’)

KINO-PRAVDA, NO. 1–8 (Goskino, USSR 1922)
35 mm (20 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 1 230 m., 10’
    AA: Famished children. Junkers airplane. Process S.R. (Socialist Revolutionary Party = SRs = Esers).

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 2 222 m., 10’
    AA: Fragments from power station.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 3 161 m., 7’
    AA: Eserov = S.R. Visual quality often good.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 4 164 m., 7’
    AA: Trial of the S.R. Car tyres. Bread barges. Caucasus, Sochi.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 5 170 m., 7’
    AA: Yakovenko – Siberia. Agricultural machines. Dr. Anapa machine. Children's sanatorium. Red derby.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 7 244 m., 11’
    AA: Box projector. Tram crash near Moscow river. Constructivist intertitles. Armored car plant. The assembly of the first motorcar. Acrobatic motorcycling. SR trial. Burnt by Kolchak. Lake Baikal. Forlorn Maika Mines. Kurort Sochi. Tulip tree, Agava. Persia: silk to Baku. Afghanistan: Kabul Caucasus: Red Lane. Betting on SR. Mikhail Kaufman.

KINO-PRAVDA NO. 8 299 m., 13’.
    AA: SR, moving imagery, clock face, Vertov in tram: impatient reader. Plane crash in Moscow. Moscow tramline reconstructed.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "Of all the rarely seen Vertov films, Kino-Pravda (1922–25) is the rarest of all. Everyone (starting with Vertov himself) mentions Kino-Pravda as the playground for Vertov’s boldest experiments in film form, but how many of us have actually seen any of its 23 issues — apart from special issue 21, devoted to Lenin’s death? To show the whole 3-year run of the Kino-Pravda newsreel (all but one survive, though some in fragments) is — I am sure — one of the Giornate’s history-changing decisions. I doubt if it has ever been done before — or could be done, without the involvement of RGAKFD and the Österreichisches Filmmuseum, which hold two of the world’s major collections of Vertov’s films. It’s quite a marathon, it is true, but the reward for running is given not at the finish line, but in the process: to see Kino-Pravda issue-by-issue is like watching a time-lapse movie showing the growth of Soviet avant-garde cinema (born in 1922, not in 1924 as we are normally told)."

"Like many a Left-wing artist of the 1920s, Vertov thought that revolutions in art are somehow linked with revolutions in politics. His Kino-Pravda was about both. In Russian, pravda means "truth", but the Pravda part of the film’s title alludes not to pravda the truth but to Pravda the paper — the Communist Party’s principal daily newspaper (illegal before, official after 1917). Vertov was never a Party member, but one could hardly find a more stalwart partisan of the Party than he. It may sound strange to hear a full champion of the party in power call himself a revolutionary — but then the Soviet Twenties was a strange time. The October Revolution did not end in October, Party leaders kept saying, true revolutions only begin with the takeover of power. All this sounds like doubletalk, and doubletalk it may have been, but if you believed it you felt doubly empowered: you could be a political orthodox while remaining politically — and artistically — Left."

"That the newsreel Kino-Pravda, like the newspaper Pravda, was less about news and more about statements, made Vertov’s task interestingly difficult. He felt he needed to string facts into sequences, and make sequences read like statements — something he kept trying to achieve from the very first issue. Kino-Pravda No. 1 is a good example. It begins with heart-rending pictures of starving children (1922 saw dreadful famine in Russia). It is what Vertov’s theory calls a "fact". The starving-children sequence consists of 16 shots. Then Vertov moves on to another "fact" of Russia’s political life in 1922: the requisitioning of the valuables possessed by the Russian Orthodox Church. Another 15 shots show Soviet authorities plucking pearls and jewels from icons in the presence of depressed, unresisting clergy. Then a title patches the two subjects together: "Every pearl saves a child." And so on. The trick may not look terribly ingenious by today’s standards, but it must have been in 1922. Dialectical editing: thesis — antithesis — synthesis. Kino-Pravda not only shows — it explains!
1922 was the year of political Grand Guignol. The views of famine were devastating. The requisitioning of the Church’s holdings made some hearts sink, some beat faster. But the most thrilling political show that summer was the trial of the S.R.s (short for the Party of Socialist-Revolutionaries). This was a public trial, the first of its kind in Russia, and quite unique in the sense that it was a court trial of a political party by a political party. Distinct from the Bolshevists, the Socialist-Revolutionaries did not call themselves the workers’ party: their point was that in a country like Russia, with a predominantly peasant population, the dictatorship of the proletariat entailed the tyranny of the minority. Another distinction between the two parties was in their ideas about the technology of revolution. The Bolshevists worked by means of strikes and agitation, while the S.R.s relied on individual terrorism (to their credit, the S.R.s never went for soft targets; their objectives were generals, ministers, and tsars). The S.R. party was crucial in the first, anti-monarchist revolution in February 1917, and had a majority in the interim government. When the Bolshevists overthrew this government in October 1917, the S.R.s had every right to consider that their show has been stolen. During the rule of the Bolshevists the S.R.s continued in the same vein. In 1918 one of them, the Socialist-Revolutionary Fania Kaplan, used her Browning to shoot Lenin, who survived but never fully recovered from his wound. There were other acts, some more successful, but the national and international reputation of the S.R. party was such that they could not be banned and disbanded as easily as, say, the Anarchists in 1918."

"I trust the reason for my excursion into historical fact becomes obvious: it sets the scene for what will become a recurrent heading in the first 8 issues of Kino-Pravda, "The S.R. Trial", one of Russia’s top news events of the year. In June 1922, 47 top Socialist-Revolutionaries were brought to court, and newspapers were busy covering the trial until August. Kino-Pravda also followed the ongoing story. Issue No. 1 shows a crowd picketing a railway station in Moscow, as a delegation of European Socialists headed by the Belgian Emile Vandervelde arrives to serve as international defenders of the S.R.s. Some members of the crowd carry banners saying "Cain! Cain! Where is your brother Karl?" To unravel this Biblical allusion, one needs to know that one ofthe arriving S.R. defenders was German Socialist politician Theodor Liebknecht, the brother of Karl Liebknecht, the German Communist leader murdered in 1919."

