Wednesday, June 27, 2018

Garmon / Accordion



Garmon / Accordion. Zoya Fedorova as Marusenka.

Гармонь. Музыкальная комедия / Harmonikka / La fisarmonica.
    Director: Igor’ Savčenko. Year: 1934. Country: URSS
    Scen.: Aleksandr Žarov, Igor’ Savčenko. F.: Evgenij Šnejder, Julij Fogel’man. Scgf.: Valentina Chmelëva. Mus.: Sergej Potockij. Int.: Pëtr Savin (Timoška), Zoja Fëdorova (Marusen’ka), Igor’ Savčenko (il cupo), Nikolaj Jaročkin (il malizioso), Nikolaj Zyrjanov (il ragazzo vestito alla marinara). Prod.: Mežrabpomfilm. 35 mm. D.: 56’. Bn.
    Print from Gosfilmofond of Russia.
    E-subtitles in English and Italian by Sub-Ti Londra.
    Viewed at Sala Scorsese, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato, Second Utopia: 1934 – the Golden Age of Soviet Sound Film, 27 June 2018

Peter Bagrov (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "In textbooks Garmon’ is often credited as the first Soviet musical. Maybe. ‘An idyll’ would be a more suitable definition. But if it is a musical, it is a very unconventional one indeed. On the other hand, what should one expect from a feature-length adaptation of a short poem? Igor’ Savčenko had a most Garmon’ 163 eclectic artistic background: a native Ukrainian, he was studying with a highbrow professor of acting in Leningrad, and afterwards started his career as the director of a very leftist avant-garde semi-professional Theatre of Young Workers (TRAM) in Baku, the capital of Azerbaijan. He made two short films in Baku, both were banned. Nevertheless, he was offered a job at Mežrabpomfilm, a company aimed at entertainment and profits (a rather exotic goal in Soviet Russia of the 1930s)."

"The advent of sound called for new genres. And Savčenko suggested a simple story with rhymed dialogue, infiltrated with singing and dancing. The best accordion player in the village is elected secretary of the village Komsomol (Young Communist League). He decides to lead a serious life from then on and buries his accordion in a haystack. Life without music becomes dull, until a kulak, an enemy of the state, appears from his Siberian exile with his own accordion and his own ‘kulak music’. The only way to save the village from his influence, to destroy him, is to exhume the ‘Soviet accordion’…"

"The plot is deliberately silly. But it isn’t just a comedy. It is also a very poetic film, highly influenced by Dovženko. If Dovženko had decided to turn Earth into a comedy, he would have made something like Garmon’. There is a most unusual camera style – Evgenij Šnejder was a refined cinematographer with a taste for eccentric angles and expressionist lighting. To make things even more complicated, Savčenko decided to turn field labor (such as harvesting) into musical numbers – several years later this technique became the core of Ivan Pyriev’s famous collective farm musicals.
Never make such rubbish as Garmon’ again”, said Stalin. Thus began Igor’ Savčenko’s remarkable film career. Not only did he become a versatile film director, he was also a legendary professor of film: among his pupils were Marlen Chuciev and Sergej Paradžanov." Peter Bagrov

AA: Last month in Rochester I saw Jolly Fellows, also often credited as the first Soviet musical. It premiered on 25 December 1934. I am not able to find the premiere date of Accordion but presumably it must have been earlier so it would indeed have to be the first.

In his illuminating introduction Peter Bagrov singled out among other things the contribution of Yevgeni Schneider, one of the best Soviet cinematographers, of for instance Fragment of an Empire. Igor Savchenko in Accordion invented the theme of harvesting as a rewarding motif for a musical: the rhythmical movement, the joy of collective work. That became a motif for the kolkhoz musicals of Ivan Pyriev. In Soviet cinema love was portrayed as pure and chaste, but the passion of the harvest scenes was a way of sublimation of the energy of physical love. Himself influenced by Dovzhenko, Savchenko died young but as a professor of VGIK taught a remarkable generation of talent including Alov, Naumov, Paradzhanov, and Khutsiev (still alive at age 92). None of them became clones of him. (Résumé of Peter's introduction)

In early Soviet sound cinema music was of the essence as we saw yesterday in the Song About Happiness. The composer in Accordion was Sergei Pototsky who also composed By the Bluest of Seas for Boris Barnet. The songs are infectious, with refrains such as "From far away", "The sun goes down to rest", "Sing a song of harvest", "A lovely romantic evening was coming", "No end in sight for our land", and "Polka Komsomolka".

The diabolical kulak seducer (the actor is not credited but he is the director Igor Savchenko himself, revealed Peter) plays tunes such as "A glass of vodka on the table". He is seducing the villagers to drink. He tries to harass the leading lady (at first superbly able to defend herself, making the seducer a laughing stock for all, but then threatened by a whole group of men). He spreads slogans about "down with the Soviet power" and breaks the window of the Komsomol quarters. The hero grabs a gun but then decides: "we don't need to shoot them, quite the opposite".

Instead of the gun, the hero fetches his accordion which he has buried deep into the haystack, having reasoned that serious kolkhoz duties and musical merriment don't mix. But love and joy are indispensable, too.

Soviet films were Troyan horses. Accordion is a propaganda vehicle which portrays the Soviet countryside as full of joy and abundance with slogans such as "big harvests all over the Soviet Union" and "affluent life has come to collective farms". The audience knew otherwise. Meanwhile the crazy humour and the affirmation of life in films like this convey elements and continuities of poetry and subversion.

Wanjia denghuo / Lights of Ten Thousand Homes




萬家燈火 / 万家灯火 / Myriad of Lights / Les Lumières de dix milles foyers / [Luci di diecimila case]
    Director: Shen Fu. Year: 1948. Country: Cina.
    Shen Fu. F.: Zhu Jinming. M.: Wu Tingfang, Fu Zhengyi. Mus.: Wang Yunjie. Int.: Shangguan Yunzhu (Lan Youlan), Lan Ma (Hu Zhiqing), Wu Ying (la madre di Hu). Qi Heng (Qian Jianzhu), Gao Zheng (Xiao Zhao), Li Huanqing (Ah Zhen). Prod.: Kunlun. DCP. D.: 115’. Bn.
    Music selections include "Clair de lune" by Claude Debussy.
    Chinese version with French subtitles.
    DCP from Centre de Documentation sur le Cinéma Chinois (Paris).
    DCP from the Collection Films from The Chinese Embassy.
    E-subtitles in English and Italian by Sub-Ti Londra.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato, The Rebirth of Chinese Cinema (1941-1951), 27 June 2018

Marie Claire Kuo and Kuo Kwan Leung (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "Wanjia Denghuo was produced by Kunlun, established in Shanghai by Xia Yunhu and his communist friends after they reopened the second studio of Lianhua where they had worked in the 1930s. The scenario, written by Yang Hansheng and Shen Fu, highlights the desperate situation of many Shanghai people during the last years of the civil war, by choosing one average family, among many others, who could not live decently in a society rotten with corruption, and where little hope was left to those who worked hard without being rewarded. The film was delayed several times by the Kuomintang censorship."

"Shen Fu (1905–1994) had worked at Lianhua as director and scenarist on famous films like Langshan dixue ji (Blood on Wolf-Mountain, Fei Mu, 1936), starring Lan Ping before she married Mao, and for that, he was later prosecuted by her. After the war, he joined Kunlun and directed Wanjia Denghuo and Xiwang zai renjian (Hope in the World), both interpreted by Shangguan Yunzhu and Lan Ma."

"Shangguan Yunzhu (1920–1968) had never studied acting but she was so talented that she could play any type of character with equal success: the high society lady in Yijiang chunshui xiang dong liu (Spring River Flows East, Cai Chusheng, Zheng Junli, 1947); the demi-mondaine in Taitai wansui(Long Live the Wife, Sang Hu, 1947); the middle-class wife in Wanjia Denghuo; the old actress in Wutai Jiemei (Stage Sisters, Xie Jin, 1965) or the peasant in Kumu feng chun (Spring Comes to the Withered Tree, Zheng Junli 1961). Persecuted during the Cultural Revolution, she committed suicide in 1968." Marie Claire Kuo and Kuo Kwan Leung

Tony Rayns (Il Cinema Ritrovato): ""Alongside Wenhua, The Peak Film Industries Corp (aka Kunlun) energised Shanghai film culture in the late 40s / early 50s with a string of social-realist melodramas which combined Borzage-like pictures of romantic tribulations with covert political activism. Several Peak projects had been vetoed by Kuomintang censors when the company’s head writer Yang Hansheng and writer-director Shen Fu, both leftist veterans of 30s cinema, came up with Wanjia Denghuo. Shot in the studio but with vivid documentary inserts of life on Shanghai’s streets, the film focuses on the plight of the emerging middle class. As the title suggests, the Hu family is seen as representative of thousands of others."

"It starts with positive images – domestic bliss, a well-run company, happy good-time girls on the make – but soon hints at dark shadows: hyper-inflation strains the household budget, the press reports rumours of business chicanery, and a letter brings news of starvation in the countryside. By the time that a large crowd of relatives from the home village arrives to stay in the cash-strapped Hu household, a tide of familial and financial disasters is let loose: unemployment, duplicity, rage and miscarriage beset Hu Zhiqing (Lan Ma, excellent) and those around him. The ending points up an obvious political moral (solidarity is the answer!), but the lively mise en scène maintains a certain dramatic tension – and delivers a rather fine montage of delirium in the closing reel." Tony Rayns

AA: A devastating family story from contemporary Shanghai: relatives in the countryside have heard that the Hu family is living in a big house in the big city, but when they arrive they realize that the Hu couple is living in a little room in a big block. The extended family is on the point of breaking many times, but they always finally decide to stay together.

