Friday, October 15, 2004

Kleider machen Leute / Clothes Make the Man (1921) (fragment)


Hans Steinhoff: Kleider machen Leute / Clothes Make the Man (1921) with Hermann Thimig.

The Steinhoff Project
KLEIDER MACHEN LEUTE / BRŸUTIGAM AUF KREDIT (Volo Film, AT 1921)
Clothes Make the Man.
Unreleased in Finland.
    Dir/prod: Hans Steinhoff; sc: Hans Steinhoff, based on the short story “Kleider machen Leute” di / by Gottfried Keller; titles: Homunculus [Robert Weill]; ph: Anton Pucher; des: Hans Neumann (interiors), Hans Dostel, Robert Reich; cost: Karl Alexander Wilke; title des: Mayblond [Michael Maybaum], based on ideas by Hans Steinhoff;
    cast: Hermann Thimig, Dora Kaiser, Hugo Thimig, Thea Oesy, Wilhelm Schmidt, Franz Kammauf, Cornelius Kirschner, Eugen Günther, Fritz Straßny, Josef Moser, Victor Kutschera, Hans Thimig;
    premiere: 29.12.1921, UT Kurfürstendamm, Berlin; orig. length: 1893 m; fragment [restored Act 2 only]: 35 mm, 335 m, 13’ (22 fps), tinted & toned, Bundesarchiv-Filmarchiv.
    German intertitles.
    In the presence of Horst Claus
    Grand piano: Donald Sosin.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fuori quadro  – The Steinhoff Project, 15 Oct 2004

Horst Claus (GCM): "Based on a short story by the 19th-century Swiss author Gottfried Keller about the discrepancy between appearances and reality, the film tells the story of an unemployed, penniless tailor whom the petty bourgeois citizens of the small provincial town of Goldach mistake for an important aristocrat. Having eaten an opulent meal that was practically forced on him by the landlord of the “Hotel zur Waage”, the tailor’s various attempts to sneak away are thwarted by important citizens anxious to meet him in the hope of profiting from his acquaintance. Eventually he ends up in the hotel’s best room having a nightmare about the day's events, leading him up to the gallows."

"Written, directed, and produced by Steinhoff himself, this fragment of his first feature (restored by the Bundesarchiv-Filmarchiv in 1999 from an original nitrate print) reflects its director's lifelong (but rarely realised) ambition to be the auteur of his films. It is an example of the professionalism with which he entered (and continued to work in) the film industry. The reel’s (originally tinted and toned) titles and trick sequences are imaginative, charming, and of a high professional standard. The humorous nightmare sequence nicely contrasts with that of Ivan the Terrible’s horror dream in Steinhoff’s next film, Der Falsche Dimitry (1922). All the location work took place in villages of the Vienna Woods. Though a flop with audiences, the film’s enormous critical success became Steinhoff’s entry ticket to the Berlin film industry. The archive would very much welcome information about any other elements of this film which may survive.
" – Horst Claus (GCM)

AA: I saw this fragment (duration at Zancanaro was 14'21"): innovative camera work and titles, even animation, interesting colour solutions of tinting and toning.

The Lure of Crooning Water


Arthur Rooke: The Lure of the Crooning Water (1920). Photo: Internet Movie Database.

THE LURE OF CROONING WATER (George Clark Productions, GB 1920)
    Dir/prod: Arthur Rooke; sc: Guy Newall, dal romanzo di / from the novel by Marion Hill; ph: Joe Rosenthal, Jr.; des: Charles Dalman; cast: Ivy Duke, Guy Newall, Mary Dibley, Hugh C. Buckler, Arthur Chesney, Lawford Davison, i bambini Hood / the Hood children, Chuh Ah Moy; trade show: 1.1920; 35 mm, 6237 ft, 84’ (20 fps), BFI / National Film and Television Archive.
    Didascalie in inglese / English intertitles.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM) (Asquith e gli altri), 15 Oct 2004.

Bryony Dixon (GCM): "Ivy Duke plays Georgette Verlaine, a sophisticated and jaded city actress suffering from exhaustion who is sent by her doctor friend for a rest cure to a farm in the country, where she causes the farmer, Horace (Guy Newall), to fall in love with her. The tensions between the hard work and simple morals of the rural environment and the excesses of the town are thrown into sharp relief when he later follows her to the city. The setting-up of the romance starts lightly, as she mocks him for his coarseness and he shows his disapproval of her frivolity. This is frequently juxtaposed with the homeliness and drudgery of the farmer’s wife Rachel (Mary Dibley), although the husband and wife seem to exist together happily enough."

"Of Ivy Duke’s charms in the film, historian Rachael Low said that they held “just that touch of refinement and distinction that might cause resentment in a village”, and Duke does indeed play the part with great subtlety. Likewise, Newall’s portrayal of his developing passion for her is beautifully restrained. The pivotal scene takes place in a thunderstorm, prefigured metaphorically in the intertitles: “Rachel didn’t see the storm clouds gathering.” As Rachel comforts the children upstairs, Georgette invades the farmer’s private study. As the lightning flashes, he sneeringly asks if she is afraid. “ No,” she says, “I want someone to revel in it with me”. Bodies move closer; he follows her off screen; fade to black. A great movie moment, even if the lightning is a bit cheap."

"This was one of the first George Clark/Guy Newall feature collaborations. It was made with very little money, and cramped studio space, but ironically this forced the team (with Rooke directing and Joe Rosenthal, Jr. on camera) to shoot as much as possible on location, greatly to the benefit of the final film.
" Bryony Dixon (GCM)

AA: The theme of the collapsing diva reminds me of Persona. Crooning Water is the name of a place, of which it is said that it is "the back of beyond". (A Finnish expression would be "tuppukylä").

Thursday, October 14, 2004

Big Red Ridin' Hood


Leo McCarey: Big Red Ridin' Hood (1925). Jimmy Jump (Charley Chase) uses every opportunity to read "Little Red Riding Hood", even during a car chase. My screenshot from YouTube.

BIG RED RIDIN’ HOOD (Hal Roach, US 1925)
Big Red Ridinghood [the title credit]
    Dir: Leo McCarey; prod: Hal Roach; cast: Charley Chase, Helen Gilmore, Richard Daniels, Martha Sleeper; 35 mm, 295 m, 13’ (20 fps), Lobster Films.
    English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Günter Buchwald.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Goodnight, Silents, 14 Oct 2004.

Serge Bromberg (GCM): "Jimmy Jump, a professional translator, is commissioned to do a Swedish version of “Little Red Riding Hood”. Having no money to buy the book, he thinks up a thousand tricks to read the story without spending a cent. A delectable 2-reeler from the team of Leo McCarey and Charley Chase, the forgotten greats of the Roach Studio." – Serge Bromberg (GCM)

AA: * One of my favourites at the Festival. Charley Chase in great form. Very nice, made just before his very greatest films.

East Is East (1916)


Photo: Internet Movie Database.

EAST IS EAST (Turner Company, GB 1916)
    Dir/prod/sc: Henry Edwards; cast: Henry Edwards, Florence Turner, Edith Evans; trade show: 9.1916; 35 mm, 4787 ft, 71’ (18 fps), BFI / National Film and Television Archive.
    Didascalie in inglese / English intertitles.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (Asquith e gli altri),

Bryony Dixon (GCM): "Edith Evans, an arch ham even in 1916, tries to upstage everyone in this rags-to-riches drama of childhood sweethearts, played with exquisite naturalness by Florence Turner (“The Vitagraph Girl”) and Henry Edwards. This film is the only survivor of several films starring the pair. The influence of Hollywood narrative style is clear. The film is well structured, with an elegance that is not so surprising until you look at the date it was made and its country of origin. The subject, though, is fundamentally British, a familiar theme concerning the impossibility of finding love and fulfilment outside one’s social class. Money is a hindrance, and financial comfort or security brings with it stifling social conventions. As always with these stories, happiness is achieved only through escape to the rose-covered cottage of every Englishman’s dreams."

"Well-worn as the story is, the performances lift the film out of the ordinary (although by 1916 not enough features had been made for it to have really become a cliché). Edwards’ performance in particular is notable for its profound understanding of the spatial qualities of cinema, even with a relatively static camera. Edwards was already an experienced stage and screen actor by this time ­ watch how as an actor he makes us believe in the three-dimensional world we see through the frame. This is much helped by his use of location work in the hop-fields of Kent, where traditionally the working classes of London enjoyed a brief working holiday away from the miseries of the city. The beautiful English rural scenery adds greatly to the film’s charms." Bryony Dixon (GCM)

AA: A social comedy, a satire of class society, with a great sense of humour and social observation, nuance and realistic density. The print is ok. *** Actual duration of the screening 1:15'38" = 76 min.

Chelovek s kinoapparatom / Man With a Movie Camera (GCM Sacile 2004)


Dziga Vertov: Chelovek s kinoapparatom / Man With a Movie Camera (1929). Poster design by the Stenberg brothers (Vladimir Stenberg, Georgi Stenberg), signature "2 Stenberg 2". Photo from IMDb.