"We see various street manifestations and "punish-them" rallies — most definitely arranged by powers from above, for it is hard to believe that the crowd in Red Square shown in Kino-Pravda No. 3 would stand through that torrential rain without strict orders. But whether or not the crowds were composed of political extras, the general interest about the trial’s outcome must have been genuine. No one could have seriously doubted that such a political trial could end with anything but a conviction, but exactly what the verdict would be, and whether some would get away with it, kept public interest alive. Apparently, bets were made — at least that is what we learn from Kino-Pravda No. 8, which begins with two men quarrelling. One says, "They will surely be shot." The other doubts it. "Let’s bet on it!" says the intertitle. The scene changes. We are now in the courtroom. The judges are out deliberating. An insert: the face of a clock. A finger moves the clock’s hands to indicate the passage of time. In the street, people crowding around a kiosk are shown waiting for the newspaper with the verdict to arrive. A newsboy is shown running and shouting. A man leans out of the window of a running tram to pick up a newspaper from the boy. Our two bettors drive by in a car and get a copy… But I must be careful not to give away the verdict!"

"Needless to say, this issue of Kino-Pravda consists mostly of staged scenes. But who are the players? The man in the tram is Dziga Vertov. The man who bets "They will surely be shot" is Vertov’s brother, cameraman Mikhail Kaufman. Kaufman’s betting opponent is Ivan Beliakov, Vertov’s cinematographer and graphic artist. The man standing in line for a newspaper is Vertov’s friend, cameraman Aleksandr Lemberg. In other words, these are all Kinocs ("Kino-Eye men") — members of a group which, ironically, condemned any acting in movies. One good thing about Vertov is that he never felt enslaved by his own dogmas."

"There are touches of experimentation in the first 8 issues of Kino-Pravda, which only grow bolder in subsequent issues (note, for instance, the somewhat awkward POV trick with a girl swimmer, or the trick with the tank driver’s close-up). Perhaps the most interesting of these are Vertov’s games with the film’s title. Kino-Pravda No. 5 begins with a view of a man whose face is hidden behind the newspaper he is reading. The title of this sham newspaper is "Kino-Pravda No. 5. July 7, 1922". In other words, the man reading the paper represents us, the spectators, and the paper he is reading stands for the film we are watching. In the next issue, Kino-Pravda No. 6, Vertov tries out another trick, the likes of which he will try again, 7 years later, in Man with a Movie Camera. It begins with a close-up of a box, on which we read the words "Kino-Pravda No. 6. July 14, 1922". A man comes and opens the box, which turns out to contain a reel of film. The man threads the film — the very film we are watching — into a projector, and the newsreel Kino-Pravda No. 6 begins. Take a careful look at the projectionist at work. I could not believe my eyes — but he seems to be smoking as he opens the box and takes out the nitrate film! Verily, Vertov’s time was not for the nervous.
" – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

Sunday, October 10, 2004

La Joie de vivre (1934) 2004 restoration Lobster Films


Hector Hoppin, Anthony Gross: La Joie de vivre (1934). Photo: IMDb.

LA JOIE DE VIVRE (Animat / HG Productions, F 1934)
    Dir/anim: Hector Hoppin, Anthony Gross; mus: Tibor Harsanyí; 35 mm, 250 m, 9’ (24 fps), sound, Lobster Films.
    No intertitles.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Goodnight, Silents, 10 Oct 2004

Serge Bromberg (GCM): "This legendary masterpiece of animation can be seen afresh in a new restoration from a miraculously pristine nitrate print, rediscovered in the early summer of 2004. This magical and exquisite work is contrary to all preconceptions of cartoons of the period. Two long-legged women frolic through various stylised settings, both industrial and natural, ranging from power lines, springtime fields, and a stream, to a busy railway signal house. A male cyclist chases after them, trying to return a shoe one of them has lost. An exquisite ballet of shapes and delightful rhythms, full of joie de vivre. Now little known, the film is a reference point for all specialists in animation cinema." – Serge Bromberg (GCM)

AA: A brilliant print of one of the greatest animations ever made. A ballet defying gravity, a chase where the sky is the limit, a slight narrative giving sufficient excuses for endless inventions. The elements are there: the air, the water, and the earth. We move between nature and urbanity.

The two girlfriends are also like elements themselves: of movement, grace, fun, and life. They are like birds and butterflies. Wherever they run, flowers bloom. They are like leaves flying in the wind. We remember the affinity between animation and animism. Anima is here.

There is an affinity with Douglas Fairbanks whose films we have been seeing in this festival (Double Trouble, He Comes Up Smiling).

La Joie de vivre expands the boundaries of animation with its visions of electricity, water and the train control center. The vision of multiple trains going awry is special.

The nude sequence is witty and charming, with the proper amount of abstraction.

The action sequences evoke the mystical martial arts scenes of King Hu in A Touch of Zen.

The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917)


Maurice Tourneur: The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917) with Mary Pickford. Photo: IMDb.

Mary Pickford directed by Maurice Tourneur in The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917). Photo: IMDb.

THE POOR LITTLE RICH GIRL / Pieni rikas tyttö-parka (Paramount-Artcraft, US 1917)
    Dir: Maurice Tourneur; ph: John van den Broek, Lucien Andriot; sc: Frances Marion, from the play by Eleanor Gates; des: Ben Carré; cast: Mary Pickford, Madeline Traverse, Charles Wellesley, Gladys Fairbanks; rel. 5.3.1917.
    35 mm, 5750 ft, 77’ (20 fps), The Mary Pickford Foundation, Milestone Film & Video, UCLA Film and Television Archive (via Dennis Doros).
    The Poor Little Rich Girl (1917) online.
    In the presence of Richard Koszarski and Carl Meyers.
    Grand piano: Phil Carli.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fort Lee, 10 Oct 2004.

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "The Paragon Studio, just south of Universal’s studio on Main Street, was built by Jules Brulatour in 1915 largely for the use of his artistic partner, Maurice Tourneur. At first they produced films here for World, later for the Mary Pickford Corporation, then Paramount-Artcraft. Eventually the facility was taken over by Selznick before reverting to Brulatour, who continued to make films here with his protégée, Hope Hampton, well into the 1920s. The Poor Little Rich Girl was one of two Pickford vehicles made at the Paragon by Tourneur, and probably the first film in which he and his art director, Ben Carré, experimented with the use of stylized settings (they would make the far more radical The Blue Bird and Prunella in this same studio the following year). Tourneur was a master of theatrical melodrama, but he also waged a one-man campaign to translate the ideals of Gordon Craig, Max Reinhardt, and Maurice Maeterlinck to the cinema screen. The balance of dream and reality worked perfectly here, but none of Tourneur’s subsequent “artistic” features gained equal commercial success." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: A masterpiece combining the talents of Mary Pickford and Maurice Tourneur, based on a compelling screenplay by Frances Marion, displaying the enchanting symbolist design by Ben Carré to create a quest between harsh reality and a dreamworld of the fairy-tale. A turning-point for Mary Pickford: for the first time she portrayed a girl so much younger than herself. A turning-point for Maurice Tourneur in his unique style soon developed in The Blue Bird and Prunella. Tourneur refined the tableau style and opened the way to new perspectives in stylization before Caligari. A beautiful print. One of the greatest highlights of this edition of the GCM. ****

The Iron Claw. Chapter Seven: The Hooded Helper


Advertisement in Moving Picture World. Source: Internet Archive. From: Wikimedia Commons. Please click on the image to enlarge it.