The clash of the country folks and the city folks gives material to many moments of comedy and tragedy. At the same time there is a generation clash and a clash between tradition and modernity.

The father of the Hu family is an honest man who gets to suffer for his character. "Are you so naive that you think it pays to be honest?" But he cannot be otherwise. It's all downhill after he gets unemployed yet has more mouths to feed. Even a new baby is on its way, but there is miscarriage.

The most formidable character in the movie is the old mother (see image above). There is a sense of matriarchy in this family saga.

A recurrent plot motif in Shanghai cinema seems to be that a poor person brings a rich person's lost wallet back to him and is beaten for that. That also happens to Hu when he is experiencing a nadir of poverty. After that he becomes a victim of hit and run, by his former boss who has fired him, of all people.

An ok print which occasionally betrays the duped quality of its sources.

Now I'll Tell (UCLA restoration)


Edwin J. Burke: Now I'll Tell / När New York sover [While New York Sleeps] (US 1934). The Swedish poster from the IMDb where there is also a fine photo gallery of the film.

Edwin J. Burke: Now I'll Tell (US 1934). Spencer Tracy (Murray Golden), Helen Twelvetrees (Virginia Golden).

New Yorkin nukkuessa / När New York sover.
    US 1934. Prod.: Winfield R. Sheehan per Fox Film Corporation. 
    Director: Edwin J. Burke. Sog.: dall’autobiografia di Mrs. Arnold Rothstein [Carolyn Green Rothstein]. Scen.: Edwin J. Burke. F.: Ernest Palmer - b. M.: Harold D. Schuster. Scgf.: Jack Otterson.
    Int.: Spencer Tracy (Murray Golden), Helen Twelvetrees (Virginia Golden), Alice Faye (Peggy Warren), Robert Gleckler (Al Mossiter), Henry O’Neill (Tommy Doran), Hobart Cavanaugh (Freddie Stanton), J. P. Huntley (Jack Hart), Shirley Temple (Mary Doran), Ronnie Cosby (Tommy Doran, Jr.).
    87 min
    Restored by UCLA Film and Television Archive with funding provided by The Louis B. Mayer Foundation, Eleanor and Glenn Padnick, The Packard Humanities Institute, and the Estate of Ronald Terry Shedlo.
    35 mm print from UCLA Film & Television Archive.
    Courtesy of 20th Century Fox and Park Circus.
    Sottotitoli in italiano di Sub-Ti Londra.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (William Fox Presents: Rediscoveries from The Fox Film Corporation), 27 June 2018.

Ehsan Khoshbakht (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "The story of the “biggest gambler in New York”, charting his rise and fall between 1909 and 1928. A tale of affairs, gambling addiction and gang rivalry, Now I’ll Tell is based on the life of Arnold Rothstein, a notorious and well-connected gangster who was also the inspiration for Meyer Wolfsheim in The Great Gatsby. The film is more closely connected with real events, being written by ‘Mrs. Arnold Rothstein’, a pseudonym of Carolyn Greene (later Carolyn Rothstein Behar), the gangster’s widow."

"Despite its adherence to certain facts and its sense of realism (photographs of Rothstein’s regular haunt and ‘favourite office’, Lindy’s restaurant, were taken for the purposes of a studio reconstruction) it does not closely follow Rothstein’s memoir, published a week before the film was released."

"Writer Edwin J. Burke (1889–1944) moved to Hollywood in the year that Rothstein was killed. Now I’ll Tell was the only picture he directed, although he co-directed the retakes of Hello, Sister! (1933). He stayed in Hollywood for seventeen years before returning to the East Coast. In between he wrote everything from Shirley Temple vehicles to Bad Girl (Frank Borzage, 1931), for which he won an Oscar. Burke’s winning ticket was his rapport with Spencer Tracy which, in spite of the star’s problems with alcohol, brought out the best in him. Tracy humanises the story, setting it apart from the other key gangster films of the early 1930s such as Little Caesar and Public Enemy. Unlike the protagonists in those films, Tracy’s Golden is anything but monstrous and destructive. The film also reveals the unglamorous and political aspects of power, in its depiction of an America where becoming corrupt is easier than remaining unaffected."

"The film did well in New York – where the circumstances of Rothstein’s death were still subject to rumours – but failed elsewhere, adding to the growing list of unsuccessful Tracy pictures made for Fox, before his eventual move to Metro."

"Long available only in a censored reissued version, Now I’ll Tell has now been restored to its original 87 minute length." Ehsan Khoshbakht

AA: In the history of the gangster film Now I'll Tell belongs to a rare line which had been launched by City Streets, directed by Rouben Mamoulian from a story by Dashiell Hammett. In this tradition gangsters are portrayed as businessmen, a trend which culminated later in the Godfather trilogy.

The screenplay has been freely inspired by the life of Arnold Rothstein, considered to be the founding father of organized crime in the U.S. (David Pietrusza, 2011). Gambling is the business here. Gambling at the racetrack, cards, and boxing are elements in common with the real Rothstein.

Spencer Tracy often portrayed criminals in the early stage of his career, in films such as Up the River, Quick Millions, 20 000 Years in Sing Sing, and The Mad Game. In many legendary gangster films of the early 1930s such as The Public Enemy, Little Caesar, and Scarface the protagonists were criminals who seemed to relish violence.

Because Murray Golden (as the Rothstein figure portrayed by Spencer Tracy is called) is a businessman, he avoids violence, yet there is an incessant concern for violence. But Murray Golden works with his brains, not fists or guns. He is an incarnation of moral hazard, and moral void, as long as money is concerned. "You can do anything you can get away with" is his motto.

This is the earliest film I have seen with Alice Faye, the first great "Fox blonde", to be followed by Betty Grable, June Haver and Marilyn Monroe. She was the only one who got to deliver pre-Code dialogue such as "I was born on the Virgin Islands". "You must have left early", quips Spencer Tracy.

There is a structure familiar from crime films: Golden has a childhood friend, Tommy Doran, who is a policeman. Doran is a happy family man and as a policeman his integrity is inviolable, proof that most policemen don't participate in the Tammany Hall web of corruption. Another great Fox star, Shirley Temple, appears in a bit role as Doran's daughter.

Some details of the movie have documentary interest such as location shooting and a reproduction of Lindy's, the famous New York restaurant which was closed in February 2018. (I digress. Tom Wolfe died earlier this year, and I can't help laughing when I remember a favourite piece of his called "The Purveyor of Public Life", an interview with Bob Harrison, conducted at Lindy's while enjoying lox, bagels, and coffee. In the beginning of the piece Harrison is astounded when Wolfe claims he does not know Lindy's. Some might discover in Wolfe a hint of anti-semitism, but I believe the opposite, that Wolfe was so far beyond racism like Tarantino that he could play around.)

Most significantly Now I'll Tell departs from the Rothstein story in that Golden is not involved in bootleg liquor or drugs (Rothstein is sometimes considered to be the father of organized drug dealing).

Based on Mrs. Arnold Rothstein's eponymous autobiography, Now I'll Tell focuses on the love affair of Murray and Virginia Golden. Although Murray has affairs on the side Virginia is his only true love. Virginia is disappointed when Murray breaks his promise to quit gambling when he has collected a fortune of a half a million dollars. When the affair with Peggy Warren (Alice Faye) becomes public she quits him. "My love to you. I'm sorry I've lost that. I guess you never loved me".

A brilliant UCLA print.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: DATA FROM THE AFI CATALOG:

Tuesday, June 26, 2018

Pesnya o shchastye / Song About Happiness


Pesnya o shchastye / Song about Happiness. Mikhail Viktorov (Kavyrlya), Yanina Zhejmo (Anuk).

Песня о счастье / Pesn’ o sčast’e / [La canzone della felicità] / Pesnja o stshastje.
    Directors: Mark Donskoj, Vladimir Legošin. Year: 1934. Country: URSS.
    Scen.: Georgij Cholmskij con modifiche di Michail Blejman. F.: Nikolaj Ušakov. Scgf.: Semën Mejnkin. Mus.: Grigorij Lobačëv. Supervisione artistica: Sergej Jutkevič. Int.: Vladimir Gardin (il professore di musica), Janina Žejmo (Anuk), Michail Viktorov (Kavyrlja), Boris Tenin (Goroch), Boris Čirkov (capo del reparto disciplinare del carcere), Fëdor Nikitin (l’insegnante di musica), Ignatij Moskvin (il taglialegna di Lebedev), Leonid Kmit (Grjaznov), Nikolaj Mičurin (Lebedev / nonna di Anuk). Prod.: Vostokfilm. 35 mm. D.: 85’. Bn.
    Not released in Finland.
    Print from Gosfilmofond of Russia.
    Introduce Peter Bagrov.
    Viewed with e-subtitles in English and Italian at Sala Scorsese, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Second Utopia: 1934 – the Golden Age of Soviet Sound Film), 26 June 2018.