DZIGA VERTOV XIV
Grand piano: John Sweeney
Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 14 Oct 2004

Prog. 14 (82’)

Dziga Vertov: Goskinokalendar 47. Photo: Österreichisches Filmmuseum, Collection Dziga Vertov.

GOSKINOKALENDAR 47 / [CINECALENDARIO DI STATO N. 47 / STATE KINO-CALENDAR NO. 47] (Goskino, USSR 1925)
Dir: Dziga Vertov; rel: 2.1925; 35 mm, 160 m, 6’ (24 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.
    AA: Duration of the screening: 5'59".

CHELOVEK S KINOAPPARATOM / L’UOMO CON LA MACCHINA DA PRESA / MAN WITH A MOVIE CAMERA (VUFKU, USSR 1929)
A Film Feuilleton.
Author/Leader: Dziga Vertov; chief ph: Mikhail Kaufman; asst. dir: Elizaveta Svilova; rel: 9.4.1929; lunghezza originale / orig. length: 1839 m; 35 mm, 1785 m, 65’ (24 fps), Nederlands Filmmuseum.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.
    AA: A good print. Duration of the screening: 1:06'+ = 67 min.

CHELOVEK S KINOAPPARATOM / L’UOMO CON LA MACCHINA DA PRESA / MAN WITH A MOVIE CAMERA (VUFKU, USSR 1929)
Rullo / Reel 3, 35 mm, 300 m, 11’ (24 fps), RGAKFD.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.
    AA: Lower and weaker definition than in the previous print. 10'39"12.

Yuri Tsivian (GCM): "Much in agreement with the Productionist movement in art (of which more later), L’uomo con la macchina da presa is a film about film production: it shows a movie being made. But this alone does not make Man with a Movie Camera unique. What does is that the film which Man with a Movie Camera shows being made is Man with a Movie Camera itself. It is as if Man with a Movie Camera had two, even three, identities at once: the film that we are watching, the film which we see being made, and the film that we are shown being shown somewhere else. There are no clear boundaries between the three — or, to be more exact, the boundaries are clear; it is Vertov who keeps teasing us by constantly shifting these boundaries."

"Take the beginning of the film. Man with a Movie Camera begins with a prologue set in a movie theatre. We see what takes place in the projection booth and in the orchestra pit before a movie show, and see people filling the theatre, just as we have filled ours only minutes before. What film have they come to watch? When the projectionist opens a can and prepares to put the film in the projector, we can read the film’s title on the can: "Liudina z aparatem, Ch. 1," [Ukrainian for Man with a Movie Camera, Reel One] — the very reel of the very film we are now watching — but of course, the onscreen Man with a Movie Camera is only going to be shown. Note the fascinating sensation of being "in" and "out" at the same time — it will be key throughout the entire film. We see how the conductor’s baton requests the orchestra’s attention, how the projectionist adjusts the knob of the carbon-arc lamp, how inside the projector two carbon needles come closer together — and as a bright spot of light is formed between the two, the two films — the one we are watching, and the one shown to the onscreen audience — become one. The prologue is over; we are now part of the prologue audience."

"Evidence survives that this illusion — the fusion of two movies and of two movie theatres into one — may have been particularly strong when Man with a Movie Camera was screened on its opening night on 9 April 1929. From Vertov’s instructions for the orchestra, we know that he wanted no music to be heard throughout the prologue — nothing apart from the percussion imitating the "tick-tock of a clock" — the pulse of silence. Only when the conductor on the screen waves his baton and the screen musicians start playing is live music from a real orchestra supposed to join in. If there can be such a thing as musical trompe-l’oeil, this is it."

"Those who have followed our Kino-Pravda shows will have noticed that that self-reflexive quality, that in-or-out ambiguity is not something peculiar to Man with a Movie Camera alone. Recall issues 6 and 9, which begin in a projection booth, showing how a projectionist threads Kino-Pravda 6 and 9 into his projector, or a more recent issue, 18, with its recurring shadow of a man with a movie camera recording what we see. Is this just a Baroque idiosyncrasy, or there is something about Vertov’s time and culture that can help us explain his tendency to expose the "backstage" story behind film images and films?"

"To address this question we would need to connect Man with a Movie Camera to the Left Front [LEF] doctrine known as Productionism [proizvodstevennichestvo], according to which (to summarize this rather sketchy set of ideas), in the future society where everyone works, the work itself — not its end results — will become the aesthetic value. The process will prevail over the object, the production over the product. The future belongs to the art of work, not to works of art.
This was a rather vague theory indeed, but maybe it was exactly due to this vagueness that Productionist ideas became productive for Left-wing cinema and art. It was up to the artist to translate these ideas into practice. Was it not an interesting and challenging task — to make a picture or write a book that would be less concerned with its end value — the book as such, a picture as such — than with the process of their coming into being? Suddenly, such marginal genres as do-it-yourself books for children came into focus. One of these — a 1926 collection of poems under the tell-tale title Samozveri [Self-Animals] by the Productionist writer and theorist Sergei Tretiakov — is so much like Man with a Movie Camera in miniature that it is worth mentioning here. The poems the book includes describe various adventures of people and animals cut out of paper; there are also photographic illustrations which show these adventures enacted by cut-out people and animals (designed, staged, and photographed by the Constructivist artists Aleksandr Rodchenko and Varvara Stepanova). A book as a book — but the reason why its title is "self-animals" is that, in addition to the poems and photographed paper figures, it includes cutting charts, guided by which the little reader can take the scissors, cut out his/her own paper animals, and involve them in new adventures. A model Productionist book: in it, reading and making are treated as one."

"Two major film directors, Vertov and Sergei Eisenstein, tried to apply the Productionist principle in their works. The way Eisenstein interpreted it was to say that his aim was not to produce films, but to produce film spectators. His films, he wrote, were what the hammer was for the factory worker: their aim was to process the mind of the spectator through a series of pre-calculated shocks. Distinct from Eisenstein’s, Vertov’s approach to production art was more of a Constructivist variety — somewhat similar to the Constructivist cut-it-yourself book mentioned above. Truly Constructivist artworks — from Tatlin’s tower to a book for children — are transparent as to their own making, its "construction". This transparency is best described through an architectural metaphor. Normally, after a building has been erected, the builder removes the scaffolding. The Constructivist artists would rather remove the building, but leave the scaffolding intact. Vertov’s movie is of a similar kind — the building of thebuilding is more important than the building built. That Man with a Movie Camera lays bare the process of its own production — from the cameraman and the editor to the projectionist and the orchestra — was consistent both with the principle of Constructivist transparency and with the Productionist doctrine. A true do-it-yourself movie, Man with a Movie Camera puts the making above the made. Each time Man with a Movie Camera is shown, it is made anew. While other movies are made to exist, this one exists to be made."

"You will not easily find a Soviet silent more often shown in the West than Man with a Movie Camera. This film has also been shown before at the Giornate — this film, but not this print. All 35 mm prints of Man with a Movie Camera available in the West have the same defect — they have been printed sound aperture, without adjusting the aspect ratio, which means that a soundtrack-wide area on the left has been lost — and with it, Mikhail Kaufman’s painstakingly achieved frame compositions. The Nederlands Filmmuseum print we are showing is a good full-frame print, whose provenance goes back to the time when Man with a Movie Camera was first shown in The Netherlands. The only trouble with this print is that one shot is missing — the one that shows, point-blank, the moment a baby is being delivered, the most direct manifestation of Vertov’s direct cinema, which may be the reason why it has been censored from the Dutch print. In order to make up for this loss, Reel 3 from the full (and full-frame) print of Man with a Movie Camera preserved at RGAKFD will be shown after the Dutch version."

"It was Aleksandr Deriabin’s idea to show the 1925 State Kino-Calendar No. 47 before the 1929 Man with a Movie Camera. It helps to situate that famous trick shot from the last reel of Man with a Movie Camera which makes the Bolshoi Theatre collapse. A more or less similar thing happens to the Bolshoi in the 47th issue of State Kino-Calendar. For a variety of reasons (detailed in my introductory essay in Lines of Resistance: Dziga Vertov and the Twenties), Left-wing writers and filmmakers alike perceived the Bolshoi (former Imperial) Theatre as an emblem of dated, portentous, etc., art. Vertov, who was, as we know, always on the Left, took the existence of the Bolshoi Theatre almost personally — as the theatre which the authorities refused to demolish or convert into something useful, as the Left Front of the Arts [LEF] group demanded, or at least closed (as Lenin wanted to, back in 1921), and which was instead turned into an official showcase for official art. Ironically, in February 1925, when the 100th anniversary of the Bolshoi was pompously celebrated (meetings, speakers, banners, demonstrations), Vertov was assigned to record the event for State Kino-Calendar. But then, he could use the movie camera — the filmmaker’s weapon — to knock out symbolically what could not be physically knocked down." – YURI TSIVIAN (GCM)

The Birth of a Nation (Photoplay print with a music soundtrack of John Lanchbery's adaptation of the Carl Joseph Breil score)


D. W. Griffith: The Birth of a Nation (1915).

THE BIRTH OF A NATION (David W. Griffith Corp. / Majestic Motion Picture Co., US 1915)
    Dir.: D. W. Griffith; cast: Henry B. Walthall, Lillian Gish, Mae Marsh, Miriam Cooper, Ralph Lewis, Mary Alden, George Siegmann, Walter Long, Elmer Clifton, Joesphine Crowell, Spottiswoode Aitken, Raoul Walsh;
    English intertitles.
    35 mm, 11,335 ft, 190' (16 fps), Photoplay Productions.
    Act I: 88 min, Act II: 101 min.
    Playback: music score: John Lanchbery.
    Cinema Ruffo, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): The Griffith Project 8, 14 Oct 2004.