The Iron Claw. Chapter Seven: The Hooded Helper. My screenshot from YouTube.

THE IRON CLAW. EPISODE SEVEN: THE HOODED HELPER (Pathé, US 1916)
    Dir: Edward Jose; cast: Pearl White, Creighton Hale, Sheldon Lewis, Harry Fraser; rel. 10.4.1916.
    35 mm, ? ft, UCLA Film and Television Archive.
    The Iron Claw. Episode Seven: The Hooded Helper: online.
    In the presence of Richard Koszarski and Carl Meyers.
    Grand piano: Phil Carli.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fort Lee, 10 Oct 2004.

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "In revenge for having had his arm cut off by a cuckolded husband, Legar (later known, for obvious reasons, as The Iron Claw) had kidnapped the man’s daughter and raised her for a life of crime. Returned to her father years later by The Laughing Mask, a mysterious crusader for good, Margery (Pearl White) soon becomes involved in the search for a missing treasure map, which provides the excuse for weekly conflict between the forces of good and evil. One of the few locally-produced Pearl White serial episodes to survive in an intact, tinted 35 mm original." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: In 35 mm from a rare print of a Pearl White serial. Fine tinting.

Richard Koszarski: Fort Lee: The Film Town (1904–2004) introduction to the retrospective in Le Giornate del Cinema Muto, Sacile

Richard Koszarski:
Fort Lee: The Film Town (1904-2004)

"The 100th anniversary of the incorporation of the Borough of Fort Lee, New Jersey, provides an ideal moment to reflect on the role this new community played in the development of the American motion picture industry. Laid out by General George Washington at the time of the American Revolution (he was soon forced to abandon it when British forces succeeded in crossing the Hudson a few miles to the north), Fort Lee was for its first century a rural satellite of New York. Farming provided the basic occupation, but towards the end of the 19th century the area also became an attractive tourist mecca. The Palisades, which General Washington felt might protect the spot from invasion, had succeeded in retarding the commercial development which had overcome most of the Hudson’s Jersey shore. No railroad line was ever built along the Palisades, and most direct access was by ferry across the Hudson River and then up the Palisades via interurban trolley car. To take advantage of this relative isolation vacation cabins were constructed as summertime rentals, while tourist hotels and livery stables catered to New Yorkers seeking a bucolic getaway only a day trip from midtown Manhattan. And Fort Lee was not only unspoiled and close at hand, it offered surprising topographical variety, with cliffs, cornfields, rocky shoreline, country estates, and winding village roads all within its geographical boundaries. By 1907 the tourists had been joined by filmmakers.

Gene Gauntier and Sidney Olcott of the Kalem company claimed to be the first to discover the value of this community as a production center. In any case, they were soon joined by Biograph, Pathé, IMP, the New York Motion Picture Company, and other early producers, trust members and independents alike. James Young Deer shot Pathé’s first American westerns here in 1910, while D. W. Griffith made nearly 100 short films in Fort Lee. Soon, “Jersey scenery” had become so commonplace on motion picture screens that the term acquired an unfortunate generic meaning: an overused landscape failing to pass as something it is not. That same year Mark Dintenfass decided to take Fort Lee filmmaking indoors, opening the Champion studio at the borough’s northern boundary. At that moment, Fort Lee passed from being just another interesting location and began its brief career as America’s first “motion picture town”. Within a few years the borough’s tax rolls would be completely dominated by motion picture studios and laboratories.

Champion was soon joined by American Éclair and Alice Guy Blaché’s Solax, the beginnings of a French invasion that would shape the character of Fort Lee filmmaking for a decade. Backed by Eastman raw stock mogul Jules Brulatour, Éclair’s Charles Jourjon built the Peerless studio next door to Éclair as a center for feature film production. When World War I changed Jourjon’s plans, the World-Peerless studio was taken over by his partners, Broadway impresarios Lee and J. J. Shubert, with Lewis J. Selznick and later William Brady as managing partners. For several years the Éclair and World studios served as a dissemination point for French filmmakers, film style, and film technology. Maurice Tourneur, Albert Capellani, Ben Carré, Lucien Andriot, Francis Doublier, and Georges Benoît were all on staff here, as was a certain Monsieur Grisel, employed as interpreter (Émile Cohl and Étienne Arnaud had already returned to France, while Léonce Perret and Henri Ménessier were busy down the road at Solax).

In 1914, laboratory specialist “Doc” Willat had opened his own lab and two large greenhouse studios just south of Éclair. The World-Éclair-Willat properties constituted an unprecedented film superblock, crowded with stages and laboratories (today known as Constitution Park, it is home to summer concerts and outdoor film screenings). Willat rented his stages to William Fox, then to Triangle and Fine Arts. Theda Bara, Douglas Fairbanks, and “Fatty” Arbuckle would work here over the next few years. Just across the street from the Willat stages, Universal built the largest glass-enclosed studio in the world in 1915, the same year that they opened a western “Universal City” in California. In 1917 it would become home to the new Goldwyn Corporation, and Fort Lee’s ferries would be renamed for Goldwyn’s stars, Mae Marsh, Geraldine Farrar, and Madge Kennedy.

Just as California’s “Hollywood” studios were scattered far beyond the confines of that locality, so the name of Fort Lee (now generic in its own way) was often stretched to include such outlying facilities as Herbert Brenon’s Ideal studio in Hudson Heights, Kalem’s open-air stages in Cliffside Park, and the impressive studio built by E. K. Lincoln at Grantwood. Pathé, which had discovered the advantages of Fort Lee even before it constructed its Jersey City studio in 1910, continued to return to the Palisades, especially when filming Pearl White’s cliffhanger serials.

The last of the great Fort Lee studios, the Paragon, was built just south of Universal in 1915 by Jules Brulatour. Maurice Tourneur was a partner in the Paragon, and it was here that he made A Girl’s Folly, Poor Little Rich Girl, and The Blue Bird. Later it became the New Jersey headquarters of Famous Players-Lasky, and eventually of Selznick Pictures. In fact, Selznick’s would be the last traditional studio operation in Fort Lee: after a series of political, economic, and even environmental pressures forced out most other producers in 1918, only Selznick remained and prospered. By the early 1920s he controlled 2/3 of the studio space in Fort Lee, as well as the Biograph stages across the river in the Bronx.