Peter Bagrov (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "Mark Donskoj, an enfant terrible, a madman (or an actor – there still isn’t a consensus here), was rarely taken seriously by his Soviet colleagues. It was the adoring interest of the Italian neo-realists and later the critics of “Cahiers du cinéma” in his masterpieces The Gor’kij Trilogy (1937-39), Raduga (Rainbow, 1943) and Dorogoj cenoj (The Horse That Cried, 1958) that finally made Donskoj’s compatriots recognize his significance. Pesn’ o sčast’e is Mark Donskoj’s first sound film, and the first one where his aesthetics and philosophy are clearly visible."

"It was intended to be a film of little importance. As were all the pictures produced by Vostokfilm, a nomad film company cruising around the eastern part of the Soviet Union to portray the lives of the locals. Donskoj and his co-director Vladimir Legošin (three years later he directed one of the best Soviet films for children, Beleet parus odinokij / Lone White Sail) were to make a film about Maris, a Finno-Ugric people who lived in Russia along the Volga river."

"Neither Donskoj nor Legošin were interested in ethnography. But both were happy to choose ‘a man of nature’ as their protagonist. His activities were minimized, and the actor Michail Viktorov’s duty was to tactfully blend into trees and waters (Nikolaj Ušakov’s poetic photography was a vitally significant component here). Or into music – little relies on human speech, but a flute is almost a full-fledged character, and some of the most emotionally rich ‘dialogue’ and ‘monologue’ belongs to it."


"What was supposed to become yet another ‘optimistic drama’ (the beloved genre of the Soviets) about the formation of a class-conscious character turned into something between a fairy tale, a miracle-play and an eccentric comedy. Upon its release, Pesn’ o sčast’e was received gleefully. It was hard to tell what the film was about, but one thing was clear: Donskoj had an ability to turn whatever he touched into cinema." (Peter Bagrov)

AA: I was surprised to hear Peter Bagrov's introduction on Mark Donskoy. I was not aware how little he was regarded in Russia. In the West "the Gorky of the cinema" was admired for The Childhood of Gorky and At High Cost, "the Tristan and Isolde of Ukraine", and many other films full of passion and genuine cinematic grandeur. Personally I have had a special fondness for Foma Gordeev, the growing-up story of a rich merchant's son with an epic sense of life on the Volga.

Donskoy usually focused on pre-revolutionary history and rarely depicted Soviet reality with the exception of the war years. Perhaps the experience of Song About Happiness helps explain. Kavyrlya, the wild boy from the woods, is taken into prison, and Gulag is the best thing that can happen to him. This preposterous propaganda plot must have felt embarrassing for Donskoy.

Donskoy's great theme was education understood in the most profound way. He showed people living in ignorance and conditions of backwardness. "In Gorky I was always fascinated by the theme of suppressed talent, the man of the people whose talent remains unfulfilled when in other circumstances, in a society of true freedom, it might shine in the colours of the rainbow".

Song About Happiness is the first film in which Donskoy finds this dearest theme of his. The boy from the backwoods becomes a master musician. And the girl from the backwoods gets educated, as well, defying her community who does everything to belittle and discourage her. The love story is unconventional. The boy is determined to change his identity and denies the girl, too, for a very long time.

Song About Happiness is not a good film: often clumsy, often uneven, yet with much to like. Besides the deeply felt theme of education there is the sense of nature, and especially the river, the key element for Gorky and Donskoy with all its symbolic values present in a fresh and original fashion. The river is more specifically usually the Volga as it is even here.

The protagonists stem from the Mari people, but I am unable to comment on the accuracy of the details of Mari life. The Mari (the Cheremis) are a Finno-Ugric people from the bend of the Volga. The Maris are the only European people among whom ancient nature worship survives as a living tradition. This sense is vaguely reflected in Song About Happiness.

For instance the fascinating theme of the ban of the image is dealt with. Image means death.

The Mari intelligentsia fell victim to genocide under Stalin's Great Terror. All learned Maris were executed or perished in the Gulag in the 1930s. Knowing this casts a special shadow on the young lovers of Song About Happiness.

A special feature in Song About Happiness is that there are passages of dialogue and even a final speech in the Mari language, untranslated. Also Mari language newspapers are on display. It would be interesting to hear a Mari commenting all this.

Fine performances by Mikhail Viktorov whose other films I have not seen and Yanina Zhejmo, one of the most prominent actresses of the Soviet cinema since the earliest films of Kozintsev and Trauberg.

Boris Chirkov (the lead actor of the Maxim trilogy) is seen as the fair and firm prison camp commander. With leaders like him the Gulag would have been the best place on Earth. The professor of the conservatory is played by none other than Vladimir Gardin (1877–1965), a great figure of the Russian cinema, director and actor from 1912 until 1950, and a founder of the VGIK film school.

The music score is wonderful, ranging from simple folk tunes to revelations in J. S. Bach at the Conservatorium, with the flute being the lead instrument as observed by Peter Bagrov above.

The visual quality is often good enough  but sometimes the sources have been inferior.

Ella Bergmann-Michel - La donna con la Kinamo 2


Joris Ivens & Mannus Franken: Regen (1929).

The Woman with The Kinamo: Ella Bergmann-Michel
    Introduce Madeleine Bernstorff
    Piano accompaniment by Matti Bye
    Viewed at Cinema Lumiere - Sala Officinema/Mastroianni, Tuesday 26/06/2018

REGEN / Rain / Pioggia
    Director: Joris Ivens, Mannus Franken. Year: 1929. Country: Olanda.
    Sog., Scen.: Mannus Franken, Joris Ivens. F., M.: Joris Ivens. Mus.: Hanns Eisler. Prod.: Capi-Holland. DCP. D.: 11’. Bn
    Restored in 2005 with the original music of Hanns Eisler
    DCP from EYE.
    Courtesy of Mannus Franken Foundation and Tamasa Distribution.

Tom Gunning: "Regen explores the effects of a single rain shower on a modern city, creating a synthesized view point through editing, moving across space and time (Ivens, of course, shot many downpours in order to create this single filmic one), allowing us to live through an everyday event with all the vividness cinema offers. Ivens’ camera is alert not only to visual patterns of reflection and refraction, of textures transformed by the sheen of moisture or an atmosphere veiled by soft rain, but also participates in the human interaction with this environment. The unforgettable moment of the little girls scampering through the frame wrapped in a blanket to shelter themselves inspired Ivens’ observation, “the skipping movements of their legs had the rhythm of raindrops”. This analogy cues us to the logic of Ivens’ lyrical editing and its role as a guide to a heightened power of observation. Unlike many avant-garde filmmakers of the late Twenties, Ivens does not subordinate such human moments to the logic of an edited rhythm. Rather, the human body and its blend of grace and awkwardness becomes the basis for a cinematic rhythm built from the gestures, and patterns of bodily motion. Ivens forges the link between visual observation and lyrical transformation with a filmic poetry that comes from a clarity of perception, and a direct participation in bodily motion." Tom Gunning, Joris Ivens, Filmmaker of the Twentieth Century, of the Netherlands and the World in Cinema without Borders. The Films of Joris Ivens, European Foundation Joris Ivens, Nijmegen 2002

"Ella Bergmann-Michel saw Regen in a matinee in May 1931, organised by the Bund Neues Frankfurt and their film club. She was deeply impressed and Joris Ivens recommended that she use the Kinamo camera to shoot her films." Madeleine Bernstorff

AA: Revisited the Joris Ivens / Mannus Franken masterpiece which we have also screened in a live performance with this same score by Hanns Eisler, "14 Arten den Regen zu beschreiben", later dedicated to Arnold Schönberg. The film also brings to mind Andrei Tarkovsky's book Sculpting in Time where he discusses the many manifestations of water as expressions of time.


Wahlkampf 1932.

WAHLKAMPF 1932 (LETZTE WAHL) / Election Campaign 1932 (Last Election).
    Director: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Year: 1932. Country: Germania.
    F., M.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Prod.: Ella Bergmann-Michel, Paul Seligman. 35 mm. L.: 240 m. D.: 13‘ a 16 f/s. Bn.
    Courtesy of Sünke Michel.

Madeleine Bernstorff: "In August 1932, in the Bund neues Frankfurt group magazine, news appeared of the closure of the Bauhaus in Dessau by the town council, the sign of a political situation that was now coming to a head. Ella Bergmann-Michel was already under police surveillance during the filming of her documentary on street vendors. In the autumn of 1932, during the last free electoral campaign, she walked the streets of Frankfurt with her camera, documenting the streets decorated with banners, the electoral manifestos posted on columns, a march of Nazis in uniform taken overhead from the window of her studio, the endless discussions between people on the street, a large demonstration on the banks of the Main and, finally, a Nazi electoral office. There, she filmed a street fight but was arrested and forced to hand over the film. She managed to save the material filmed beforehand, but was no longer able to edit it. These clips convey a very vivid picture of the conflicts at the time, and the lack of editing gives us the perception of a daily life at risk and the radicalization of the political situation." Madeleine Bernstorff

Ella Bergmann-Michel: "I succeeded in documenting the Frankfurt streets and alleys, already adorned with swastika flags and the hammer and sickle as well as with the well-known flag with three arrows. Then I had to stop filming for political reasons. (Filmstrips, photos and reports were published in the next to last issue of the journal “Die neue Stadt”, “Bund das neue Frankfurt”, volume 6, number 10.) It was January 1933." Ella Bergmann-Michel

AA: An ominous documentary on the last year of democracy before the Nazi takeover.