Eileen Bowser [DWG Project # 513]: "Memoirs by several eyewitnesses of the production of The Birth of a Nation have been published. Two who were closest to it day by day were G. W. Bitzer, the cameraman, who had been with Biograph from its beginnings, and Karl Brown, a clever and sharp-eyed kid in his teens, later a well-respected cameraman, writer, and director. Karl Brown wangled a job as assistant to Bitzer as soon as the new company had arrived in California, months before production of The Birth of a Nation began. As part of his job assisting the cameraman, he recorded every scene of that production in his log as it was made. These men were blessed with good memories and a desire to record what happened as objectively as possible, but we have to take into consideration that their remembrances were those of old age, long after the events they recorded (see G. W. Bitzer, Billy Bitzer: His Story, 1973; Karl Brown, Adventures with D. W. Griffith, 1973; another eyewitness account, Before, In and After Hollywood: The Autobiography of Joseph E. Henabery, was published in 1997)."

"In April the company completed and released Home, Sweet Home, and in May produced The Avenging Conscience. At the same time that Griffith worked on that innovative film, preparations had already started on The Clansman. A caravan of automobiles led up through Cahuenga Pass to the northern slope of Cahuenga Peak, and there, in a natural clearing, the plans were laid out for the battle scenes. Karl Brown remembered: “A sort of ridge of high ground curved around the rim of a gently descending slope of clear ground that ran down to where the dry-as-dust riverbed of the Los Angeles River lay baking in the sun. There were little clumps of trees clustered on both sides of this open area, with small hills rounding up here and there in the background to provide splendid locations for artillerymen to rake the field with grape and canister, the two favorite close-range charges of the Civil War cannoneers. Not only the geography but the orientation of the field happened to be perfect. When shooting big stuff you must shoot either north or south, never east or west. On this location all the camera angles from the ridge would be shooting north, which meant cross light from the right during the morning, and from the left throughout the afternoon.” (Adventures with D. W. Griffith, pp. 55
–56)"

"Frank Wortman, master carpenter, and George Siegmann, chief among the multitude of assistant directors, laid out the trenches and gun emplacements as Griffith surveyed the scene and expressed his vision with gestures and words that to the young Karl Brown were poetic and unspecific but that Wortman and Siegmann knew how to interpret in practical terms. Confederate trenches to the right, Union to the left. Griffith had observed long ago at Biograph that it was necessary to preserve screen direction in battle scenes, in order not to confuse the audience about which running and falling soldiers belonged to which side of the conflict. There is a long list of “assistant directors”: Joseph Henabery (in the Appendix to his autobiography) disputed the title of chief assistant director that Karl Brown awarded to George Siegmann, claiming that title for George Beranger. It is easy to fall into such disagreements, since the title “assistant director” was not then an official one, and any number of people might have acted in that capacity for the moment when Griffith needed something done. As Karl Brown put it, “…and whoever else happened to be standing around doing nothing…”. Brown mentioned, after George Siegmann, Elmer Clifton, Herbert Sutch, Erich von Stroheim, Howard Gaye, Monte Blue, George (André) Beranger, Donald Crisp, Fred Hamer, Tom Wilson, Christy Cabanne, and Raoul Walsh, all names known to film history, but this list is not complete and surely not entirely accurate. Some of these names are also to be found in Bitzer’s account. Many of these men also worked on Intolerance, which could have added to the confusion in Brown’s and Bitzer’s memories. Henabery thought Stroheim and Monte Blue were not yet at the studio. Ambitious young men were eager to act in the lowliest capacity to work with D. W. Griffith, considered the outstanding creative genius of his day in motion pictures, or, if not actually present, ready to claim in later years that they were. Assistants were always needed in large crowd scenes such as the battle sequences to direct groups of extras in the action."

"Brown said that Battles and Leaders of the Civil War became the chief reference for all the military equipment. The job of Herbert Sutch was to procure the ancient muskets, and to find a way to convert these weapons, which had been modernized to fire cartridges, to the appearance of Civil War authenticity, not to mention the necessity of shooting blanks. According to Brown’s account, Sutch achieved this by pouring a very soft wax into the modern cartridges with a small amount of smoky black explosive powder (Brown, p. 58). Such improvisation characterized the spirit of Griffith’s team. For period uniforms and costumes, they turned to Robert Goldstein, a Los Angeles costumer who was to be enriched by having to accept part ownership in the production instead of payment of his bill. The same reference, Battles and Leaders of the Civil War, was Goldstein’s guide to preparing the costumes. Bitzer, too, became a part owner of the film when he advanced his savings to help finish it. W. H. Clune, owner of Clune’s Auditorium, where The Clansman had its Los Angeles premiere, was a big contributor to the costs of production. Nobody had reason to regret their investment, as it turned out."

"Journalistic attempts to characterize the achievement of The Birth of a Nation often point to its production cost, lavish for its time, and its record-breaking return at the box-office, but the problem with this is that we do not have good enough financial records to tell us the real story. All we really know is that production costs swelled way beyond what they had available, and loans were needed to complete the film. Bitzer gave a sort of account of costs: $10,000 to Thomas Dixon for the rights to The Clansman; filming costs rose to $78,000 at one stage; Bitzer put in $7,000 from his own savings; Griffith told Bitzer “That Woman” (whoever that may have been) invested $9,000; W. H. Clune put up $15,000, and Goldstein took payment for costumes in stock for $7,000. Originally budgeted for $40,000, Bitzer said, The Birth of a Nation cost $110,000. He also announced that it grossed $20,000,000 over the years, but Variety is unsure enough as to decline to list the film at all in their annual top-grossing films lists, although, of course, they mention it."

"While trenches were dug and gun emplacements built in the valley chosen for the battle scenes, a vacant lot across the street from the studio was leased, where “Huck” Wortman and his carpenters erected the streets, house fronts, and slave quarters of a sleepy Southern town. Some of these sets were erected right on the studio lot, conveniently next to the carpenter shop."

"After six weeks of rehearsal, shooting began on 4 July 1914. Bitzer said that just one camera was used, a Pathé “with a 3.5 two-inch lens interchangeable with a wide-angle lens – that is, you had to screw one out and screw the other into its place” (Iris Barry, D. W. Griffith, p. 37). The orthochromatic film was slow, and limited in tonal range. Bitzer suggested that the limitations of this stock may have helped give the images “historical authenticity”. The entire film was hand-cranked by Bitzer, in what he described as 3⁄4 waltz time, and the turning had to be absolutely constant to the end of the shot, as was second nature to any experienced cameraman of that day. It was also common to vary the cranking speed according to the demands of the specific scenes, and in addition, Griffith films were sometimes sent out with instructions to the theatre manager to vary the projection speed in certain scenes."

"The first scenes filmed were the battle scenes. Bitzer claims that the little family group on the hill, watching Sherman’s march to the sea, were discovered sitting there by Griffith, and were captured on film without their knowing. The team went up in the mountains to Big Bear to shoot Gus’s chase of Little Sister among the pine trees, and her fall to her death among the rocks. Later, Brown and Bitzer were sent back to the mountain to film a dummy that Brown threw – in place of Mae Marsh – over the cliff, and, according to his tale, almost went over with it. In a mountain meadow at Big Bear, they did the love scene between Margaret Cameron and Phil Stoneman. They drove east to the open country around the Rio Hondo [a tributary of the Los Angeles River] to film the thundering hordes of the white-robed Clansmen on horseback from every possible angle: both Billy Bitzer and Karl Brown have left harrowing tales of horses jumping over them and explosions and smoke beside them as they filmed from ground level."

"The assassination of Lincoln in Ford’s Theatre was pictured in authentic detail according to old engravings, with the playscript of Our American Cousin at hand to guide the performance on stage. A mirror was moved around to reflect sunlight on Booth like a spotlight as he slid through the theatre crowd. After three seasons filming on the West Coast, Billy Bitzer was experienced with lighting by the brilliant California sunlight, aided by soft cloth diffusers and mirrors, instead of the electricity needed for indoor work back East. According to him, the only scene requiring special lighting was the burning of Atlanta in miniature, in order to make it look real, as he put it (Bitzer, p. 106). Joseph Henabery, stepping out of the ranks of extras, got the role of Lincoln by showing Griffith what he could do with Lincoln make-up: actors at that time were still responsible for their own make-up. Joseph Henabery said that in one long sequence he was chasing himself: as a black renegade and then as a white soldier. As an extra, he believed he played 13 different characters. The repeated use of extras, and at times actors playing extra roles, may explain why some scholars have found editing “errors” in later years, such as a character falling dead in battle and discovered up and running in a later scene. Blackface make-up on white actors, and black extras even in the same scene, were common in the industry."