Unfortunately, Selznick himself was out of business by 1923, and the last silent films shot in the borough were independent productions featuring stars like Richard Barthelmess and Barbara La Marr. Jules Brulatour single-handedly kept the Paragon studio open for his protégée, Hope Hampton. But while most accounts of Fort Lee film history end here, a few of the “old” studios saw new life in the early years of sound. Several stages were soundproofed and made available to independent producers, including racial, religious, and ethnic minorities ignored by the majors. Instead of French, the languages now heard on the stages were more likely to be Italian, Yiddish, or Croatian. Ambitious feature films were shot here by Mormon interests, as well as race film producers like Oscar Micheaux (who had already worked in Fort Lee during the silent era). W. C. Fields, Edgar G. Ulmer, and Harry Langdon all made films here during the early 1930s, or at least tried to. The collapse of film production in the East in 1932, and the general economic depression, left the laboratories and storage vaults as the only vestige of this industry still standing. Today, Fort Lee Film Storage still holds nitrate film in an enormous building put up by Jules Brulatour more than 80 years ago.

While filmmaking in Fort Lee did not strictly precede similar activity in “Hollywood”, this was the first industrial location in America completely dominated by the producing and printing of motion pictures. For a time, cultural critics seemed fascinated by this “film town” on the Palisades, where the movies had supplanted all other commercial activity. But as the studios, and the producing entities that operated them, suddenly entered the dark hole of “orphan cinema”, even historians lost interest. Fifty years ago, Theodore Huff was pretty much alone when he wrote of Fort Lee as “Hollywood’s predecessor”. Did the American film industry really learn anything from Fort Lee? Given the current interest in the “transitional era” of American cinema, this year’s centennial would seem to provide a convenient moment for reassessment.
" – RICHARD KOSZARSKI

Dziga Vertov III, GCM Sacile 2004


Photo not from Dziga Vertov. Pervoe Maia v Moskve, 1923. Демонстрация на Красной площади в Москве 1 Мая 1923 г. From: http://www.retromap.ru/show_pid.php?pid=15643

I did not see this show because it overlapped with the film concert of D. W. Griffith's Home, Sweet Home, but I copy the program notes here for the sake of completeness.

DZIGA VERTOV III
Grand piano: Stephen Horne
Cinema Ruffo, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 10 Oct 2004

Prog. 3 (78’)

PERVOE MAIA V MOSKVE / [IL 1° MAGGIO A MOSCA / THE 1ST OF MAY IN MOSCOW] (Proletkino, USSR 1923)
Person in charge of filming: Dziga Vertov; ph: Piotr Novitsky; 35 mm, 367 m., 18’ (18 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "If programs 1 and 2 covered Vertov’s work in 1918-1919 — the worst years of the civil war in Russia — then program 3 is a sampling of genres in which Vertov worked and the subjects he tackled in the first half of the 1920s, the years of peace and relative well-being triggered by NEP (the New Economic Policy, tolerant of small businesses and market-regulated agriculture).
On the surface, not many things shown in the films that Vertov was making after 1920 look strikingly different from what we have seen already. Does Moscow as filmed on the 1st of May in 1923 (now known as May Day, then as International Workers Day) look very different from the way it looked on the same day in 1918 — as we remember it from Kino-Week No. 1? The same flag-carrying crowds cross Red Square, a familiar globe symbolizing the unity of the workers drives by on a truck, and a military parade is reviewed by the perpetual (though not permanent) Leon Trotsky. An attentive eye, however, will notice the signs of the times: the absence of Lenin (who saw in his last May Day bedridden), or the presence of an anti-fascist banner."

"But the main news of the day, its main attraction, was airplanes — the subject that occupies the last third of the film. Not that there were many people in Russia in 1923 who had ever seen an airplane, but my guess is that most would have seen one only in the distant skies. Here the plane is close by, first sitting in Red Square, then showing how it can take off and land. 1923 was the take-off year for Soviet civil aviation. Airplanes were in. Vladimir Mayakovsky wrote poems about "flying proletarians", and Aleksandr Rodchenko was busy designing covers for books about aviation and logos for Dobrolet (the volunteer association for the support of Soviet aviation). And judging from the movies he made this year Dziga Vertov too was not immune to this craze.
" – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

DAESH VOZDUKH / [EVVIVA L’ARIA / YOU GIVE US THE AIR!] (Goskino, USSR 1923) [Secondo e terzo numero speciale / Special Issues 2 & 3]
Numero speciale 2 / Special Issue 2: Leader: Dziga Vertov; ph: Mikhail Kaufman.
Numero speciale 3 / Special Issue 3: Leader: Dziga Vertov; ph: Ivan Beliakov; intertitles & diagrams produced by: Ivan Beliakov.
35 mm, 2 rulli / reels (2a & 3), 560 m., 29’ (18 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "The film Daesh vozdukh! (You Give us the Air!) consists of three "special issues" dedicated to airplanes. The two included in this program are of interest not only to those who like to watch vintage aircraft in action, but also to us, the studentsof theatre and film. Issue 2 begins with the record of an avant-garde theatre performance which I fancy to be a Meyerhold production, but it will take a theatre historian to verify this. The performance takes place in a vast open-air countryside location, which may have served as an airport in 1923. Groups of spectators are seated freely on the grass, while the action evolves both in their midst and on a special elevation which serves as an open stage."

"The action: the story of the two revolutions of 1917 — the fall of the monarchy (February) and the fall of the bourgeois republic (October) — is presented in a grotesque key. The actor impersonating the last Russian tsar, Nicholas II, is reading out the Act of Abdication. As he does so, he is shown squatting on a giant chamber-pot, on which is quoted the words "freedom of assembly, liberty of conscience, freedom of the press". It may be a coincidence, or the work of a copycat, but it is still worth mentioning that a similar (if not the same) scene — the tsar on a chamber-pot — is known to have been part of Vsevolod Meyerhold’s 1923 production Zemlya dybom (Earth Rampant). A procession representing the "bourgeoisie" and "officers" crosses the viewing space and enters the stage. Then we see "the people" attacking the stage, as its former owners (some on horseback) desperately try to retain control of it. Note the huge movable screens used to enhance the dynamic of the battle — a distinctive device of the Soviet Constructivist stage."

