Thursday, November 19, 2026

You Can See Everything

 
Nathan Fielder & Lance Oppenheim: You Can See Everything (US 2026). Elizabeth Holmes and Nathan Fielder.

Non-fiction with enactments.
    US © 2026 Nice Playground LLC. PC: A24 / Blow Out Productions / To Be Formed. P: Maggie Ambrose, Tatiana Bears, Jack Davis, Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim.
    D: Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim. DP: David Bolen – digital – colour – 1,33:1 – source format: Arriraw 4.6K, 3,4K – master format: digital intermediate – release format: DCP. PD: Alex DiGerlando. AD: Molly Mikula (supervising), Jonathan Mosca. Set dec: Rebecca Meis DeMarco. Cost: Katina Danabassis., Makeup: Stephanie Pasicov. Hair: Kerrie Smith. Contact lens technician: Genesis Kuhl. M: Ari Balouzian. S: Paul Hsu. ED: Adam Locke-Norton.
    Clip: "Who's on First?" from The Abbott and Costello Show, S1, E24, The Actors' Home (1953). A & C performed the routine hundreds of times between 1938 and 1956.
    Featuring: Elizabeth Holmes, Billy Evans, Christian Holmes IV, Noel Holmes, William Evans, Invicta Evans.
    Featuring: Gary Wilmes (A24 Executive), Phillip Andre Botello (A24 Executive), Nick Choksi (friend), Manik Choksi (friend).
    Featuring: Nathan Fielder, Lance Oppenheim.
    C: Amanda Seyfried (Elizabeth Holmes), Christopher Abbott (Billy Evans).
    174 min
    Loc: Del Mar, San Diego County, CA (Holmes and Evans's rented home); Bryan, Texas; Los Angeles, CA; California; Texas.
    Festival premiere: 6 Sep 2026 Telluride Film Festival.
    US premiere: 16 Oct 2026.
    Finnish premiere: 20 Nov 2026 – distributor: SF Film Finland Oy – Finnish / Swedish subtitles: Vesa Kujala / Jukka Nieminen.
    Viewed at Finnkino Tennispalatsi 2, Helsinki, 19 Nov 2026.

A24 OFFICIAL SYNOPSIS: "Thirty-four days before she’s sent to prison, notorious Silicon Valley founder Elizabeth Holmes invites a skeptical film crew to document her every move. What begins as an intimate portrait of an enigmatic felon becomes a mind-bending three-year journey into the abyss."
    
AA: WHO?

The keyword is "who?".

"Whodunit" ("who has done it?") is a classic form of detective fiction. It is the story of an investigation to find out who committed the crime. The guilty one is usually exposed by the detective in the finale.

Dostoevsky and Hitchcock were interested of a mystery of another kind. We already know who did it, but for them, that is not the conclusion, only the beginning. The question "who has done it?" indeed remains, but switches to another, more profound level. 

The extraordinary You Can See Everything is such a whodunit. The directors Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim deal with issues of awareness and responsibility, self and representation, biases of personality, traumatization from sexual abuse, neurodiversity and mental health.

However, this three-hour case study is so full of interesting revelations that there is not much time to go deep even into aspects of the greatest gravity.

In their investigation, Fielder & Oppenheim stage a Mousetrap moment just like Prince Hamlet in his own detective story at the Elsinore Castle when he turned into a theatre director to solve the crime. 

In You Can See Everything, the revelatory performance is Abbott and Costello's "Who's on First?". The fun is based on a misunderstanding (you see, the first baseman's name is Who).

Elizabeth Holmes falls into the trap. She seems unable to register a double meaning. It also seems that she, although a sunny person always ready to smile and laugh, has difficulty in getting a joke or understanding the absurd. She does not recognize the famous comedy routine.

HALL OF MIRRORS

"They're not playing me. They're playing a character I created", becomes a key quotation from Elizabeth Holmes, disputed by her but insisted on by the New York Times.

Undeniably, Holmes was able to create a public persona so persuasive that a multi-billion-dollar blood-testing industry was based on it. You Can See Everything is a study in charisma, the X factor, the mind-boggling phenomenon essential in explaining the rise of the very stable genius into the White House.