"Karl Brown told us that Griffith (at least in the period to which Brown was witness) never called “camera” or “cut” as other directors did, but always “fade in” and “fade out”. Brown’s theory was that Griffith never knew in advance whether he would need a fade to open or close a scene, and the system of including a fade every time gave him the option to use it or not. Rose and Jimmie Smith were his cutters for most of his career. They knew how to interpret the remarks he made when he looked at the footage in the projection room at night, after shooting was done for the day."

"Shooting was complete in October, and the footage was edited to 12 reels by the end of the year. Karl Brown was assigned to shoot the intertitles for the film, and therefore was not a daily witness to the editing work. While the editing and titling went on, the indefatigable Griffith produced The Mother and the Law, which was not released at that time, but revised and incorporated as the modern story of Intolerance (1916)."

"As The Clansman, The Birth of a Nation had its first public showing on 1 January 1915, at the Loring Opera House in Riverside, California, with a special seven-piece orchestra, and prices of 20 and 30 cents, according to the printed program in the Griffith Papers at the Museum of Modern Art. This was a high-class showing for 1915. Nevertheless, Griffith considered it only a trial run, held secret from most of his staff, because he did not want any cheerleaders in the audience, just ordinary moviegoers. Joseph Henabery said that he went along with Griffith to that screening and wrote down as best he could and with the help of his fiancée, later his wife, what was in the film at that date (this document is in the Joseph and Jeanne Henabery Collection at the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, Margaret Herrick Library; see Henabery, p. 82). The official premiere was at Clune’s Auditorium in Los Angeles on 8 February. Griffith attended these showings to judge audience reaction, and then edited further. He continued to do the same at the New York premiere on 3 March, where the picture was now known as The Birth of a Nation; he followed it to the showings in Boston and Chicago for the same purpose."

"If production of a film includes its editing stages, production of The Birth of a Nation continued long after the film was being shown to the public. It is hardly surprising that modern-day prints and even negatives show some gaps or illogical connections, when the editing continued under such circumstances. Today, archival reconstruction offers a variety of choices to the restorer: which showing constitutes the original version? Griffith cared deeply about audience reaction. I expect he would be quite bewildered to observe how young audiences perceive the film today. The film has not changed, but we have."
" – Eileen Bowser [DWG Project # 513]

AA: I viewed only 25 minutes from the beginning because I wanted to catch the Vertov screening at 20.30 at Teatro Zancanaro. And because I had seen the electrifying 1997 Pordenone film concert The Birth of a Nation of the Photoplay print with John Lanchbery himself conducting his adaptation of the Carl Joseph Breil score. A great score and a great print.

Krunisanje kralja Petra I Karađorđevića i Putovanje kroz Srbiju, Novi Pazar, Crnu Goru i Dalmaciju / Coronation of King Peter I Karadjordjevic and Journey through Serbia, Novi Pazar, Montenegro and Dalmatia


Frank Mottershaw: Krunisanje Kralja Petra I Karađorđevića / The Coronation of King Peter I Karadjordjevic of Serbia (1904). Photo: IMDb.

KRUNISSANJE KRALJAA PETRA I KARADJORDJEVICA I PUTOVAWE KROZ SRBIJU, NOVI PAZAR, CRNU GORU I DALMACIJU / THE CORONATION OF KING PETER I OF SERBIA AND A RIDE THROUGH SERBIA, NOVI-BAZAAR, MONTENEGRO AND DALMATIA / [INCORONAZIONE DI RE PIETRO PRIMO DI SERBIA ED IL VIAGGIO ATTRAVERSO LA SERBIA, NOVI-BAZAAR, IL MONTENEGRO E LA DALMAZIA]
Krunisanje kralja Petra I Karađorđevića i Putovanje kroz Srbiju, Novi Pazar, Crnu Goru i Dalmaciju / Coronation of King Peter I Karadjordjevic and Journey through Serbia, Novi Pazar, Montenegro and Dalmatia
Krunisanje kralja Petra I / The Coronation of King Peter I of Serbia
Krunisanje Kralja Petra I Karadjordjevica [IMDb]
GB 1904
    Prod: Arnold Muir Willson; ph: Frank Mottershaw, Jr.; 35 mm, 1480 m, 54’ (25 fps), virato / toned, Jugoslovenska Kinoteka.
    Serbian & English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Antonio Coppola.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fuori quadro, 14 Oct 2004.

Dejan Kosanovic (GCM): "This is the oldest preserved film shot in the territory of former Yugoslavia (now Serbia). In June 1903 (actually 29 May at the time, as Serbia was still following the old Julian Calendar), King Alexander Obrenovich and his wife Queen Draga were assassinated in Belgrade.  The throne passed to the Karageorgevich dynasty, and the new king, Peter 1st Karageorgevich, was crowned in September 1904, more than a year after the coup d’état. Belgrade invited foreign guests to the coronation, but no European court (except Montenegro) sent representatives, as Serbia was under sanctions because of the 1903 killing of the royal family. But the coronation festivities in Belgrade were attended by delegations from all parts of the Kingdom of Serbia, as well as many private guests from abroad."

"Among the guests was an eminent lawyer from Sheffield, England, Mr. Arnold Muir Willson, who was also the Honorary Consul to the Kingdom of Serbia. Beside being a lawyer, Willson was a traveller, journalist, and photographer.  He hired cameraman Frank Storm Mottershaw, Jr. of the Sheffield Photo Company, a very active film production company at this period. They attended the coronation together, and realized a documentary film about the event. After Belgrade, they visited and filmed some other places in Serbia: the small town of Kraljevo, the medieval monasteries of Zica (Zhicha) and Studenica (Studenitza), and then, on their way home, Novi Bazar (under Turkish rule at the time), Andrijevica and Cetinje in Montenegro, and Sibenik (Sebenico) and Zadar (Zara) in Dalmatia.  Willson screened this film several times in Britain to illustrate his lectures on Serbia.  In the spring of 1905 he screened the film at the Serbian National Theatre in Belgrade in the presence of the king and the royal family."

"The print of this film was found in England and purchased before World War II by a collector from Belgrade, Mr. Jovanovic-Marambo. It has been in the collection of the Yugoslav Film Archive (Jugoslovenska Kinoteka) in Belgrade since 1949, the year of its founding. Some parts of the film were copied 5 decades ago, and they have occasionally been screened or broadcast, but the whole film has never been completely reconstructed until this year. The new print, including new intertitles, was made in Bologna at the Immagine Ritrovata lab." – Dejan Kosanovic (GCM)

AA: Epic themes today: The Birth of a Nation preceded by the first surviving film shot in Jugoslavia, Karageorgevich. A good-looking print, well restored from sources in bad shape. Endless processions. A very moving experience nonetheless, documentation from the powder keg from which a world fire was ignited.

Captain January (1924) in the presence of Baby Peggy: Diana Serra Cary



Baby Peggy, Diana Serra Cary, at Le Giornate del Cinema Muto in Sacile, 2004.

CAPTAIN JANUARY (Principal Pictures, US 1924)
Dir: Edward F. Cline; prod: Sol Lesser; sc: Eve Unsell, John Grey, dal romanzo di / from the novel by Laura Elizabeth Richards (1891); ph: Glen MacWilliams; art titles: William J. Sackheim; cast: Baby Peggy, Hobart Bosworth, Irene Rich, Lincoln Stedman, Harry T. Morey, Barbara Tennant, John Merkyl, Emmett King; prima proiezione pubblica / rel: 6.7.1924; lunghezza originale / orig. length: 6194 ft.; 35mm, 5040 ft., 61’ (22 fps), Library of Congress.Titolo edizione italiana: Capitan Baby. Didascalie in inglese / English intertitles.
    GCM Sacile, Teatro Zancanaro, 14 Oct 2004

GCM: "A little girl is the sole survivor of a shipwreck, but is rescued by a kindly lighthouse keeper who raises the child as his own until inevitable complications — meddling moralists and the girl’s relatives among them — ensue. Captain January is very much a star vehicle for "Baby Peggy" Montgomery, and, like Jackie Coogan in the almost identical My Boy (First National, 1922), she takes to the role of urchin-with-a-heart-of-gold with great gusto. Avuncular Hobart Bosworth is ideally cast as her surrogate father, and although one might wish director Eddie Cline had used more of his estimable comic sensibility to enliven the proceedings (and dampen some of the more treacly sentimentality), the overall effect is that of a charming story, well told. — Mike Mashon"

"I left Universal for Lesser’s Principal Pictures in September of 1922 and started work on Captain January immediately. I was supported by veteran stage and screen actor Hobart Bosworth and the popular actress Irene Rich. Most of the filming was done on location aboard a yacht anchored off scenic, sparsely populated Laguna Beach, sixty miles south of Los Angeles. Its one hotel, where we were put up, had no electricity, heat, or indoor plumbing."