"The third special issue of You Give us the Air! (274 m.) starts with credits specifying which of the two kinoc brothers is responsible for what. Dziga Vertov is credited as the supervisor (rukovoditel) of the production, Mikhail Kaufman as the cinematographer and editor. I know the Giornate audience needs no guidance in appreciating editing and camerawork — the only thing I want to remind them of is that this is 1923, so Kaufman’s exercise in rhythmical montage and his clear, not to say geometrical, shot compositions comes one year before Kuleshov’s Mr. West and two years before Eisenstein’s Strike.
" – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

GOSKINOKALENDAR / [CINECALENDARIO DI STATO / STATE KINO-CALENDAR] (Goskino, USSR 1923)
Dir: Dziga Vertov; rel: 6.1923; 35 mm, 142 m., 7’ (18 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

GOSKINOKALENDAR / [CINECALENDARIO DI STATO / STATE KINO-CALENDAR] NO. 20 (Goskino, USSR 1924)
Dir: Dziga Vertov; 35 mm, 159 m., 8’ (18 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "Alongside thematic pictures, two periodical newsreels kept Vertov busy in the first half of the 1920s. One was his famous Kino-Pravda (1922-1925), the other, the somewhat more obscure Goskinokalendar [State Kino-Calendar], which appeared from April 1923 to May 1925. Kino-Pravda (which we are going to show in full) was the more ambitious of the two — it was cinematically experimental, had a political edge, and was made to be noticed and discussed. And discussed it was."

"State Kino-Calendar was more of a quickie. Its task (reflected in its subtitle, "Daily and Weekly Express Newsreel") was to respond to current events, not so much to interpret them. This task explains its title. Distinct from Kino-Pravda, so named to evoke Pravda, the central newspaper of the Communist Party, State Kino-Calendar was indeed an equivalent of a tear-off calendar — which, in turn, explains why Vertov used tear-off calendar pages as the background for this newsreel’s intertitles. These are small-scale news items — which of course makes them no less interesting for the present-day viewer."

"We cannot afford to show all 57 issues of State Kino-Calendar (miraculously all survive, in relatively good shape), but a selection of four (two now, two later) will help to give us a general idea. For the most part, the events shown in Kino-Calendars are self-explanatory — except for two, which may appear baffling without historical comment. The first issue (June 1923) begins with this title: "Goskino assumes patronage over the Fire-Explosion School (Shkola Ogne-Vzryva)." This phrase, and the rite shown after it, are less arcane than they may seem. Patronage (shefstvo) was a system which required large, well-to-do organizations (in this case, the State movie enterprise Goskino) to serve as a "patron" — sponsor, supporter — of a poor one (in this case, the "Fire-Explosion School" — the sapper school of the Red Army Academy). Patronages (which were mandatory, and assigned from above) were showcased as noble acts of Socialist solidarity — hence, the pompous ceremony, and the fact that Goskino included it in its State Kino-Calendar."

"Later into the film, the viewer is faced with another puzzling title: "Moscow. Red pussy willow. Sunday, 1 April 1923 (19 March, Old Style)." There is nothing arcane about this phrase, either. Pussy-Willow Sunday (Verbnoe voskresenie) in Russia is the same as Palm Sunday in the West (there are lots of pussy-willows and almost no palms in Russia). "Red pussy willow" stands for the Communist, atheist Palm Sunday. What it means is that on that Sunday, instead of going to church to hear the liturgy celebrating Christ’s entrance to Jerusalem, Soviet people are offered a range of secular alternatives. It so happened that in 1923 Pussy-Willow Sunday fell on April 1st, April Fools’ Day according to the Western-style calendar. Hence comic dances and buffoonery presented, of all places, at GUM — the huge department store in the center of Moscow.
" – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

[KINO-PRAVDA (AUSSCHNITTE)] / [CINEVERITÀ (ESTRATTI) / KINO-PRAVDA (EXCERPTS)] (MoMA compilation, 1930s; orig. material Goskino, USSR 1922)
35 mm, 342 m., 16’ (18 fps), Österreichisches Filmmuseum.
Didascalie in inglese / English intertitles.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "The last film in this program can be seen as a trailer, of sorts, for the next one. At the Austrian Film Museum, the source of this print, it is catalogued as Kino-Pravda (Ausschnitte) [Kino-Pravda (Excerpts)] — because it consists of selected subjects from the first 9 issues of Kino-Pravda, pieced together by English titles laid out in the manner of Russian Constructivist titling. This one-reel anthology was edited together for the Museum of Modern Art Film Library in the 1930s, so in a sense it is part of film history itself. According to Jay Leyda’s Kino (1983 edition, p. 161), the Kino-Pravda circulated by the Museum of Modern Art Film Library was a synthesis made from several issues of 1922 found in a New York collection: 1 (June 5), 2 (June 12), 4 (July 1), 4 (July 7), 6 (July 14), 7 (July 25), plus some August items." – YURI TSIVIAN

The Battle of the Sexes (1914, fragment)


D. W. Griffith: The Battle of the Sexes (1914). Only a two minute fragment survives from this original straight drama version. In 1928 Griffith directed a comedy remake.

THE BATTLE OF THE SEXES (Majestic Motion Picture Corp., US 1914)
    Dir.: D. W. Griffith; cast: Donald Crisp, Lillian Gish, Robert Harron, Mary Alden, Owen Moore, Fay Tincher, W. E. Lawrence; 35 mm, frammento / fragment: 131 ft., 2’ (16 fps), George Eastman House.
    English intertitles.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): The Griffith Project 8, 10 Oct 2004
   

Paul Spehr [DWG Project # 503] GCM: "No complete copy of the film is known to exist, but a fragment survives. It is the scene in a dance hall where Mrs. Andrews (Mary Alden), daughter Jane (Lillian Gish), and son John (Robert Harron) discover that Mr. Andrews (Donald Crisp) is having an affair with their neighbor Cleo (Fay Tincher). The sequence is introduced by a text written by an unidentified commentator (probably in the 1940s or 1950s) that explains, incorrectly, that this is “Mr. Griffith’s first pioneer feature”. It credits Harry E. Aitken (Mutual’s former president) as the source for the material. Although short, this is quite a complicated sequence. There are four different camera set-ups, edited into almost a dozen separate cuts. There are two titles (with a DG logo that appears original). It opens with Gish, Harron, and Mary Alden (the mother) settling into a box; their father and Cleo arrive and enter the next box (on the right). Gish and Harron are shocked to see him, but he does not see them because he is entranced with Cleo. Gish restrains Harron from confronting his father, and they decide to take their mother out. She has been talking to someone off-screen and hasn’t seen her husband. As they leave, the father and Cleo come onto the dance floor and the mother sees them. Gish, Harron, and Alden make a quick exit as the scene ends."