Fischfang in der Rhön.

FISCHFANG IN DER RHÖN (AN DER SINN) / Fishing in the Rhön (at the Sinn)
    Director: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Year: 1932. Country: Germania.
    F., M.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Int.: Robert Michel. Prod.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. 16 mm. L.: 93 m. D.: 11‘ a 16 f/s. Bn.    The film was shot on 35 mm but only a 16 mm print survived.
    Print from DIF Deutsches Filminstitut Filmmuseum.
    Courtesy of Sünke Michel.

Madeleine Bernstorff: "This is the film that best represents the merging of Ella Bergmann-Michel’s artistic activity and her documentary work. There are also echoes of Joris Ivens’ film Regen: “Water landscapes as transparent surfaces, a vision of alienated nature, devoid of technical effects. The close-ups, details and overhead shots without a horizon create a feeling of flatness; the vegetation, reflected symmetrically on the water, is transformed into a graphic element, just like the vivid reflections of light on the waves […]. These spaces, lacking perspective, are reminiscent, on the one hand, of the experimental photographic landscapes of Ella Bergmann-Michel and, on the other, her collages made using layers of multi-coloured tracing paper” (Jutta Hercher)." Madeleine Bernstorff

"The fourth film, Fischfand in der Rhon, interested me mostly because fishing had been the impetus for my walk: I managed to catch the trout jumping in the river at dusk with my camera." Ella Bergmann-Michel

AA: Lyrical impressions of fishers catching fish and crawfish.

MEIN HERZ SCHLÄGT BLAU / Blue Is the Beat of My Heart.
    Director: Jutta Hercher, Maria Hemmleb. Year: 1989. Country: Germania Ovest.
    F., M.: Jutta Hercher, Maria Hemmleb. Mus.: Ernst Bechert. Prod.: Jutta Hercher per Westdeutscher Rundfunk. DCP. D.: 30‘. Col.
    DCP from Deutsche Kinemathek.
    Courtesy of Jutta Hercher.

Madeleine Bernstorff: "This portrait of Ella Bergmann-Michel, enriched with photographs, film clips, drawings and collages, links her artistic work to the use of cinema as an instrument of social reform, talks about her grotesque collages, strongly influenced by science and technology, her pacifist aspirations, the photographic experiments then used by the artist as preparatory studies for her short films, the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Film, and the film society she ran. The documentary opens in a desolate Schmelzmühle, the mill that had been home to the ‘local modern art museum’ and a meeting place for artists and art lovers, and where Ella Bergmann-Michel and her family went ‘underwater’ during Nazism. There are the voices of people close to the artist, such as the Dadaist Kurt Schwitters as well as her son Hans Michel, and obviously her own voice: “Our life is abstract, while painting is tangible once again. Yet, who knows, if the world becomes tangible again, we’ll have to paint abstract once more”. " Madeleine Bernstorff

AA: A documentary portrait of Ella Bergmann-Michel, finely tuned to her approaches as an artist.

Geheimnisvolle Tiefe / Mysterious Shadows (2018 restoration Filmmuseum München)


Geheimnisvolle Tiefe / Mysterious Shadows. Cornelia (Ilse Werner) caught between two men. One is obsessed with money. The other with the study of the past: Dr. Benn Wittich (Paul Hubschmid).

Profondità misteriose.
    Director: G. W. Pabst. Year: 1949. Country: Austria.
    Scen.: Gertrude Pabst, Walter von Hollander. F.: Helmuth Ashley, Hans Schneeberger. Scgf.: Isabell Schlichting, Werner Schlichting. Mus.: Roland Kovac, Alois Melichar. Int.: Paul Hubschmid (dottor Benn Wittich), Ilse Werner (Cornelia), Stefan Skodler (Robert Roy), Elfe Gerhart (Charlotte), Hermann Thimig (Heinemann), Maria Eis (signora Willard), Otto Schmöle (presidente Ries), Ulrich Bettac (Kessler), Robert Tessen (Bobby Ries), Helli Servi (Krümmel). Prod.: G. W. Pabst per Pabst-Kiba-Filmproduktionsgesellschaft. DCP. D.: 104’. Bn.
    Not released in Finland.
    Restored in 2018 by Filmmuseum München in collaboration with the Svenska Filminstitutet and La Cinémathèque francaise at Alpha Omega Digital laboratory.
    DCP from Filmmuseum München.
    Introduce Stefan Drössler.
    Viewed at Sala Scorsese, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Recovered & Restored 2018), 26 June 2018.

Stefan Drössler (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "Bavaria Film’s production schedule for 1941-1942 announced Geheimnisvolle Tiefe (Mysterious Depths) for the first time: the director would be G. W. Pabst, based on a screenplay by his wife Trude and Walther von Hollander, starring Brigitte Horney and Ferdinand Marian. The story focused on a woman in between two men, an idealist who believes in his own powers and delves deep into the dark, prehistoric past, and a materialist who relies on the power of money and lives in the light of the present. But Geheimnisvolle Tiefe was only one of many unrealized projects that Pabst worked on in the early 1940s to avoid being commissioned by Joseph Goebbels to do propaganda films."

"In 1947, after the success of his first post-war film Der Prozess (The Trial, which won several awards at the Venice Film Festival), Pabst founded Pabst Kiba Filmproduction with public funding from the city of Vienna. Geheimnisvolle Tiefe was the most expensive project of the four films produced by this company before its liquidation in 1949. It was the most expensive Austrian production to date, with a popular cast (Ilse Werner and Paul Hubschmid), spectacular locations (the Hermann and Dachstein caves) and lavish settings at the Studio Schönbrunn. But representing Austria at the 1949 Venice Film Festival, the film was a terrible flop: critics called it an “embarrassment”."

"The German premiere took place on September 30, 1950 – more than a year after the Austrian release. The film was cut from 109 minutes to 94 minutes, but the reviews were no less malicious than the Austrian ones. For decades the film was considered lost until in 1992 La Cinémathèque française was able to compile a shortened version from two decomposing nitrate positive prints. Now the critics rate the film as an interesting minor work of Pabst’s “with disturbing metaphorical imagery” (Thomas Brandlmeier) showing traces of many of his early masterpieces. The new digital restoration by Filmmuseum München is based on a recently discovered complete nitrate negative from the collection of the Svenska Filminstitutet." Stefan Drössler

AA: Today was a day of inspired introductions. Stefan Drössler faced with relish the fact that Geheimnisvolle Tiefe is no masterpiece. Yet it has its rewards.

Cornelia (Ilse Werner) is caught between two self-centered men. The millionaire Robert Roy (Stefan Skodler) sees in her a trophy, highly presentable in high society.

Dr. Benn Wittich (Paul Hubschmid) is obsessed with ancient skulls and obscure caves. He risks his life in daring explorations deep inside mountains.

The turning-point of the story is when Robert Roy donates Cornelia a priceless set of jewels. Cornelia must sign a contract with strict terms about its possession. The signing of the document takes place in an atmosphere of divorce.

At this moment Cornelia realizes her role in a play of commodities. She starts to move back to Benn who has experienced a period of self-reflection. He needs her. But there is still a dangerous adventure ahead.

The implausible story is told in a spirit of gleeful abandon with witty repartee. Rarely does one see the leading couple of a movie skating in an underground cave. The commodification of the woman is a theme that connects this film with G. W. Pabst's Weimar classics (Die freudlose Gasse, Die Büchse der Pandora, Tagebuch einer Verlorenen). Here the spirit is less dark and less profound, the title of the film notwithstanding.

A valuable reconstruction and restoration of a lost and found film.

Seed


Seed. Posters from Ehsan Khoshbakht's Twitter account.

Seed. Genevieve Tobin as Mildred the literary agent and John Boles as Bart Carter, the writer who has five reasons why he has stopped writing.

Rakastavia naisia / Mellan två kvinnor / Il richiamo dei figli.
    Director: John M. Stahl. Year: 1931. Country: USA.
    Sog.: dal romanzo omonimo di Charles G. Norris. Scen.: Gladys Lehman. F.: Jackson Rose. M.: Ted J. Kent, Arthur Tavares. Mus.: Heinz Roemheld. Int.: John Boles (Bart Carter), Lois Wilson (Peggy Carter), Genevieve Tobin (Mildred), Raymond Hackett (Junior Carter), ZaSu Pitts (Jennie), Bette Davis (Margaret Carter), Richard Tucker (Bliss), Frances Dade (Nancy), Jack Willis (Dicky Carter), Dick Winslow (Johnny Carter). Prod.: Universal Pictures. 35 mm. D.: 96’. Bn.
    Print from Library of Congress.
    Courtesy of Park Circus.
    Introduce Imogen Sara Smith, hosted by Ehsan Khoshbakht.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Immortal Imitations: The Cinema of John M. Stahl), 26 June 2018.

Imogen Sara Smith: "Seed marks a flowering in the career of John M. Stahl. Having established himself in the silent era as a critic of modern marriage and its discontents, with his second talkie he achieved a delicately unsparing, quietly radical drama worthy of Mikio Naruse. This launched a series of mature melodramas in which Stahl treats the subject of female devotion with ambivalence and unforced sympathy, accepting the great loves to which his heroines give their lives but looking with a cold, clear eye at how little they get in return."