"Throughout my life, whenever movie buffs have seen this film, they’ve been sure to ask, ‘Surely you can’t remember that movie? You were much too young!’ The truth is, every time I watch it, the same feeling sweeps over me that I experienced sharply on the first day of shooting — a feeling of being suddenly very old. This was a big production, an expensive one, and my part very demanding. I felt the weight of the load I was carrying. True, I was four and a half, but by now I had been working without letup for the past two and a half years, having made close to one hundred fifty comedies and three feature films. By the time I started Captain January, the day my fancied ‘stars’ began pouring rain through the roof of Century’s Barn seemed ages ago." — Diana Serra Cary (What Ever Happened to Baby Peggy? 1996)

AA: A good children's film. Actual duration of the screening: 64 min. It was amazing to see this delightful film in the presence of its star, Baby Peggy, Diana Serra Cary, 85 years old. ***

NB. Baby Peggy died on 24 Feb 2020, age 101.

How It Happened (US 1925, Twisted Tales, Ira Young, Betty Young)


Not from the film. An illustration by Cyrus Cuneo in The Strand Magazine (September 1913) where Arthur Conan Doyle's short story "How It Happened" was originally published. From: The Arthur Conan Doyle Encylopedia.

HOW IT HAPPENED (Short Film Syndicate, Inc. / Reciprocity Films, US 1925)
    series: Twisted Tales
    Dir: ?; ed/titles: Hal Hodes; cast: Ira Young, Betty Young, Martin Decker, Henry Carter; 35 mm, 731 ft, 10 min (20 fps), tinted, UCLA Film and Television Archive.
    English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Mauro Colombis.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fuori quadro, 14 Oct 2004

Doron Galili (GSM): "How It Happened is an episode from a short-lived series of one-reel mystery films, Twisted Tales. The production company, Reciprocity Films, is unrecorded in the Library of Congress copyright catalogue. Adapted from a short story by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle, it is faithful to its literary source‚ the story of a rich man who is killed in an accident in the mountains while driving with his chauffeur. He nevertheless remains among the living, as a dead man, and encounters an old friend who died in the war." – Doron Galili (GCM)

Enoch Arden (William Christy Cabanne, Majestic 1915)


William Christy Cabanne: Enoch Arden (1915) starring Lillian Gish and Wallace Reid. Photo: IMDb.

AA: I missed this screening but include J. B. Kaufman's text to keep a full run of the program notes of The Griffith Project 8.

The third Enoch Arden in the Griffith Project. The previous ones, directed by Griffith: After Many Years (1908) and Enoch Arden (1911).

ENOCH ARDEN (Majestic Motion Picture Co., US 1915)
    Dir.: William Christy Cabanne; supv.: D. W. Griffith; cast: Alfred Paget, Lillian Gish, Wallace Reid; 35 mm, 3502 ft, 58’ (16 fps), George Eastman House (Casselton / Larson Collection).
    Preserved and printed 1997.
    English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Donald Sosin.
    Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): The Griffith Project 8, 14 Oct 2004

J. B. Kaufman [DWG Project # 514]: "Considering that Griffith hardly ever remade one of his films, it’s especially remarkable to find a story produced in three different versions, as Enoch Arden was. We’ve already seen the first two, both produced at Biograph: After Many Years (1908), which is not strictly based on Tennyson’s poem but clearly derives from it, and the two-reel Enoch Arden in 1911. This multiplicity of versions probably has something to do with the prestige associated with Tennyson’s name, but in addition it may well indicate a fondness for the story on Griffith’s part. (After all, despite numerous stage adaptations, Enoch Arden doesn’t appear to have been particularly popular with other filmmakers.) Technically, of course, this feature-length 1915 version is directed not by Griffith but by Christy Cabanne. But it’s no discredit to Griffith to say that this version is, in some respects, the best of the three; not only did Griffith supervise the film, but it’s clear that Cabanne was heavily influenced by the previous Griffith-directed versions."

"This is strikingly evident in the film’s structure. The intercutting in After Many Years, implying a telepathic connection between Charles Inslee on the island and Florence Lawrence at home, has given that film a degree of latter-day notoriety, but we can infer that Griffith was equally taken with the effect in 1908. For his subsequent 1911 version he expanded on it, interweaving the scenes of shipwreck survivor and wife far more extensively than in the 1908 version – even though (as Tom Gunning has pointed out in D. W. Griffith and the Origins of American Narrative Film, p. 112) the original poem had offered little or no precedent for either formal interweaving or the idea of a telepathic connection between husband and wife. By 1915 the device has become a tradition, and Cabanne cuts between the two threads of the story with freewheeling abandon. The story is faithful to the original poem (most of the titles are taken directly from it, though often condensed and modified), but in terms of formal structure Cabanne is taking his cues not from Tennyson but from Griffith."

"The influence of the earlier film versions can also be seen in such scenes as those of the sailors’ discovery of Enoch on the island, and his return to his former home, both of which are staged very much as in the 1911 version. The device of taking the intertitles from Tennyson has some interesting results: when Alfred Paget as Enoch proposes to Lillian Gish as Annie the scene is played without titles, simply because it’s not described in the poem. At times Cabanne’s interpretation of a scene seems slightly at odds with that offered in the titles. When Lillian consults the Bible for an answer to her dilemma, the sense of the scene matches that in the poem, but Cabanne condenses the action so that what we see on the screen seems to clash with what we read in the titles. And midway through the last reel we are informed that Lillian has become fully reconciled to her second marriage to Wallace Reid, but Cabanne allows Reid to worry about it until the very last scene in the film."

"Roberta Pearson has analyzed Griffith’s 1908 and 1911 versions of this story in detail, comparing the acting in both films and distinguishing between “histrionic” and “verisimilar” styles. In general she finds that Griffith tends towards the latter by 1911, encouraging his cast to adopt more restrained gestures and expressions, and helping them out by conveying narrative information himself through props and editing. In general, we can say that the 1915 version reflects the same trend. By and large, the acting of the three principals is subtle enough that when Paget, in the tavern near film’s end, delivers a gestural soliloquy about his changed appearance – an action that would not have seemed out of place during most of the Biograph years – it seems jarring by its contrast with the general tone of the film."

"The prize performance here is that of Lillian Gish as Annie Lee. Enoch Arden was produced immediately after The Birth of a Nation, and displays, perhaps even more prominently than that film, the promise of the sensitive, thoughtful actress Lillian Gish would become in just a few short years. In Enoch Arden her character ages two decades, a process convincingly conveyed through acting far more than make-up. Her painful indecision in the last two reels, agonizing over whether to accept Reid’s marriage proposal or cling to the dwindling hope of Paget’s return, is just the kind of dilemma she would portray so well throughout her career. Admittedly, she benefits from the increased length of the film. Linda Arvidson, playing Annie in the 1911 version, is required to submit to her persistent suitor in one shot; Lillian, in 1915, holds Reid off for the better part of a reel, a luxury that would have been impossible in the earlier versions. But even allowing for such advantages, Lillian’s future acting accomplishments are unmistakably announced here. When she holds her sickly baby in an early scene, fearing for its life, and later when the baby dies, it’s difficult not to think of Way Down East."

"As a 1915 version of a story that had already been produced twice at Biograph, Enoch Arden offers a useful index to the rapidly changing conditions of film production during these vital years: it’s produced on a far more lavish scale than the Biograph versions, but would itself have seemed quite modest within a few years. In the shipwreck scene an actual sinking ship was beyond the means of Biograph (or Majestic), but here Cabanne is able to give us the rocking, partially submerged interior of the boat. The passage of time on the island is cleverly suggested by placing Paget on the beach next to some little imitation palm trees, and later situating him among fuller vegetation. The most elaborate setting is the exterior of the village square, with a working windmill at the rear, a church on one side, and a tavern on the other. When Paget returns at the end, the passage of time is again suggested by tall weeds and fuller vegetation, and the faded sign of the “King Henry Inn”."

"Enoch Arden was reissued in 1922 with the less-than-inspired title The Fatal Marriage. Art titles, augmented with such touches as an animated tolling church bell, were added to pad the film’s length from four reels to five. (Regular attendees of the Giornate may remember that a fragment of this version was shown at the festival in 2001.) Whatever one may think of such reissues, we can be grateful for this one. A nitrate print of the 1922 edition, combined with authentic 1915 intertitles from a 28 mm original, provided the source material from which George Eastman House produced their gorgeous restoration print.
" – J. B. Kaufman [DWG Project # 514]

The Triumph of the Rat


Graham Cutts: The Triumph of the Rat (1926) with Ivor Novello and Isabel Jeans. Photo from: Back to the Past Web.