"Based on a story by Daniel Carson Goodman, a writer who had joined the Reliance Company’s scenario staff, The Battle of the Sexes was the second multi-reel feature that Griffith started for Mutual, and the first one that he completed. Like The Escape, which was begun earlier, it was an exploration of sex and morality, but unlike its still unfinished counterpart, in The Battle of the Sexes the bad genes, brutality, and venereal disease that plagued the tenements did not play an important role. This was about middle class life, so prurient members of the audience had to content themselves with seduction, adultery, and attempted murder."

"Billy Bitzer, the cameraman on the film, called The Battle of the Sexes a “quickie”. He said it was rushed into production because of a delay in completing The Escape caused by Blanche Sweet’s slow recovery from scarlet fever. The recently expanded and refinanced Mutual conglomerate needed a Griffith-made film. Since November 1913, when it was announced that Griffith was joining the company, Mutual’s publicists Phil Mindil and Hopp Hadley had touted the company’s alliance with the previously anonymous director. They had little trouble arousing interest because the motion picture trade press was already proclaiming that Griffith was the greatest director in the world and that he was responsible for converting movies from entertainment to art. But, with all this fine publicity, Mutual as yet had no “big stuff” to lure audiences into the theatres. To fill the gap, Goodman’s story was rushed into production, with the working title The Single Standard."

"The film was shot sometime in January 1914 at Reliance’s makeshift studio near Union Square in New York City. Camerawork was completed before 27 January, because that was when Griffith and a crew of writers, directors, and players departed New York for warmer and sunnier Los Angeles. Lillian Gish said that The Battle of the Sexes was shot in five days – at least her scenes were finished that quickly. Her story that Bitzer could not shoot a close-up of her because her eyes were so bloodshot is often told to illustrate the “quickie” nature of this film. This occurred, she said, because the hours were long and she had so little sleep. By her account, shooting was completed that same day, after she had a rest. Although the camerawork was done in New York, the final editing may have been finished at the former Kinemacolor studio that Mutual had bought as the Los Angeles base for their Reliance and Majestic companies."

"Terry Ramsaye and others have reported that The Battle of the Sexes was rushed through in order to provide funds for a cash-strapped parent company, but if so, it was a while before the cash began to flow. Although The Battle of the Sexes was finished and in the can as early as February 1914, it was not exhibited until early April 1914, when it opened at Weber’s Theatre, at 29th St. and Broadway in New York City, on a program of Mutual films which included a Sennett comedy and another feature by one of Mutual’s other production companies. Later that month it was among a number of multi-reel Mutual features advertised as available from Continental Feature Film Corp. and “all Mutual Exchanges”. Included in this package were several other titles that Griffith supervised: The Great Leap, Gangsters, The Floor Above, The Dishonored Medal, and The Mountain Rat. The last four were made after The Battle of the Sexes. In addition to Griffith’s films, Continental also offered features produced by Ince, Sennett, Thanhouser, and the American Film Company. The ad for this package in Mutual’s house organ, Reel Life magazine (25 April 1914), singled out The Battle of the Sexes, or The Single Standard as “staged by that Genius of the Photodrama, Mr. D. W. Griffith”. Later ads proclaimed that it was the “greatest domestic heart-interest drama ever produced”, and that it was released in five reels even though “the vital material would have made eight, but that isn’t Griffith’s way”."

"There was no explanation for the delay in releasing this and several other multi-reel films produced by Griffith. In the case of The Battle of the Sexes, it may have been because Griffith was not satisfied with the results. It is also possible that the company was leery of launching their new director with subject matter that might offend some of the potential audience. But these are only suppositions. A more plausible explanation is that Mutual was searching for a way to reach the appropriate mass market in a consistently profitable way. The company had a network of regional exchanges that contracted with exhibitors to take a program of one- and two-reel films made by the several production companies that made up the Mutual organization. This was similar to the distribution pattern established by the Motion Picture Patents Company and also adopted by Universal Pictures. The parent company set a schedule for releasing the films made by the production members and fed them to the exhibitors on a schedule. The exhibitor knew that on Monday there would be single-reel productions made by Reliance, Keystone, and American; Tuesday by Majestic, Beauty, and Thanhouser; and so on. It was a system that ensured a stream of fresh new productions for exhibitors,  and guaranteed exhibitions (and rental fees) for producers."

"The multi-reel films that Griffith wanted to make, as well as those being made by Ince, Thanhouser, and American Film Co., did not fit this programming package. They were too long to program in the small theatres that showed the one- and two-reel films, and because they cost more to make they had to be shown in theatres that had more seats, and where audiences would pay more than five or ten cents. Although larger theatres wanted to show longer films, there was no system to distribute them, so films were booked title-by-title as they became available. As Griffith completed new features, Mutual searched for a way to control the distribution in order to ensure a steady income for their new product. As a step in this direction, Mutual set up two new distributing organizations, Continental Feature Film Corporation, headquartered at 29 Union Square, and Western Import Co., 71 West 23rd St., New York. Continental handled sales in the United States; Western Import was actually an export company designed to distribute Mutual films in Europe and other foreign locations. The films were also available through Mutual Exchanges. To stimulate business, Mutual contracted with Weber’s Theatre in New York to exhibit their longer productions, and began building a network of urban theatres that would show their multi-reel films on a regular basis."

"The Battle of the Sexes was the first feature film that Lillian Gish and Owen Moore made at Mutual, but it was not their first multi-reel feature. In 1913 Owen Moore appeared in Caprice with his then-wife, Mary Pickford. Gish had a small role in Judith of Bethulia, and was featured in at least two of the multi-reel films that Biograph was producing for Klaw and Erlanger, although they had not been released yet. In a review published in Mutual’s Reel Life (25 April 1914), Ada Patterson characterized Gish’s role as that of a “child woman” and found the “dawning comprehension of her father’s weakness” gripping. The part of Cleo, the femme fatale, was Fay Tincher’s first work for Griffith, and even though the part was very serious her comic ability impressed Griffith, and most of the rest of her career was as a comedienne."

"Just before release the title was changed from The Single Standard to The Battle of the Sexes – a move from the relatively bland to the slightly racier, indicating that Griffith or Mutual was aware that audiences were more interested in sex than standards. Even though this production was a “quickie”, it seems to have stuck in Griffith’s mind, because he remade it in 1928.
" – Paul Spehr [DWG Project # 503] GCM

Film concert Home, Sweet Home (Neil Brand's band, GCM Sacile 2004)


D. W. Griffith: Home, Sweet Home (1914). Henry B. Walthall (John Howard Payne), Lillian Gish (sweetheart), Josephine Crowell (mother).