"Based on a novel by social realist Charles G. Norris, Seed contrasts two types of womanhood: the chic, modern executive and the old-fashioned housewife and mother. As in Back Street (1932) and Only Yesterday (1933), further variations on the theme of independent working girls snared by love, the male lead is John Boles. A handsome, dead-eyed mannequin, Boles personifies oblivious masculine selfishness and entitlement. Here his character, a frustrated writer who resents the large family he has to support, abandons his wife and noisy brood of children for an old flame who believes in his talent. (In the film’s second half, one child is played with spring-water freshness by a very young Bette Davis.) At first, there is no contest between the witty, elegant career woman played by Genevieve Tobin and Lois Wilson’s smugly domestic wife. But there is a gradual, underground shift in the film’s sympathies, nudged by long, patient close-ups of Wilson. In the end, the rivals find common ground in a rueful acceptance of disappointment, facing the neglect and invisibility that is their lot as middle-aged women and taking the full bitter measure of the way men sentimentalize female self-sacrifice even as they take advantage of it. Stahl’s direction is self-effacing to the point of invisibility, and the film is all the more piercing for its simplicity, restraint, and bracing dryness." Imogen Sara Smith

AA: The screening began with the best introduction I heard during the festival. By Imogen Sara Smith. I wish I could quote it verbatim. She reads while we others spell. (NB 7 September 2018: her beautiful essay on Seed has now been published by Film Comment, September / October 2018).

I have had trouble relating to John M. Stahl partly because of the cardboard quality of his leading men. For instance Only Yesterday left me cold, although Margaret Sullavan is wonderful in her debut role. We screened it ten years ago in our "four letters from an unknown woman" mini-series, and it was easily the weakest of all.

John Boles seems like a sleepwalker in his John M. Stahl roles. Regarding Only Yesterday perhaps there is an even stronger and stranger case of projection and transference than I had imagined. The radiation of the loving woman is so extraordinary that her reflection can make even John Boles shine and make him a plausible love partner. Love is sometimes an illusion, an affair of make-believe, yet so essential that even a John Boles style diluted substitute can pass. This is one possible relevant interpretation of Stefan Zweig's story. Love as an illusion which can become reality, overwhelmingly so.

Back Street which I saw two years ago in Bologna completely changed my view on Stahl. In Only Yesterday Margaret Sullavan dies of heartbreak. In Back Street both partners of the illicit love story die. In it the John Boles character is plausibly torn between the real passion of his secret love and the official facade of his happy family.

Seed is different again, a love drama seen first from the viewpoint of a man who sacrifices his talent as a writer to his family and then from the viewpoint of the wife who finds herself abruptly a single mother of five children for whom she sacrifices the best years of her life alone.

Tact and restraint are again the characteristics of Stahl's approach in Seed. The last section, "ten years after", is magisterial. The father's homecoming is covered in long takes in which Stahl dares to be slow, showing the reunion of the broken family in almost real time. The emotion rises to new heights as the father embraces his oldest daughter (Bette Davis). From this moment on Stahl's touch is breathtakingly assured. The performances of Lois Wilson as the mother and Genevieve Tobin as the woman of the world are honest and surprising.

One of my three favourite films at Il Cinema Ritrovato.

The visual quality of the print is mostly brilliant.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: DATA FROM THE AFI CATALOG:

Women of All Nations



Women of All Nations. Victor McLaglen as Flagg and Greta Nissen as Elsa.

Women of All Nations. A Comedy Drama with the characters of Quirt and Flagg originally created by Laurence Stallings & Maxwell Anderson.
    Sempre rivali.
    Director: Raoul Walsh. Year: 1931. Country: USA.
    Sog.: basato sui personaggi di Maxwell Anderson, Laurence Stallings. Scen.: Barry Conners. F.: Lucien Andriot. M.: Jack Dennis. Scgf.: David Hall. Mus.: Carli Elinor. Int.: Victor McLaglen (capitano Jim Flagg), Edmund Lowe (sergente Harry Quirt), Greta Nissen (Elsa), El Brendel (Olsen), Fifi D’Orsay (Fifi), Marjorie White (Margie), Jesse De Vorska (Izzy Kaplan), Bela Lugosi (principe Hassan). Prod.: William Fox per Fox Film Corporation 35 mm. D.: 73’. Bn.
    Not released in Finland.
    Restored by UCLA Film and Television Archive.
    Print from UCLA Film & Television Archive.
    Courtesy of Park Circus.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (William Fox Presents: Rediscoveries from The Fox Film Corporation), 26 June 2018.

Ehsan Khoshbakht (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "During the closing years of the silent era, Walsh met with great success for his depiction of the rivalry between two U.S. Marine officers in What Price Glory? (1926). Nevertheless the director felt some dissatisfaction: in the absence of sound, the sharpness of the film’s dialogue was lost in the intertitles. In the early 1930s, Walsh returned to the same characters, Jim Flagg and Harry Quirt, first in The Cock-Eyed World (1929) and then Women of All Nations, by which time the focus had shifted from war and military life to sex and comedy – yet the two seem to be intertwined. In the latter film Walsh frames a WWI trench and a line of bare female legs with the same type of dazzling tracking shot. Both are associated with mobility too. As the Marines are sent on missions to different countries, where they encounter women, a Swedish dancer enjoys her own freedom of movement, with her own ‘weapons’ to help her."

"Unlike What Price Glory? Walsh was able not only to make the ludicrous conversations audible, but also enriched the soundtrack with the sounds of shelling, women giggling and mewing – Walshian sexual innuendo through sound."

"The film is almost bereft of plot, instead introducing a series of situations and gags, both comic and dramatic. A stunning battle sequence leads into slapstick, as the viewer is whisked around the world. The scenes are linked by intertitles, the first one of which is signed by Walsh himself as ‘narrator’. Throughout, a small number of ideas are masterfully exploited by Walsh to the point of absurdity."

"Audiences were far from enthusiastic however, perhaps tired of the Flagg / Quirt partnership, and the film lost $175,000. Surprisingly, Fox didn’t give up, making a fourth and final installment, Hot Pepper (1933), directed by John G. Blystone. This madcap, fast-moving film is a thoroughly enjoyable example of Walsh’s most lucid period of filmmaking – the work of a man who can turn even vulgar sex jokes into unassuming art." Ehsan Khoshbakht

AA:  The women of all nations are a harem for Flagg and Quirt.

For some patrons Women of All Nations was one of the favourite films at Il Cinema Ritrovato. For most it was the worst / one of the worst, me included.

Not without incidental pleasures, such as the character Big Olaf who throws Flagg, Quirt and Olsen clean through the door of Elsa's chamber which only Olaf has permission to enter. [The actor in the role of Olaf is identified in the end credits but not in any online source.]

And Bela Lugosi, charismatic, as Sheik Hassan whose harem also comes to include Elsa. He scares the three adventurers away with a threat of something unspeakable to be achieved with his sharp dagger if uninvited men are discovered.

And the whole preposterous episode in Göteborg / Gothenburg. Mostly our international travellers focus on visiting the red light districts of the world's ports, and the talented female cast including Greta Nissen, Fifi D'Orsay, Marjorie White, Marion Lessing, Ruth Warren, and Joyce Compton are reduced to playing prostitutes or something similar. That said, Walsh and Mizoguchi are the cinema's most sympathetic portrayers of the oldest profession.

I love What Price Glory? which balances the horror of war and the joy of life. When that electrifying balance is removed, a tired comedy formula emerges in the eternal navy world tour of Flagg and Quirt.

I have reservations even about A Girl in Every Port which is both fascinatingly embryonic for the oeuvre of Howard Hawks and frustratingly adolescent, a showcase of arrested development. The harem concept was close both to Walsh and Hawks. (Fazil is the story of an evolution from the harem to true love).

There is one case of true emotion in Women of All Nations: the story of the rookie marine Izzy Kaplan whom Flagg and Quirt swear to protect. Alas, he meets his fate in the earthquake of Nicaragua. His father is played by none other than Max Davidson.

A first rate print.

PS. 19 July 2018. Pamela Hutchinson reminds us of the cat in El Brendel's pants. Others focus on Victor McLaglen's meowing like a tomcat in heat.

Monday, June 25, 2018

Auf der Suche nach Ingmar Bergman / Searching for Ingmar Bergman


A photo in Margarethe von Trotta's documentary: Ingmar Bergman – Vermächtnis eines Jahrhundertgenies / Searching for Ingmar Bergman. A family photo with Käbi Laretei, Daniel Bergman, and Ingmar Bergman.

Ingmar Bergman – Vermächtnis eines Jahrhundertgenies
    Director: Margarethe von Trotta. Year: 2018. Country: Germania-Francia.
    A documentary film on the Ingmar Bergman centenary.
    Scen.: Felix Moeller. F.: Börres Weiffenbach. M.: Bettina Böhler. Int.: Liv Ullmann, Ruben Östlund, Olivier Assayas, Mia Hansen-Løve, Carlos Saura, Gunnel Lindblom, Jean-Claude Carrière, Julia Dufvenius, Gaby Dohm, Daniel Bergman, Rita Russek. Prod.: Guy Amon, Benjamin Seikel, Stéphane Sorlat, C-Films, Mondex&cie DCP. D. 95’. Bn e Col.
    German, Swedish, English, French and Spanish version with English subtitles
    DCP from CMG Cinema Management Group.
    Introducono Margarethe von Trotta, Felix Moeller, and Stéphane Sorlat, hosted by Ehsan Khoshbakht.
    Viewed at Auditorium – DAMSLab, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Documents and Documentaries 2018), 25 June 2018.