THE TRIUMPH OF THE RAT (Gainsborough Pictures / Piccadilly Pictures, GB 1926)
    Dir: Graham Cutts; prod: Michael Balcon, Carlyle Blackwell; sc: Graham Cutts, Reginald Fogwell, based on characters from the original play The Rat by Ivor Novello & Constance Collier; titles: Roland Pertwee; ph: Hal Young; asst. ph: Freddie Young; des: Basil Evans; cast: Ivor Novello, Isabel Jeans, Nina Vanna, Marie Ault, Lewis Mannering, Adeline Hayden Coffin, Julie Suedo, Charles Dormer, Gabriel Rosca; trade show: 9.1926; 35 mm, 7430 ft, 99’ (20 fps), BFI / National Film and Television Archive.
    Didascalie in inglese / English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Gabriel Thibaudeau.
    15 minutes from the beginning viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 14 Oct 2004

Bryony Dixon (GCM): "The Triumph of the Rat is the ironically titled sequel to The Rat (1925), in which Ivor Novello played an underworld Apache jewel thief who falls for a beautiful courtesan, Zelie de Chaumet (Isabel Jeans), but ultimately leaves her to be with the waif (Mae Marsh) who has been living under his protection and who remains loyal to him through thick and thin. In this sequel, “The Rat”, now minus the waif, has attained the heights of Parisian society, groomed to perfection by Zelie, but no longer with her. He is bored, however, and is goaded into a bet by his former lover that he cannot make a woman fall in love with him within a month. Cue the delicately lovely Nina Vanna, and the plot is set for The Rat to lose his heart, and ultimately even his position with the human dregs of the White Coffin nightclub, where he has formerly reigned supreme."

"The downward trajectory of the story might surprise some people ­ have the British adopted the Russian ending? It’s more complicated, perhaps. The central theme of the story is about a man’s divided soul. There is something of Novello’s persona in this “horror-haunted man”, as Michael Williams calls him (in his book Ivor Novello: Screen Idol, BFI Publishing, 2003), and the post-war subtext is ever present. There are lighter moments. As production values rose in line with the popularity of the series, Cutts was able to stage some spectacular set-pieces (a particularly good one, shot from above, sees thousands of balloons opening the masked-ball sequence), as well as exploit the fluid camera technique for which he was praised by producer Michael Balcon."

"“Graham Cutts has never produced anything so fine, and many successes are already to his credit, than The Triumph of the Rat. Ivor Novello’s down and out scenes are remarkable, his entire physique is a bitter revelation of debased despair…” (Edith Nepean, Picture Show, 13 November 1926, quoted in Michael Williams).
" – Bryony Dixon (GCM)

The Enchanted Cottage (1924)


John S. Robertson: The Enchanted Cottage (1924). Poster from IMDb.

John S. Robertson: The Enchanted Cottage (1924) with Richard Barthelmess and May McAvoy. Poster from IMDb.

THE ENCHANTED COTTAGE (Inspiration Pictures, US 1924)
    Dir: John S. Robertson; adapted by Josephine Lovett from the play by Sir Arthur Wing Pinero; ph: George Folsey; cast: Richard Barthelmess, May McAvoy, Florence Short, Holmes Herbert; rel. 24.3.1924.
    35 mm, 7120 ft /24 fps/ 79 min, Library of Congress.
    English intertitles
    Grand piano: Phil Carli.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fort Lee, 14 Oct 2004

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "Until 1926, all the Barthelmess Inspiration productions were made in the East; two of them, The Fighting Blade and The Enchanted Cottage, at the Universal studio in Fort Lee, once the largest glass-enclosed studio in the country. Except for a handful of scenes, The Enchanted Cottage was filmed entirely inside this studio during the bitter winter of 1923–24, including all scenes of the cottage and its surrounding grounds. “In the East,” Barthelmess said, “there are many fine studio facilities, and any picture demanding only interiors can be made as well in Fort Lee as in Hollywood.” Of course, such artificial settings worked best with fanciful material like this, elegantly photographed here by George Folsey. Although a few independent productions came later, this was the last silent feature from a major producer/star made in Fort Lee." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: A war trauma film: the crippled war invalid Oliver Bashforth (Richard Barthelmess) wants to break free from the presence of his domineering sister and finds refuge in a lonely cottage. There he meets the plain but kind Laura Pennington (May McAvoy) who reveals that the place is a very old honeymoon cottage. The spirit of the place casts a spell of them, and both are transformed by love. Cinematic dimensions: mirror phobia; "the blind sense what others see". 

I know May McAvoy best from her great Ernst Lubitsch roles in Three Women and Lady Windermere's Fan (the title role) and of course the female lead in The Jazz Singer. This is something completely different, nuanced and delicate in an unconventional and moving romance.

Richard Barthelmess had an interesting career as a producer-star. His first film as an independent producer was Tol'able David, no less, and he produced several of the best films of Henry King before King signed with Goldwyn and Fox.

WIKIPEDIA:

"The Enchanted Cottage is a 1924 American silent drama film based upon a 1923 play by Arthur Wing Pinero, and directed by John S. Robertson.

The film was produced by Richard Barthelmess, through his company Inspiration, and released through Associated First National. Barthelmess and May McAvoy star in the drama.

Robert Young and Dorothy McGuire starred in 1945 version also based on the 1923 play.

Crippled by the war, Oliver Bashforth (Richard Barthelmess) moves into a lonely cottage in search of solitude. He meets Laura Pennington (May McAvoy), a plain and lonely woman, and marries her, primarily to escape from his energetic sister, Ethel (Florence Short). The unhappy couple allow their insecurities to suppress romance and happiness, but their mutual admiration grows and becomes love, manifested by the recognition of the inner beauty in each of them.

A reviewer for Photoplay wrote, "To anyone with a poetic soul, this picture will be a rare treat. But the too literal person will be sadly disappointed. A picture for folk who dare to dream. As such we cannot recommend it too highly."

"There is a charm about the spoken or written word that is frequently too elusive to be caught by the camera, and in its efforts to make things clear, too often the screen makes them merely clumsy," wrote Marguerite Orndorff for The Educational Screen. "There was a danger of such a result in filming this whimsy of Pinero's, but the direction of John S. Robertson, and the understanding portrayals of May McAvoy and Richard Barthelmess have in a large measure preserved its delicacy."
" (Wikipedia)

P.S. Fritzi Kramer: The Enchanted Cottage, Movies Silently, 26 July, 2015. 

White Fawn's Devotion


James Young Deer: White Fawn's Devotion (1910). The opening credit title card from IMDb.

James Young Deer: White Fawn's Devotion (1910) with Princess Red Wing* and James Young Deer. Photo and caption from Library of Congress, National Film Registry (2008), essay by Scott Simmon based on his American Archives dvd notes.

WHITE FAWN’S DEVOTION (Pathé Frères, US 1910)
White Fawn's Devotion: A Play Acted by a Tribe of Red Indians in America
    Dir: James Young Deer; cast: James Young Deer, Princess Red Wing*; rel. 18.6.1910.
    35 mm, 950 ft /16 fps/ 16 min, Library of Congress.
    English intertitles.
    Grand piano: Phil Carli.
    Viewed at Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM): Fort Lee, 14 Oct 2004

Richard Koszarski (GCM): "Pathé opened an American factory in Bound Brook, New Jersey in 1910, and established a local production unit the same year. Many of their films were westerns shot in Fort Lee, often directed by James Young Deer, and starring Young Deer and his wife, Princess Red Wing*. While Red Wing* (real name, Lillian St. Cyr) was an authentic member of the Winnebago tribe, Angela Aleiss, in her forthcoming Native Americans in the Movies, reveals that Young Deer was a make-believe Indian whose name does not appear on the Winnebago rolls (and therefore was not “the first native American filmmaker”). White Fawn’s Devotion is only one of many contemporary derivatives of The Squaw Man, the Ur-text of much early western fiction. Although it makes good use of Fort Lee’s natural wonders, only a New Jersey western would so emphasize the rigors of the Palisades. Horses, although easily available at many local livery stables, appear to have been used sparingly by Young Deer, his Indians being forced to chase their white quarry on foot." – Richard Koszarski (GCM)

AA: Very primitive. But of special importance as the first film made by Native Americans. Princess Red Wing* (who would soon play the female lead in Cecil B. DeMille's first film adaptation of The Squaw Man) was a Winnebago, James Young Deer was not, but since this GCM Sacile screening it has been established by Angela Aleiss in 2013 that he was a Nanticoke, belonging to Delaware Nanticokes, among "the Moors of Delaware": Angela Aleiss: "Who Was the Real James Young Deer? The Mysterious Identity of the Pathè Producer Finally Comes to Light" (Bright Lights film journal, 30 April, 2013).

Library of Congress: National Film Registry (2008)

"White Fawn’s Devotion (1910) James Young Deer is now recognized as the first documented movie director of Native American ancestry. Born in Dakota City, Neb., as a member of the Winnebago Indian tribe, James Young Deer (aka: J. Younger Johnston) began his show-business career in circus and Wild West shows in the 1890s. When Pathé Frères of France established its American studio in 1910, in part to produce more authentically American-style Western films, Young Deer was hired as a director and scenario writer. Frequently in collaboration with his wife, actress Princess Red Wing* (aka: Lillian St. Cyr), also of Winnebago ancestry, Young Deer is believed to have written and directed more than 100 movies for Pathé from 1910-1913. Many details of Young Deer’s life and movie career remain undocumented and fewer than 10 of his films have been discovered and preserved by U.S. film archives."