EVENTO MUSICALE

HOME, SWEET HOME (Majestic Motion Picture Co. / Reliance Motion Picture Co., US 1914)
    Dir.: D. W. Griffith; cast: Henry B. Walthall, Josephine Crowell, Lillian Gish; 35 mm, 4118 ft, 65’ (16–18 fps: vedi nota / see note), The Museum of Modern Art.
    English intertitles.
    Live musical accompaniment arranged by Neil Brand following the musical indications within the film. Music performed by: Neil Brand (grand piano), Günter A. Buchwald (violin), Romano Todesco (accordion), Denis Biason (guitar), Lorena Favot (vocals).
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): The Griffith Project 8, 10 Oct 2004.

Note 1: The 35 mm print screened at the festival appears to have an episode card out of order. The card “Part 4 (Episode 3)” incorrectly pops up in the middle of action in Part 3 (Episode 2). This misplacement is presumably an error in the negative, as there is no splice where this particular card is located. Our thanks to Anne Morra for drawing this to our attention.

Note 2: “Mr. Griffith suggests that the running time for the picture should be: – 16 min. for the first reel, 14 min. to 15 min. for the second reel, and from 13 min. to 14 min. for each of the other reels. The last reel, however, should be run slowly from the beginning of the allegorical part to the end.” (Reel Life, 13 June 1914, p. 3)

Ben Brewster (GCM, DWG Project # 509): "Most commentators on Home, Sweet Home note that, as a multi-episode film, it anticipates Intolerance. More knowledgeable ones note also the analogy with the 1909 Biograph one-reeler Pippa Passes. As in the latter, a series of stories involving different characters are linked by the fact that they find their resolution in chance hearings of the same song. However, in Pippa Passes, a character walking about a city singing in the morning provides the link that anchors all the episodes into a single diegetic space and time (though Griffith does not try to reproduce the unifying series of subtle links of Browning’s play, among Pippa and the various characters); in Home, Sweet Home, by contrast, the only spatial-temporal linkage is that all the stories are set in a cultural universe that knows the famous song by John Howard Payne (lyrics) and Henry Bishop (music). Moreover, it is the theme of the song that counts, rather than the innocence of the singer (as in Pippa), which brings it closer to the thematic unification of Intolerance. But the fact that the stories follow one another, rather than being intercut, obviously makes it closer to the earlier film than the later one."

"Differences underscore the parallels. Thus, three different instruments, an accordion, a guitar, and a violin, play the music in each episode (notably, only the guitarist seems also to sing the words, so the unifier is really Bishop’s music, not Payne’s lyrics, but the tune is so closely associated with the words, or at least the theme of the song, and the song, words and melody, is usually thought of as Payne’s, so the discrepancy is not very important). The three settings contrast three characteristic American environments – a Western mining camp, a seacoast fishing village, and a big city (an agrarian moment is notably absent). Finally, where two of the stories have unalloyed happy endings, with successful marriages blessed with many children, a third is much more ambiguous: the song fails to deter one of the brothers who hate from killing his sibling, so its later success in preventing the mother’s suicide is not an unmixed happy end. Interestingly, the Moving Picture World summary places this episode third and last, whereas the surviving print and the reviews on release indicate that it should go second. If it were in final place, it would bring the film overall closer to the characteristic ambiguity of Griffith’s later Biograph films (such as The Adopted Brother), where the film ends happily insofar as the hero and heroine survive and are perhaps united in marriage, but this is achieved by the destruction of another family group or other innocent characters. The MPW summary also omits the Epilogue. If the Epilogue showing Payne’s redemption was in fact an afterthought, the film as originally conceived would have been a gloomy one indeed."

"Another way of looking at the multi-episode format is as a transitional form between the one-reel film and the feature, a unification by theme of the variety program of short films that constituted the bill in a typical Mutual-served movie house – in this case comprising a two-reel costume drama, a comedy Western, a melodrama, and a society drama. The lengths of the episodes bear this out. In the current print, Episode One is 986 feet long, Episode Two 953 feet, and Episode Three 761 feet (as if it were a split-reeler, with the Epilogue at 80 feet). In Edward Wagenknecht and Anthony Slide’s The Films of D. W. Griffith (p. 41), Slide even claims of Episode One: “Interestingly, prior to the first screening of Home, Sweet Home, this sequence had been released, on April 18, 1914, as a separate story, titled Apple Pie Mary, but with a slightly different plot line. Instead of returning to marry Mae Marsh, Harron (here called Burford Dane) marries Miriam Cooper, and only visits Mae Marsh again on her deathbed, when she forgives him ‘with a sad smile playing about her lips and dies with his baby playing at the bedside’.” Unfortunately, despite the circumstantial nature of this comment, I can find no trace of this release; it was certainly not on the regular Mutual program for 18 April, or any other nearby date. However, it does at first sight seem plausible that an episode from Home, Sweet Home might have been released as a separate one-reeler, just as the different parts of Intolerance were released as separate features. If Home, Sweet Home were Griffith’s first feature-length film, the temptation to think of it as a cautious step towards the feature in this way would be almost irresistible. However, he had made at least three features before this (Judith of Bethulia, The Battle of the Sexes, and The Escape), each of which is a straightforward single-narrative film, so inexperience cannot be the explanation in this case. And the individual episodes are not, if examined closely, very like Griffith’s one-reel films."

"By 1913, Griffith constructed these films by combining different plotlines, integrating them by the device he took further than any of his contemporaries, alternating editing. This can be seen partly as a response to the problem of making so many films. There are a relatively limited number of situations suitable for a short dramatic film, and one way of extending the number so that each film is somewhat different from the others is to combine them. Thus, The Adopted Brother has one storyline concerning the hero’s persecution by the family’s full-blooded son, and a second concerning the hero’s restoration of a drunken writer’s self-respect. The two are brought together by the writer sacrificing himself to save the hero from a murderous attack by his brother. Or take The Voice of the Child (1912), whose main plotline is virtually identical to that of Home, Sweet Home’s Episode Three: A husband is so wrapped up in business that his neglected wife is vulnerable to the seduction of another man, in this case the husband’s friend rather than her own. But the resolution involves an elaborate secondary plotline, where the friend, to persuade the wife of her husband’s infidelity, uses a stolen photograph, which the couple’s daughter sees him slip into the husband’s coat pocket, thus enabling the daughter to resolve the couple’s dissension fully once her appeal has induced her mother not to abandon the family."