Margarethe von Trotta: "Margarethe von Trotta delves deep into the life and the character of Ingmar Bergman, with a particular view to showing the role of women, who were more central to Bergman’s practice than any other filmmaker’s. She acts as a guide, narrating this film, giving her point of view as an experienced director in her own right on Bergman’s work and on specific scenes from his films."

"What place does Bergman occupy in the minds of today’s filmmakers? In order to answer this question, von Trotta recruits internationally famous actors and directors from a range of different walks of cinema and countries, such as Carlos Saura, Olivier Assayas, Ruben Östlund and Mia Hansen-Løve… The latter is a thirty-six-year-old director whose work contains many strong references to Bergman. Are we witnessing a Bergman revival? Von Trotta angles her interviews to discover which scenes prove most inspirational, where Bergman’s influence shows in their work and what trace, more generally, remains in today’s cinema: subject-matter, characters, relevance."

"Ingmar Bergman would have been delighted to learn that ten years after his death Margarethe von Trotta was making a film about him, not just because her movie Two German Sisters was one of his favourite films, but also because she is a woman and he felt a peculiar empathy for women. As he said himself, “There are several women inside me”. In this sense, this film also shows Ingmar Bergman as a tireless advocate for women on either side of the camera. Wim Wenders is quoted as saying that Bergman’s films were obscured by an “opaque screen of opinion” and that they merited to be seen afresh, “without prejudice”. This is what von Trotta’s documentary sets out to do. Her commentary, her eye and the eye of a new generation of actors and filmmakers together renew the way we see Bergman: an entire century of filmmaking seen through the prism of today’s filmmakers."

"“At the end of this documentary, I show myself leaning against a big rock by the sea. I feel tiny beside the master that is Bergman. The rock stands for him. It protects me. I stand in the friendly shade of this big rock”.
" Margarethe von Trotta

NB. Berg = rock. Ingmar, his father, and the family were certainly conscious of the association in their name to the word of Jesus about Peter: "upon this rock I will build my church".

AA: A deeply moving and personal documentary on Ingmar Bergman who became a family friend for Margarethe von Trotta and Volker Schlöndorff during his years of exile in Munich.

What I cherish:

The Liv Ullmann interviews, also a personal friend of the director. "He looked at me. He knew".

Stig Björkman takes von Trotta to an Ingmar Bergman tour in Stockholm, including to Bergman's chair at Teatergrillet from where he could see everybody entering the restaurant.

Gunnel Lindblom: "It is impossible to know what would have happened without him".

Jean-Claude Carrière analyzes the essence of Bergman's arch.

Olivier Assayas cherishes Bergman, including his revealing a modern woman, "la femme libre".

Carlos Saura: each actress was different in Bergman's films.

Katinka Faragó talks about her 30 year collaboration with Bergman. Before the shooting started each day Ingmar was so scared that they were holding hands 20-30 minutes.

The most shattering interview is with Daniel Bergman who discusses his experience with Ingmar in directing Sunday's Children, written by Ingmar. The flashforward caused a conflict, a war with father and son. "This scene must go out now", said Ingmar to Daniel about the revelations of Erik to his son. It stayed, but Ingmar never wanted to see the film again.

"He was closer to his own childhood than to his children". "I have never sensed that I miss him". "I never called them mother and father".

When Ingmar was near death he lamented how much he missed actors. "Don't you miss your children and grandchildren?" "I don't."

On Ingmar's 60th birthday his children and grandchildren met each other for the first time.

Bergman considered primal therapy to get rid of his childhood fears. When he was told that he might be healed but he might lose his creativity he decided not to visit the therapy.

Liv Ullmann came to Fårö when Ingmar was near death. "You called for me".

Ruben Östlund talks about Bergman not being a prophet in his own land. "Maybe in a few years things may change". Maybe they are already changing.

At the start and the beginning Margarethe von Trotta is looking at the sea next to a huge, mysterious rock. There is an affinity in this vision with the equally personal film by Jörn Donner, The Memory of Ingmar Bergman.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: INTERVIEW MIT MARGARETHE VON TROTTA (PATRICK HEIDMANN, EPD FILM, 28 JUNE 2018:

1898 Anno tre: Lumière locale: Jan Kříženecký in Prague and The best Lumière vues of 1898


Dostaveníčko ve mlýnici [An Assignation in the Mill]. CZ 1898. D: Jan Kříženecký. C: Josef Šváb-Malostranský. Národní filmový archiv.
Musical interpretation: Stephen Horne.
Sala Mastroianni, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Anno tre), 25 June 2018.


Lumière locale: Jan Kříženecký a Praga
Local Lumière: Jan Kříženecký in Prague

Jeanne Pommeau: "Jan Kříženecký, a construction engineer and a photographer, bought a cinématographe from the Lumière brothers in 1898 with its accessories and negative and positive film stock, with which he made the first Czech films. Most of these films describe events, celebrations and everyday life in Prague, however three of them were comedies with Josef Šváb-Malostranský as the lead actor and presumably also as co-director. Jan Kříženecký screened the films at the Exhibition of Architecture and Engineering in Prague the same year in the pavilion he named the “Czech Cinematograph”. All surviving materials have now been digitized. If possible, we will also present the original negatives and vintage prints in order to offer a better comprehension of the photographic character of these moving pictures."

"Despite the myth of the omnipotence of digital technologies, important characteristics of historical film technologies can be more faithfully reproduced with photochemical procedures. Tinting and toning are obvious examples of practices that can be reused today to achieve a maximum of the films’ original aesthetic impact. On the other hand, monochromatic colours of prints manufactured by the Lumière brothers, because they are presumably inherent in this film material, are not reproducible on safety prints using the original technologies. The fact that the nitrate vintage prints have one sprocket-hole on each side of the filmstrip adds to their fragility and makes screening them impossible. In this very peculiar case, digitization offers the only way to screen a facsimile of these films in their present state without interfering by using digital retouching or stabilization and respecting their colours. This is a modest but necessary step to invite researchers to become curious about the colour processes used in one of the very first screened moving pictures in history and one more move to fight the pervasive ideology of ‘content’."
Jeanne Pommeau

Svatojanská pouť v českoslovanské vesnici Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Midsummer Pilgrimage in a Czechoslavic Village] DCP. D.: 40’’ (copia vintage); 47’’ (negativo originale)  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Defilování vojska o Božím těle na Královských Hradčanech Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [March Past during Corpus Christi Feast in Hradčany]  DCP. D.: 22’’ Da: Národní filmový archiv

Polední výstřel na Mariánských hradbách Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Noon Cannon Firing on Marian Walls]  DCP. D.: 40’’  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Cyklisté / Cyclists Cecoslovacchia, 1898  DCP. D.: 37’’  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Staroměstští hasiči Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [The Firemen of Old Prague]  DCP. D.: 45’’ (copia vintage); 39’’ (negativo originale) Da: Národní filmový archiv

Žofínská plovárna Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Žofín Swimming Bath]  DCP. D.: 45’’ (copia vintage) 48’’ (negativo originale)  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Dostaveníčko ve mlýnici Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [An Assignation in the Mill]  Int.: Josef Šváb-Malostranský  DCP. D.: 1’(copia vintage); 44’’ (negativo originale)  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Výstavní párkař a lepič plakátů Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Exhibition Sausage Seller and Bill-Poster]  Int.: Josef Šváb-Malostranský  DCP. D.: 59’’ (capia vintage 1); 60’’ (copia vintage 2); 62’’ (negativo originale)  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Smích a pláč Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Laughter and Tears]  Int.: Josef Šváb-Malostranský  DCP. D.: 30’’  Da: Národní filmový archiv

Cvičení s kužely Sokolů malostranských Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Exercises with Indian Clubs by the Sokol of Malá Strana]  DCP. D.: 47’’ (copia vintage); 42’’ (negativo originale) Da: Národní filmový archiv

Voltýžování jízdního odboru Sokola pražského Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Vaulting of the Prague Sokol Equestrian Section]  DCP. D.: 43’’ Da: Národní filmový archiv

Slavnost zakládání pomníku Františka Palackého Cecoslovacchia, 1898 [Foundation Ceremony of the František Palacký Monument]  DCP. D.: 47’’ Da: Národní filmový archiv

Digitized in 4K in 2018 by Národní filmový archiv in collaboration with Nasjonalbiblioteket – National Library of Norway and CESNET at Hungarian Filmlab (Budapest) and Magiclab (Prague), with the support of Iceland and Liechtenstein. Project supported by Ministry of Culture of the Czech Republic

Le più belle vedute Lumière del 1898 (con un balletto in stile Gay Pride)
The Best Lumière Vues of 1898 (including a Gay Pride style Ballet)