Scott Simmon: White Fawn’s Devotion
From the National Film Preservation Foundation (NFPF)
Treasures of the American Archives DVD program notes, by permission of NFPF and Scott Simmon


“White Fawn’s Devotion” is probably the earliest surviving film directed by a Native American. Released in June 1910, it is also among the first films made in America by France’s Pathé Frères, then the world’s largest film production company.

U.S. motion picture trade journals, in a battle both cultural and economic, had ridiculed the English saddles and gingham-shirted Indians in Pathé’s European-made Westerns. Pathé’s answer was to open a studio in New Jersey and hire as director of its Westerns a Native American, James Young Deer. After Pathé opened a Los Angeles branch, Young Deer would be promoted to its general manager.

Born in Nebraska of Winnebago ancestry, James Young Deer (whose name may be a pseudonym) had trouped the country with Wild West shows and circuses before landing roles in film Westerns some-times alongside his wife, Lillian St. Cyr (likewise a Winnebago, with a long career under the name Princess Redwing). For Kalem, Lubin, and other early companies, Young Deer also penned Western scenarios. In part because he was never given credit on-screen for any of the approximately 120 films he directed for Pathé between 1910 and 1913, James Young Deer has become a completely forgotten figure, and his films are impossible to attribute with certainty. Only about six are thought to survive in U.S. archives.

“White Fawn’s Devotion,” like almost all American Westerns before it, was shot in the East. As with several other Young Deer films (to judge from their plot description), it draws from the popular 1905 stage melodrama. “The Squaw Man” —about a Briton whose Indian wife sacrifices herself by suicide —but alters the outcome significantly. In “White Fawn’s Devotion” a Briton named Combs, his Indian wife, White Fawn, and their daughter live in a Dakota log cabin. When Combs makes plans to claim “an unexpected legacy,” White Fawn fears he is leaving forever with their child and attempts suicide. The daughter, finding her father bent over her mother holding a bloody knife, mistakenly reports murder to her Indian grandfather. After the chase by the tribe, Combs is set for execution at the hands of his reluctant daughter, until White Fawn —who has only wounded herself —arrives to set things straight.

For all its simple pantomime style, “White Fawn’s Devotion” arrives at a conclusion almost unknown in the era’s film or fiction: The interracial couple live happily ever after. The surviving print, preserved by the Library of Congress, is missing a few feet at its end, and Pathé’s publicity fills in the resolution: “The Combs take their departure and return to their home, for he feels he will be happier with his family on the plains than if he goes east and claims his legacy.” It was only when Young Deer reversed the sexes of the interracial couple that reviewers were outraged.

About (the unfortunately lost) “Red Deer’s Devotion,” which Young Deer shot in the West in 1911, “Moving Picture World” said: “Another feature of this film will not please a good many. It represents a white girl and an Indian falling in love with each other. While such a thing is possible, and undoubtedly has been done many times, there is still a feeling of disgust which cannot be overcome when this sort of thing is depicted as plainly as it is here.

”Between 1908 and 1912, Native American images were seen more widely on movie screens than ever again. In 1913, “Moving Picture World “reported that “Indian dramas ...are played out” and that film companies were hanging NO INDIANS WANTED signs. That is also the year that James Young Deer — who surfaced briefly in the British and French film industries — essentially vanished from the American movie business.

About the Preservation

A nitrate print of “White Fawn’s Devotion” was located in the New Zealand Film Archive and repatriated though the American Film Institute to the Library of Congress.

Further Reading

A chapter is devoted to James Young Deer’s film career in Andrew Brodie Smith’s “Shooting Cowboys and Indians: Silent Western Films, American Culture, and the Birth of Hollywood” (University Press of Colorado, 2003).

Editor’s Note

Recent research shows James Young Deer was a member of the Nanticoke Nation of Delaware and born in Washington, D.C. See Angela Aleiss’s article in “Bright Lights Film Journal.”http://brightlightsfilm.com/who-was-the-real-james-young-deer-the-mysterious-identity-of-the-pathe-producer-finally-comes-to-light/#.VuGMDEY3J7I

Scott Simmon is Professor of English at UC Davis. His books include The Films of D. W. Griffith (1993) and The Invention of the Western Film (2003). Simmon's informative essays have accompanied the NFPF Treasures DVDs as well as the Foundation’s free online release of Orson Welles’ recently discovered and preserved film  “Too Much Johnson.
”

WIKIPEDIA: WHITE FAWN'S DEVOTION (as of 2020)

White Fawn's Devotion: A Play Acted by a Tribe of Red Indians in America is a 1910 American short dramatic silent film. Although a few writers believe the film features Young Deer's wife, Lillian St. Cyr, otherwise known as Princess Red Wing* as "White Fawn", the lead woman does not fit St. Cyr's description. The movie was shot in New Jersey at 24 fps.

White Fawn's Devotion is the earliest surviving film directed by a Native American. It was one of the earlier films shot in America by the French company Pathé. A reviewer in the New York Dramatic Mirror wrote that the film "proves to be interesting if we can forget the New Jersey scenery" and noted that "it is not quite clear where the devotion comes in, nor of what it consists.".

In 2008, the movie was added to the United States National Film Registry as being deemed "culturally, historically, or aesthetically significant".

Plot

When a settler in the Dakotas gets word that he is to inherit a large fortune, his Native American wife is upset. Believing that she will lose her husband if he returns East, she stabs herself with a knife. Her husband finds her and removes the knife, but their daughter sees him with the knife in his hand and her apparently dead mother. The girl, believing her father committed the murder, alerts the nearby Indian village. Several Indians then engage the settler in a long chase. When the settler is captured, the Indians intend to put him to death until White Fawn miraculously revives and informs the Indians of the truth. This ending, in which an interracial couple ends up together, is a rare occurrence for this period of film production.

Production

James Young Deer (also known as J. Younger Johnston or James Young Johnson), the uncredited director and writer of White Fawn's Devotion, was believed to be the first Native American film director. His ancestors were members of the Nanticoke people of Delaware. Young Deer was hired by Pathé Frères as a director and scenario writer and frequently worked in collaboration with his actress wife Lillian St. Cyr, also known by her stage name Princess Red Wing*. Out of the more than 100 short and a few feature films he made, White Fawn's Devotion is one of fewer than 10 films of Young Deer's to have survived
. 
 
...
 
* P.S. 4 Aug 2021: a comment to this blog by Anonymous: "The lead female in White Fawn's Devotion was not Red Wing. It was actress silent screen Lucille Younge."

Shankhaiski dokument / The Shanghai Document


Yakov Bliokh: The Shanghai Document / Шанхайский документ (1928). Poster design by the Stenberg brothers (Vladimir Stenberg, Georgi Stenberg), signature "2 Stenberg 2". Photo from IMDb.

DZIGA VERTOV XIII
Grand piano: Costas Fotopoulos
Teatro Zancanaro, Sacile, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), 14 Oct 2004

Prog. 13 (68’)

HÄNDE — EINE STUDIE / HANDS — A STUDY (D 1928/29)
Dir: Albrecht Viktor Blum; 35 mm, 233 m, 10’ (20 fps), Bundesarchiv-Filmarchiv, Berlin.
Senza didascalie / No intertitles.

Thomas Tode (GCM): "This is a compilation film made up solely of close-ups of hands, which obviously come from all sorts of films, documentaries as well as feature films. They are edited in short sequences, arranged by association. It starts, for example, with the hands of babies and children (caressing a puppet, moments of play, drawing), and progresses from winding up toy automobiles to grown-up hands acting in traffic (the hands of a tram driver, the gloves of a policeman). Sometimes a narrative is constructed by editing: ringing a front-doorbell, receiving mail, reading notes). Mostly, however, the editing follows semantic contexts, e.g., leisure activities (gardening, playing cards, flower arranging, rowing, swimming), eating (milking a cow’s udder, kneading dough, peeling an apple, eating ice cream, ladling soup, basting a roast), chores (vacuum-cleaning, ironing, sewing, doing the dishes), beauty care (manicuring, shaving a beard and a head, cutting hair). Interestingly, one sequence is devoted to filmcraft, just as in Dziga Vertov’s Man with a Movie Camera (handling a strip of film, animating figures). The "odd one out" is an erotic sequence about women’s hands (repairing stockings, applying lipstick, adjusting a bra, taking off a negligee, conquered by men’s hands, caressing each other). Before things get too saucy, the images are deflected towards decency (putting on a wedding ring, opening a bottle, clinking glasses, applauding). Certain sequences remind us of Vertov’s sometimes humorous associative editing technique, which treats people, things, and animals all alike: rinsing glasses, washing legs, scrubbing the backside, grooming a horse, bathing a dog. It may be of interest to compare this film with Dziga Vertov’s script "Hands Etude" (apparently based on an idea by Aleksandr Rodchenko), reproduced in the chapter "The Kinocs and Left Front of the Arts", in Yuri Tsivian’s Lines of Resistance: Dziga Vertov and the Twenties."