"The functions of this second plotline in The Voice of the Child are fulfilled by the double overhearing of the song in Home, Sweet Home’s episode “The Marriage of Roses and Lilies”. The introduction of the song is more carefully prepared in this episode than in the others, with byplay between the musician and the homesick boy in the first hearing, and between the musician and the maid in the second, but there is not any real story connected with it. In Episode Two of Home, Sweet Home, there seems to be something much more like an intervening story, but it is so underdeveloped as to be incomprehensible. The first son’s attack on his brother is motivated by the second son’s receiving money from a man, but we never discover why. The older brother’s first attempt is foiled when the same man reappears with an apparently urgent errand for the second son to run, which he reluctantly agrees to, thus removing him from his brother’s reach for a time. We then see him taking a cheery farewell of this man as he strides towards the family shack and his doom. Possibly there was once more footage to explain this secondary sequence of actions, but there is no obvious moment where such footage seems to be missing. Similarly, in the film’s first episode, Robert Winthrop’s business in the East, which motivates his separation from Mary and extended contact with the Eastern girl, is not explained. It looks as if he receives a legacy, putting him into a class above Mary, and thus motivating the letter indicating that there is a gulf between them. But this is never elaborated, and so must remain surmise."

"Another characteristic of the later Biographs is the use of symbolic props, often with ironic reversals built into them. Perhaps the most famous example of this is the heroine’s shawl in The Painted Lady (1912), but one might also mention the mouse in The Lady and the Mouse (1913), the son’s collar and tie in Home Folks (1912), and many others. There are such props in Home, Sweet Home, but they are underdeveloped. Thus the mementos that Robert and Mary exchange in Episode One are amusing, but little comes of them; Mary’s wearing of Robert’s glasses when he returns to her at the end has no function except for the comic effect on her appearance, and the picture postcard she gives him never reappears. The roses and lilies that are mentioned in the title of Episode Three serve as the thinnest of symbolic parallels, blooming in profusion side by side in the wedding shots, and their petals dropping separately in hall and sitting-room in the scenes of the couple’s dissension two years later. Only the husband even takes any notice of them when he idly tries to restore one of the fallen rose petals to its flower before he falls asleep in an armchair on returning from his club."

"This thinness also characterizes the Prologue and Epilogue. The main structuring device, the series of cutaways from the story of Payne’s descent in Europe and North Africa to his mother and sweetheart waiting patiently back home, has no consequences. It is true that the film does exploit the full range of Griffith’s use of such cutaways; sometimes it is clear that Payne is thinking of his sweetheart when there is a cut to her (e.g., when he is composing the song); at others she is farthest from his thoughts, and is brought in as a commentary for the viewer (e.g., when he is being seduced by the Worldly Woman). She, on the other hand, is always thinking of him, expecting his imminent arrival for tea, having premonitions of his downfall when the parallel scene is one of disgrace or sin; but thinking of her lost love is the only thing she has to do in the film. Not until the Epilogue does her story actually link with his, when she conjures the demons and carries him off to heaven. Robert Henderson (in D. W. Griffith: His Life and Work, p. 144) suggests that “the film was notable for its increasingly complex use of technical devices [and] refinement of parallel editing”, but to me it seems a step backwards from the technical achievements of the Biograph films. All in all, Home, Sweet Home cannot be counted as one of Griffith’s more successful films. If, as all the biographies claim, The Battle of the Sexes was simply a potboiler made to fill Aitken’s pressing schedules for Reliance product, Home, Sweet Home seems no more than a showcase for his new company of actors.
" – Ben Brewster [DWG Project # 509, GCM]

AA: A rewarding and essential musical presentation arranged by Neil Brand, following the original instructions of the film, largely based on variations of "Home, Sweet Home" (1823) written by John Howard Payne and composed by Henry Bishop. A song-driven silent film and an omnibus film, each episode inspired by the song. A film print with black levels missing.

The Heart of the World



THE HEART OF THE WORLD (Rhombus Media, CA 2000)
    Dir/sc: Guy Maddin; prod: Niv Fichman, Judy Shapiro, Jennifer Weiss; ph/ed: Guy Maddin, deco dawson; mus: Georgy Sviridov, suite dalla partitura di / from the film score Vremya, vperyod! (Tempo, avanti! / Time, Forward!; 1967); des: Réjean Labrie; art dir: Olaf Dux; cost: Meg McMillan; cast: Leslie Bais, Caelum Vatnsdal, Shaun Balbar, Greg Klymkiw, Tammy Gillis, Carson Natrass; 35 mm, 540 ft, 6’ (24 fps), b/w, sound, Toronto International Film Festival Group.
    English intertitles.

"A 6-minute short originally commissioned as part of the Preludes series for the 25th anniversary of the Toronto International Film Festival, this multiple award-winning short film – heralded by many critics as “one of the best films of the year, regardless of length” – is a loving parody of the silent Soviet cinema of Sergei Eisenstein and Vsevolod Pudovkin, and of silent movie melodrama in general."

"Evoking classic silent films, early horror films, chapter serials, and propaganda reels, The Heart of the World tells the mythic story of Anna, a state scientist, and the two brothers who vie for her love while she tries to save the world from the evil Capitalist, Akmatov."

"With a reported 850 separate edits in less than 6 minutes, the film’s rhythmic use of intertitles and sentence fragments creates a forceful visual poetry. Possessed of Maddin’s typically casual morbidity and uniquely avant-garde sense of humour, The Heart of the World is the most concise – and perhaps most successful – articulation of Maddin’s signature cinematic genius."

"The Heart of the World received a number of awards and accolades in Canada, the United States, and Europe, and has very quickly become considered one of the best short films ever made. It scored a Genie Award for Live Action Short Drama and was named the year’s Best Experimental Film by the National Society of Film Critics (USA).
" – http://www.filmreferencelibrary.ca (Toronto International Film Festival Group website

"Canadian director Guy Maddin’s six-minute music-video-cum-Eisensteinian-sci-fi-workout, should be seen at all costs. Seeming to double as an aptly hyper history of the world (or maybe just of movies), The Heart of the World almost subliminally relates the tale of two brothers – a “youth mortician” (Shaun Balbar) and an actor (Caelum Vatnsdal) playing Jesus Christ – who are both in love with the heroic Anna (Leslie Bais), a “state scientist” studying the Earth’s core and discovering that the world is at serious risk of death by heart failure. (And no wonder, with all that action!) Further propelled by a suitably frantic Soviet orchestral score, the insane rush of scratched, jumpy images compels you to keep your eyes as wide as possible for the entire six minutes – even though you couldn’t dream of absorbing it all even after a dozen viewings. Harder to miss is Maddin’s message: How contrived, how ridiculous, and how goddamn exciting this silly medium of ours!" – Rob Nelson, citypages.com (website, Minneapolis-St. Paul)