Mariann Lewinsky: "After several hundreds of views shot in 1897 in all the corners of the world by travelling operators, the Lumière production of Vues de plein air continued the following year with a series shot predominantly in France. All in all, two hundred new views were added to the Lumière catalogue in 1898, including about twenty vues composées or divers. The examples have been selected for the wondrous sense of rhythm, timing and frame composition, the magic of capturing the present moment of time and life (of a princess, of a dog) and the eerie revelation of new ways of seeing (from a balloon in bound flight, or ascending the Eiffel tower)." Mariann Lewinsky

Chiens savants: la danse serpentine n . 987, Francia, 1897 o 1898

La Duchesse d’Aoste à l’exposition n . 1051, Torino, Italia, 1898

Lavage du pont, I n . 821, Alexandre Promio, Villefranche-sur-Mer, Francia, 1898

Ramassage du linge n . 824, Alexandre Promio, Villefranche-sur-Mer, Francia, 1898

Picadors n . 864, Nîmes, Francia, 8 maggio 1898

Chiens savants: exercice du tonneau n . 989, Francia, 1897 o 1898

Ballet Excelsior: pas du bouquet n . 913, [Lione], Francia, 1897 o 1898

35 mm Da: Institut Lumière


Le Squelette joyeux n . 831, [Francia], 1897 o 1898 {Lumière!, 2017, 103}

Ouvriers réparant un trottoir en bitume n . 833, [Francia], 1897 o 1898 {Lumière!, 2017, 29}

Panorama pendant l’ascension de la tour Eiffel n . 992, Parigi, Francia, 1897 o 1898 {Lumière!, 2017, 46}

Panorama pris d’un ballon captif n . 997, [Francia], 1897 o 1898 {Lumière!, 2017, 101}

Explosion en mer n . 829, Alexandre Promio, Villefranche-sur-Mer, Francia, 1898

DCP Da: Institut Lumière

AA: I was not able to attend this screening due to a double overlap with Madeleine Bernstorff's Ella Bergmann-Michel show and Margarethe von Trotta but I include this list here to keep a complete record of the fantastic Anno Tre series. Four of the Institut Lumière DCP's in this programme are included in Thierry Frémaux's Lumière! (2017).

Ella Bergmann-Michel: La donna con la Kinamo 1


Ella Bergmann-Michel.

The Woman with The Kinamo: Ella Bergmann-Michel
    All films are silent documentaries with German intertitles, restored by the DIF Frankfurt to 35 mm.
    Introducono Madeleine Bernstorff e Sünke Michel.
    Grand piano: Matti Bye.
    With e-subtitles in English and Italian.
    Viewed at Cinema Lumiere - Sala Officinema/Mastroianni, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato, 25 June 2018.

Wo wohnen alte Leute / Where Old People Live.

WO WOHNEN ALTE LEUTE
    Where Old People Live
    Director: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Year: 1931. Country: Germania.
    Scen.: Mart Stam, Ella Bergmann-Michel. F., M.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Prod.: Ella Bergmann-Michel su commissione di Mart Stam. 35 mm. L.: 236 m (l. orig.: 240 m). D.: 13‘ a 16 f/s. Bn.

"In 1929-1930, the Henry and Emma Budge-Stiftung foundation, established by the eponymous Jewish husband and wife, commissioned Dutch architect Mart Stam to design a home for the elderly. He asked Bergmann-Michel to make a short film, which was her first. Filmed using a tripod and hand-cranked camera, it is a eulogy to modernist architecture, light, air and sun. No longer chaotic, but calm, green and with single rooms. The flexibility of the spaces is rendered with simple special effects. Ella Bergmann-Michel highlights the expressive nature of the new building, emphasizing the huge entrance and open common areas flooded with light. In the final scene, the guests, looking out from a long row of balconies, greet the camera with happy smiles. Together with other films, this short was part of the Neues Bauen – Neues Wohnen [New Architecture – New Housing] programme." Madeleine Bernstorff

"This building had large pleasant, sun-lit rooms. It had been finished in 1929 and was, according to Frankfurt standards, very modern, offering all the amenities that old people might need. Thus the home for the  elderly was filmed, showing their well-being. The floor plan of the building and the variability of some of the rooms were animated through special effects using drawings." Ella Bergmann-Michel

AA: A Modernist approach to housing in the spirit of Functionalism. The ideals of simple, stylish, elegant, light-filled and open spaces are familiar to the Finnish traditions of Alvar Aalto who probably knew and admired this film.

Erwerbslose kochen für Erwerbslose / Unemployed Are Cooking for the Unemployed.

ERWERBSLOSE KOCHEN FÜR ERWERBSLOSE
    Unemployed Are Cooking for the Unemployed
    Director: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Year: 1932. Country: Germania.
    F., M.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Prod.: Ella Bergmann-Michel per conto dell’associazione delle cucine per disoccupati di Francoforte. 35mm. L.: 171 m (l. orig.: 180 m). D.: 9‘ a 16 f/s. Bn.

"In the spring of 1932, Ella Bergmann-Michel bought, on the advice of Joris Ivens, a portable spring-driven camera, the Kinamo N 25. The association of soup kitchens for the unemployed in Frankfurt built up a network which that year offered a hearty hot meal to around 16,000 people. Finding itself short of funds, it decided to produce a promotional film. “The global crisis of 1931 has triggered an unprecedented wave of poverty in Germany. Added to the terrible psychological condition of unemployment in large cities is the spectre of hunger. One portion of soup costs 10 pfennig. The food is picked up from the kitchens and eaten at home, with the family. The cost of production is so low because the idea underlying the canteens is the self-organization of the unemployed” (“Die neue Stadt”, April 1932). Ella Bergmann-Michel wrote the script for the film and shot in twenty-eight canteens, with some short fictionalized scenes. The short was screened in cinemas alongside the main feature, or outside on a mobile screen built by Robert, Ella’s husband." Madeleine Bernstorff

"I shot it with three 1000W bulbs in my backpack and the little Kinamo camera (whose film negatives I inserted into reels in dark basements or photo shops). The footage I shot – the product of observing 28 kitchens where the unemployed handed out 10,000 liters of soup to unemployed – served as basis for the commercial’s theme, which was supposed to communicate convincingly the request for more donations. The film ran as a supporting feature in cinemas and as an open-air film at night at the Hauptwache underneath the Schiller monument. Ticket sales came to more than 600  Reichsmarks per night." Ella Bergmann-Michel

AA: Also here there is a Functionalist spirit at work. An approach of dignity to an epic problem of injustice: hunger and unemployment. "Nobody should starve". In Finland this film would be topical today, with our epic breadlines, a result of our two recent economic recessions which left tens of thousands permanently unemployed.

Fliegende Händler in Frankfurt am Main / Travelling Hawkers in Frankfurt am Main.

FLIEGENDE HÄNDLER IN FRANKFURT AM MAIN
    Travelling Hawkers in Frankfurt am Main
    Director: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Year: 1932. Country: Germania
    F., M.: Ella Bergmann-Michel. Prod.: Ella Bergmann-Michel, Paul Seligman. 35mm. L.: 673 m. D.: 37‘ a 16 f/s. Bn.

"A reportage on street vendors, almost all unlicensed, during the economic crisis. Some walk around with carts full of vegetables, escaping as soon as the police appear, letting the others know. There is a series of images of a limping newsboy, fairground shows, toy sellers and a merry-go-round operator at work. In this film, Ella Bergmann-Michel combines her particular sensitivity for movement, dynamism, light and shade with compelling social empathy. “The dynamic centre of it all is the large Ferris wheel at the fair, whose enormous iron rods are reminiscent of the wheel spokes of the fruit carts and fairground wagons, creating an effect of abstraction from everyday life and showing the artist’s interest in the connection between nature, society, and technology” (Kristin Vincke)." Madeleine Bernstorff

"With the 35 mm handheld camera one could film the street vendors in the squares and streets without being seen, some of them with sensationalist promotional acts and others who tried hard to avoid being noticed by policemen, because the wares were for sale without permission. The final sequences were devoted to the vendors who performed at the wholesale market’s fairgrounds. There the political police was already watching me, and I was glad to be able to carry my film reels home untouched." Ella Bergmann-Michel

AA: A more rhapsodic collection of footage, interesting, and fascinating, but with a random approach. Memorable views of illegal street vendors always on the alert, ready to flee when the police arrives.

Madeleine Bernstorff: Ella Bergmann-Michel: La donna con la Kinamo

A constructivist artist who worked mainly with collage and photography, Ella Bergmann-Michel (1895-1971) made some innovative documentaries between 1931 and 1933, which today provide a valuable account of the liberal climate in Frankfurt in the latter years of the Weimar Republic. She was a leading exponent of the Bund neues Frankfurt group [New Frankfurt Alliance], which brought together architects and artists intent on developing a practical and socially-oriented modernist project.

Bergmann-Michel was in charge of organizing film screenings, which was how she came into contact with Dziga Vertov and Joris Ivens, whose works strongly influenced her. Her circle of friends also included artists and intellectuals such as Kurt Schwitters, Asja Lācis, and László Moholy-Nagy.

Bergmann-Michel used the camera – a Kinamo (Kin amo = I love cinema), developed as of 1922 by the engineer Emanuel Goldberg – filming quickly, with a documentary-narrative approach, focusing on the everyday social life she observed, both to promote the Neue Bauen, and to collect funds to support soup kitchens for the unemployed. She used short scenes of fiction to emphasize the point she was most interested in: the expansive structure of the architecture of a new home for the elderly, the disappointment on the face of a starving person who turns up at a soup kitchen which has no food supplies, or even the authorities’ hold over street vendors. The habit of filming what was happening before her eyes on the street attracted growing suspicion, which culminated in her arrest and her film being confiscated during the shooting of Letzte Wahl. Earlier footage was saved, which vividly documented the bitter political conflict during the last free elections in Germany in 1932. In 1933, when the regime banned her work, Bergmann-Michel was forced to retreat to the country with her husband. Paul Seligman, her fellow comrade and producer of some of her shorts (we’ll see him in a previously unseen 1976 interview), had to leave the country. After the war, Bergmann-Michel continued to put forward her ideas as organizer of a film society. At the end of the eighties, renewed interest in progressive documentary cinema led the Hamburg Academy of Fine Arts (where Ella’s son, Hans Michel, taught) to produce the portrait-documentary Mein Herz schlägt Blau – Ella Bergmann-Michel, following extensive research of dispersed material.

Originally distributed in 16 mm format, her films were restored between 2005 and 2006 by the Deutsches Filminstitut in Frankfurt.

Our thanks go to Jutta Hercher, Karin Orchard, Gerhard Schumm (archive of the Sprengel Museum Hannover), Rudolf Worschech (Deutsches Filmmuseum – Deutsches Filminstitut) and Sünke Michel.

Madeleine Bernstorff

Caravan (MoMA restoration)



Caravan. Phillips Holmes as Lieutenant von Tokay in the middle.

Karavaani / Karavanen / Carovane.
    Director: Erik Charell. Year: 1934. Country: USA.
    Sog.: dal racconto Gypsy Melody di Melchior Lengyel. Scen.: Samson Raphaelson, Robert Liebmann, Hans Kraly. F.: Ernest Palmer, Theodor Sparkuhl. M.: Robert Bischoff. Scgf.: William Darling, Ernst Stern. Mus.: Werner Richard Heymann. Int.: Charles Boyer (Lazi), Loretta Young (contessa Wilma), Jean Parker (Timka), Phillips Holmes (Tenente von Tokay), Louise Fazenda (Bessie Opitz), Eugene Pallette (il capo degli zingari), C. Aubrey Smith (barone von Tokay). Prod.: Robert Kane per Fox Film Corporation. 35 mm. D.: 103’. Bn.
    Print from MoMA The Museum of Modern Art.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (William Fox Presents: Rediscoveries from The Fox Film Corporation), 25 June 2018.

Dave Kehr (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "Fox’s German connection began when William Fox invited F. W. Murnau to create the towering Sunrise in 1927 and continued through an association with the producer Erich Pommer – who founded Fox Europa after the Nazis chased him out of Ufa – and extended to a number of contracts with leading figures of the Weimar cinema, many of whom were able to emigrate to Hollywood as a result. Foremost among them was Erik Charell, a brilliant theatrical director who had been an assistant to Max Reinhardt and has directed one of the finest of the Weimar musicals, the bittersweet operetta Der Kongress tantz (1931). In Hollywood, Fox Film gave Charell all the resources of the struggling studio, as well as allowing him to bring over composer Werner Richard Heymann, screenwriter Robert Liebmann and production designer Ernst Stern. With a screenplay by two Lubitsch associates, Samson Raphelson and Hans Kraly, the result was Caravan, the greatest Weimar musical not made in Germany. Droll, sophisticated, bittersweet, this tale of a Hungarian countess (Loretta Young) who impulsively marries a gypsy violinist (Charles Boyer, who also starred in a simultaneously made French-language version of the film) is full of pointed observations about class and race in Old Europe. And yet American audiences rejected it out of hand, perhaps because the experienced Charell, Jewish and gay, could not bring himself to provide a traditional happy ending that would allow the minority outcast to live in eternal harmony with the aristocratic insider. Seen today, Caravan is not without its flaws of taste and scale, but it is a both a bitterly ironic and emotionally commanding film, as well as one of Hollywood’s earliest coded protests against Hitler. Restored from the only known nitrate print, held in MoMA’s collection." (Dave Kehr)

AA: A lavish musical spectacle set in an operetta Hungary of 1811. A rebellious story where the young heiress Countess Wilma (Loretta Young) falls in love with the gypsy violinist Lazi (Charles Boyer) and turns her castle into a playground for a gypsy wedding. It takes the Austro-Hungarian army to chase the gypsy camp away from the castle, ruined in riotous partying.

Wilma's intended groom, Lieutenant von Tokay (Phillips Holmes) arrives too late, stone drunk, and makes passes at Wilma and proposes a one night stand without realizing whom he accosting. (Touches of The Merry Widow).

This is a catastrophe musical, and Erik Charell and his brilliant team have perfect control over the magnificent crowd scenes, both organized and revolutionary ones. Loretta Young and Charles Boyer are sparkling, and Phillips Holmes does comedy well. But there is a little too much of the good thing. Relentless merriment can turn exhausting. Parts are better than the whole.

A valuable restoration from elements that seem to have been challenging at times.

The Woman Under Oath


The Woman Under Oath. Florence Reed as the novelist Grace Norton, the sole woman in an all male panel.

Il verdetto / Den edsvurna.
    Director: John M. Stahl. Year: 1919. Country: USA.
    F.: John K. Holbrook. Int.: Florence Reed (Grace Norton), Hugh Thompson (John Schuyler), Gareth Hughes (Jim O’Neil), David Powell (Edward Knox), Florida Kingsley (signora O’Neil), Mildred Cheshire (Helen), May McAvoy (Edith Norton), Harold Entwistle (il giudice). Prod.: Tribune Productions Inc. 35 mm. L.: 1693 m. D.: 61’. Bn.
    Print from BFI National Archive.
    Digital piano played by Donald Sosin.
    Introduce Pamela Hutchinson hosted by Ehsan Khoshbakht.
    Viewed at Cinema Jolly with e-subtitles in Italian by Sub-Ti Londra, Bologna, Il Cinema Ritrovato (Immortal Imitations: The Cinema of John M. Stahl), 25 June 2018

Pamela Hutchinson (Il Cinema Ritrovato): "“Is a woman temperamentally fitted for service on a jury in a criminal case?” With this intertitle, The Woman Under Oath announces itself as both topical and provocative. In Stahl’s lurid courtroom melodrama, Gareth Hughes plays Jim, a young man accused of shooting his repulsive former employer Edward Knox, played by David Powell. Florence Reed plays Grace Norton, a novelist sensationally elected to the jury at Jim’s trial. In the film she is the first woman in New York to do so, although it wasn’t made legal in the state until 1937."

"Via flashbacks and meaningful glances across the courtroom, Stahl deflects and then reveals the story of Knox’s death. Notable sequences include Jim’s harrowing interrogation by the police, including a decidedly unethical trick designed to terrify a confession out of him, and Grace’s tormented visions in the jury-room, where she holds out against her peers’ assumption of Jim’s guilt."

"“Exhibitors’ Herald” dismissed The Woman Under Oath out of hand as “comically serious, amateurish and altogether disappointing”, adding that Reed’s close-up-heavy performance in the lead role “does not redeem the picture”. The review in “Wid’s Daily” was more positive: while baffled by the flashbacks, it praised Hughes’s “forcefully excellent portrayal of accused youth” and the film’s restrained use of intertitles, calling it “a quite good picture of its kind” despite being “none too wholesome in certain respects”. Ultimately the topical question posed at the outset was the hook, with “Wid’s Daily” commending the film to female audiences, more specifically progressive households where “woman suffrage is a popular topic with the women”."

"Contrary to those contemporary views, The Woman Under Oath emerges an accomplished and compelling film, by a director with a sterling career ahead of him. Stahl would continue to make more female-led melodramas, and returned to a version of this plot when he produced 1929’s early-talkie Painted Faces." (Pamela Hutchinson)

AA: This film starts puzzlingly with the intertitle quoted by Pamela Hutchinson above, posing the question whether a woman is temperamentally fitted for service on a jury in a criminal case. A good question only if posed to men and women equally.

The topical interest of this film is as a study of a woman in a man's world, a continuing theme in the oeuvre of John M. Stahl. The solitude of the sole female juror on an all male panel: these images are striking and memorable.

Also David Powell's performance as the brutally predatory Edward Knox is topical in our age of the Harvey Weinstein trial. The murder mystery revolves around the coincidence that two persons with a motive and intent to kill visit Knox almost simultaneously. When the second one comes Knox is dead already. Both killers / would-be killers are there to defend their sisters.

In the dramatic jury sequence the truth is revealed but for the jury only. The jury deems that Edward Knox got the punishment he deserved.

In this tale of poetic justice the screenplay is weak and the plot full of holes. The potentially magnificent character of the brave female juror and novelist Grace Norton is diminished.

There are dynamic passages of dramatic medium shots and occasional moments of overacting.

The best part of the movie is the electrifying flashback to what really happened. Events already presented are now seen in a bigger picture, and there is a memorable shot showing the two doors. From the left door the murderer exits, and from the right door the other avenger arrives while Edward Knox is already lying dead on the floor.

The visual quality of the print is variable, often heavily duped. At the speed selected the film is moving fast. It's ok but could be a bit slower.

P. S. Geoffrey O'Brien in The New York Review of Books (16 August 2018) writes that the novelist was perhaps modeled on Edith Wharton.