"Blum had already used close-ups of hands (working on machines, crippled fingers) in his film In the Shadow of the Machine, which might have helped inspire his compilation Hands. As this film was never submitted to the censorship committee it can only be dated vaguely, to 1928/29. Blum, who completed two similar compilation films in 1929 (Wasser und Wogen and Quer durch den Sport), justified his methods of compiling in articles. He warned against a director editing his own films because he "rarely musters the ability to view his own work objectively" (Film und Volk, no. 2, December-January 1928/29). In an article in Film-Kurier (1.6.1929), Blum pleads for the documentary form — a term which began to establish itself around that time: "In the archives of every German film production company, e.g., UFA, 100,000 metres of film stock lie unused. Images of life, documents of the existence of man, animals, plants, documents of things, buildings, and towns, things of all sorts, of the customs and practices of tribes and nations, of natural catastrophes, accidents, work processes, daily occurrences, unstaged, as they come before the cameraman’s lens. Cinematographic documents that span the entire life of man today. This abundant wealth of raw material for cultural films [Kulturfilme] remains mostly unused.”
" – THOMAS TODE (GCM)

AA: * One of my favourites. A good discovery. Actual duration of the screening: 11'27".

Yakov Bliokh: The Shanghai Document / Шанхайский документ (1928). Photo from: Центральная студия документальных фильмов / Музей ЦСДФ / CSDF Museum.

SHANKHAISKII DOKUMENT / DAS DOKUMENT VON SCHANGHAI / LE DOCUMENT DE CHANGHAÏ / SHANGHAI DOCUMENT (Sovkino, Moscow, USSR 1928)
Dir/sc: Yakov Bliokh; ph/co-author: V. Stepanov; asst. ed: Lev Filonov; didascalie / intertitles: Viktor Pertsov; premiere: 1.5.1928, Moscow; lunghezza originale / orig. length: 1850 m (per Kulturfilmkatalog 1929–1930 des Kino-Kontor der Handelsvertretung der UdSSR in Deutschland, p. 38), 1700 m (per Leyda, Kino); 35 mm, 1460 m, 58’ (22 fps), Gosfilmofond, Moscow.
Didascalie in russo / Russian intertitles.

Thomas Tode (GCM): "Soviet film of the 1920s is a cinema of montage and authorship. A case in point is the first significant feature-length documentary which also had a tremendous resonance abroad: Yakov Bliokh’s Shankhaiskii Dokument (Shanghai Document, USSR 1928). This can be regarded as a prototype of the "operative" film (Tretyakov), a film of counter-information. The opening sequences show Shanghai harbour and life in the Chinese and European quarters of the city. The hard work of over-burdened coolies is contrasted with the indolence of property-owning Europeans and the Chinese elite in a series of powerful images: an exhausted coolie peeks through a fence and catches a glimpse of the European bourgeoisie enjoying bathing and cocktails; the wheels of his cart dissolve into the spinning records of dancing hedonists; a giant treadmill powered by coolies is transformed into a carousel with laughing European children, followed by images of the hard work of Chinese children in silk mills and phosphorous-poisoned match factories."

"There is turmoil in the city. Revolutionaries fill the streets, and take over command in March 1927. The Europeans hide in their enclaves behind sandbags, call for battleships, and have regular troops and tanks land. The "Southern Army" of the Kuomintang under Chiang Kai-Shek moves into the city and initiates a bloody split with the rebellious workers and the previously allied Communists. Bound prisoners are executed. In the end, Chiang Kai-Shek is branded as "the betrayer of the Chinese revolution". What is interesting in terms of the portrayal of power is that Bliokh has obscured the delicate role of the Soviet Union with its financial and military support of Chiang Kai-Shek, and turned a factual defeat into a moral victory for the Communist workers by invoking Chiang Kai-Shek’s "betrayal"."

"The epoch-making qualities of this film are the "discovery" of parallel montage as a political tool, the analytical view of the camera, and the journalistically clear-cut stance. The author insists — not least of all with the film’s title — that this is a presentation of documented practices of oppression and exploitation. His break with the postcard idyll previously conventional in travelogues is sharp and final, which contemporaries also acknowledged in their reviews: "The cultural film [Kulturfilm] must attain documentary value. This documentary value, however, will never be without a political flavor" (Film und Volk, no. 1, November 1928, p. 4). Bliokh’s parallel montage conjoins images that have no spatial or temporal relation to one another per se; instead these relations are first produced by the montage (as in Vertov’s films). Precisely because this is transparent for the audience, it is made explicit that this is an "interpretation" of the world as it appears, specifically from a Socialist perspective: a "Communist decoding of the visible world" (Kino-Eye: The Writings of Dziga Vertov, Berkeley, 1984, p. 79). The subtle difference between (justified) partisanship and propaganda is found where a person passing judgment is palpable behind the description. Through the revealing of the individual strategy of representation, the object loses authenticity, but the representation gains it. Authenticity is thus not an intention-less characteristic of images, no a priori given natural occurrence, but rather has to be understood as the form and result of media representation."

"The bulk of the footage, however, stems from the times before the uprising (e.g., the Chinese New Year celebrations). According to the credits, Stepanov was not only the cameraman but also co-author during this Sovkino expedition. Some of the depicted occurrences can be dated very precisely, to March and April of 1927 (the occupation of the city by the "Southern Army", and the ensuing massacre). Conspicuously, the film opened in Moscow one year later, on the 1st of May 1928. Even an extensive editing process cannot serve as an explanation for this delay, taking into account that Bliokh was said to be — according to Viktor Shklovsky — a talented organizer who decided quickly. The topicality of the events seems to have been not too relevant, although the "Chinese Revolution" had been given a lot of media coverage in the Soviet Union. Apparently the Soviets wanted to monitor political developments in China, a situation that was a pivotal point in the controversy between Stalin and Trotsky. Stalin supported Chiang Kai-Shek, whereas Trotsky strictly opposed any support."

"Anyhow, Shanghai Document was very popular with the Moscow public. Jay Leyda even goes so far as to mention it as a personal triumph for Bliokh. The film also proved to be a hit with Communist movements in foreign countries. (Distributed in the US by Amkino, it was shown at the Cameo Theatre in New York City in late 1928, where it was reviewed as A Shanghai Document.) That Shanghai Document is indeed a film d’auteur was illustrated by an unexpected incident in Germany: The Communist film company Prometheus had claimed the film as a German film production, probably as a means of circumnavigating the very restrictive import quota. The film was intended to be a shining example of the quality production program to follow. They claimed that it was a film by Friedrich Lienhard (= Karl Schulz, a parliamentary representative of the Communist Party and activist of the Communist press), edited by Albrecht Viktor Blum, with intertitles by Franz Höllering (see, for example, Lichtbild-Bühne, no. 271, 10.11.1928). In fact, this was only true for the production of the (slightly shortened) German version. This prompted the film’s furious actual director, Yakov Bliokh, to demand a public correction in the press (e.g., in Close Up, no. 2, February 1929, p. 76 fn.). The emphasis on authorship to this point was an issue only in feature films, not in documentary. The scandal surrounding this prototypical film in the field of documentary filmmaking highlights the issue of films and authorship."

"The prints of the film available today are significantly different. Regarding the political message (Chiang Kai-Shek as a traitor), Gosfilmofond’s Russian print is closest to the original of 1928, as a comparison with articles of the time reveals. It is this version, bought by the Library of Congress in 1990, that was thoroughly examined and commented upon by Nicholas J. Cull and Arthur Waldron in their article "Shanghai Document — Shankhaiskii Dokument (1928): Soviet Film Propaganda and the Shanghai Rising of 1927", in Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television, no. 3, 1996 (pp. 309–331), which includes a list of all the film’s intertitles in English. However, numerous sequences of the "Northern Army" leaving the city, and the "Southern Army" occupying the city are missing from this print."

"These sequences can be found in the Cinémathèque Suisse’s (16 mm) print, which probably originates from the Swiss Prometheus version that circulated in Switzerland from 1929 (all intertitles bear the name of the Prometheus company). Some passages at the end of the film deviate from the editing of the Gosfilmfond print (e.g., the speeches of the members of the military). More important, Chiang Kai-Shek is not called a "betrayer", but is referred to obediently as the "Generalissimo", and his political program concerning the insurgents has been changed from "retribution without delay!" to "moderation, reconciliation, entente". All these alterations might have arisen from diplomatic considerations about Chiang Kai-Shek, who meanwhile became his country’s central figure."

"In both versions the treadmill powered by coolies which is transformed into a carousel with laughing European children is missing (the children themselves can be seen in all prints). The treadmill can be found in an English print from the archives of ETV (Stanley’s Forman’s Educational and Television Films, Ltd.), now in Britain’s National Film and Television Archive. According to Ivor Montagu, this 10-12-minute compilation of Shanghai Document was made to promote the Film and Photo League. Gerd Roscher quotes about 7 minutes from it (among other images, the treadmill) in his documentary Wir machen unsere Filme selbst, Teil 1: Arbeiterfilm im Deutschland der 20er Jahre (BRD, 1978, 45 min). He substituted German intertitles for the English ones.
" – THOMAS TODE (GCM)

AA: * A favourite of mine. I saw this famous film for the first time. Shocking: the executions. As a rule the print is good, with fine definition. Actual duration of the screening: 62'41" = 63 min.