Holmes invites the documentary film team to her home, with all access and total transparency, to show that she has nothing to hide, that she is not lying.

Then meta-narratives begin. Holmes has become a public figure, famous in documentaries and drama series. She is completely baffled when she watches the enactments.

After Holmes goes to prison, Amanda Seyfried, who portrayed her in the series, enters the movie. A new level of complexity, a meta meta level, is introduced. And yet another level when Seyfried starts to play an updated version of Holmes in the documentary we are currently watching.

BILLY EVANS MANIPULATIONS

A parallel set of  Elizabeth Holmes presentations is stage-managed by her partner and the father of her children, Billy Evans, who has her power of attorney. Before Holmes goes to prison, a deepfake 3-D likeness is created for holograms. Evans also controls her social media account and impersonates her on X. He licenses her likeness for billboards. It seems as if he makes her digital avatar available for online porn.

Amanda Seyfried, who had conducted a profound study of Holmes for her television series interpretation, finds the Billy Evans manipulation out of character. Confronted by her, Evans loses his temper and is exposed as a toxic misogynist and a dedicated Charlie Kirk follower in front of the camera. He threatens Seyfried by saying that he carries a gun and knows people who "can do shit" "to harm people".

Elizabeth Holmes is oblivious, ignorant or indifferent to all this, including to Billy Evans manipulating her financial affairs. Holmes carries debts of hundreds of millions which she can never pay back. Money has ceased to matter.

REFLECTION AND REPRESENTATION

Fielder & Oppenheim enter deeper and deeper into the complexities of reality and illusion, reflection and representation, sincerity and lying, truth and fiction.

Erving Goffman wrote in 1956 a classic study in social psychology called The Presentation of Self in Everyday Life. He compared social interaction with a theatrical performance. Onstage we appear before the audience and offer positive self-concepts and desired impressions. Backstage we drop these public roles and are ourselves.

Elizabeth Holmes has invited the film-makers backstage for 24 hours / 7 days, to demonstrate that there is no role being played, that we see her true self.

HONESTY AND SINCERITY

Holmes has been convicted for several counts of criminal fraud, and she has been called "the most manipulative person ever", but she insists that she never lies.

"I don't know if I know".

It seems that she has experienced a dissociation, outsourcing a part of herself to partners in crime while sustaining a self-image of honesty and integrity.

In public and in private (except with her children) she seems like a doll, a robot, a weird creature, living in a parallel universe. "She sees the world differently", says Billy Evans.

Elizabeth Holmes lives in absolute denial. She lets no doubt, no hesitation crack the hard shell. The theme of denial is of course a keyword for the world today. The United States and Europe carry monumental, impossible mountains of debt. To say nothing about the unsustainable way in which we live, doomed to ecocatastrophe. 

Elizabeth Holmes is frozen to a Wile E. Coyote moment.

Like us.

THE HIDDEN TRAUMA

For a fleeting moment we meet the most genuine people of the movie (next to the children): the parents of Elizabeth Holmes. 

Nathan Fielder would like to spend more time with them, but he is prevented from doing so by the ever-manipulative Billy Evans.

Yet we learn that her father does not believe his daughter is guilty. What he says is that everything changed for Elizabeth when she was raped at Stanford University at the age of 19 in 2003 and subsequently experienced violent sexual abuse with her would-be protector Ramesh "Sunny" Balwani. The Stanford assault did not lead to legal consequences. Holmes stopped attending classes, left Stanford and founded Theranos.

CODA

Behind the prison fence, Elizabeth Holmes enjoys a family visit with her children and Billy. Is the love real? I believe it's real unless proven otherwise. We are left reflecting on the mystery woman. I think I can understand her and sympathize with her as a human being while condemning the criminal behavior. She is both a victim and a villain.

Fielder & Oppenheim make sense of an incredibly complex story. Many questions remain, including ones on exploitation. 

I started with "Who?"

I end with "Who exploits whom?"

No comments: