Showing posts sorted by relevance for query jenseits der strasse. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query jenseits der strasse. Sort by date Show all posts

Thursday, October 11, 2012

Jenseits der Strasse / Harbour Drift



Jenseits der Strasse - eine Tragödie des Alltags / Dans la rue / Au-delà de la rue / Harbor Drift / På andra sidan gatan / [Dall’altra parte della strada].
    DE 1929. PC: Prometheus-Film Verleih- und Vertriebs-GmbH, Berlin. P: Willi Münzenberg; 
    D: Leo Mittler, [Albrecht Viktor Blum (n.c.)]; SC: Jan Fethke; DP: Friedl Behn-Grund; AD: Robert Scharfenberg, Carl P. Haacker; FX: Eugen Schüfftan (trick process), Fritz Maurischat (design for Schüfftan process); artistic adviser: Willy Döll; ass D: Julius Oblatt; P mgr: Dimitri Roschanski; 
    C: Lissy Arna (prostitute), Paul Rehkopf (beggar), Fritz Genschow (unemployed man), Siegfried Arno (dealer in stolen goods), Friedrich Gnaß (sailor), Margarete Kupfer (proprietress), Dietrich Henckels; 
    filmed: 6-7.1929 (Jofa-Ateliers Berlin-Johannisthal; Rotterdam; Berlin); censorship date: 20.09.1929, B.23519, Jv. (2015 m; 2028 m before censorship); première: 10.10.1929, Berlin (Atrium); 
    Not released in Finland.
    35 mm, 1939 m, 93' (18 fps);
    From: Bundesarchiv-Filmarchiv, Berlin. Deutsche Zwischentitel.
    Viewed at Teatro Verdi, Le Giornate del Cinema Muto, Pordenone (Rediscoveries), e-subtitles in English and Italian, grand piano: Stephen Horne, 11 Oct 2012.

Anton Kaes: "Uncommonly prescient about the social consequences of economic distress, Leo Mittler’s Jenseits der Straße (literally, “Beyond the Street”) opened in Berlin on 10 October 1929, just two weeks before the Wall Street stock market crash. The film’s English title, Harbor Drift, is well chosen because it retains a sense of the film’s working title, Bettler, Dirne und Matrose (Beggar, Prostitute, and Sailor). Set in a German harbor town, the story deals with human drift, a harsh metaphor for what Marx and Engels called the lumpenproletariat (ragor rogue-proletariat), whose members – beggars, prostitutes, crooks, and “other flotsam of society” – lack class consciousness and are therefore lost to organized struggle. Although Harbor Drift follows Weimar’s popular “street film” genre (as exemplified by The Street or Asphalt), it focuses less on the dangerous lure of the street than on the crushing poverty of the lowest layers of the proletariat. In contrast to Phil Jutzi’s Mother Krause’s Journey to Happiness, which premiered two months later, Harbor Drift does not hold out the possibility of a proletarian-revolutionary alternative; its poverty-stricken characters are shown to live outside the political sphere."

"This absence of missionary zeal is curious, because the film was produced by Willi Münzenberg’s Prometheus-Film, whose express purpose was to promote progressive proletarian cinema. Founded in 1925, the company focused on importing revolutionary Soviet films (e.g., Eisenstein’s Battleship Potemkin and Pudovkin’s Mother, both 1926), but also produced a few feature films on its own, such as Harbor Drift, Mother Krause, and Kuhle Wampe (Dudow, 1932). In the end, Münzenberg’s alternative proletarian vision could not compete with Hugenberg’s plush and powerful Ufa empire. The budget for Mother Krause had to be cut because of Harbor Drift’s production overruns, and in 1932, in the midst of the production of Kuhle Wampe, Prometheus-Film declared bankruptcy."

"Harbor Drift’s narrative centers around the quest for a glitzy pearl necklace that symbolizes a different kind of life – one of money, luxury, and extravagance. The story begins when a beggar finds the necklace and is seen stealing it by a prostitute. She demands that her unemployed friend steal it back from the beggar. The sordid tale of poverty and greed ends when the beggar is chased and accidentally drowns, still clutching his pearl necklace – a worthless imitation, as it turns out. The film refrains from psychologizing its characters, whom it uses as types without names (“the beggar”, “the prostitute”, etc.). Harbor Drift also includes shots of industrial landscapes to place the individuals in their social milieu and to suggest a larger story about capitalism’s imposing, albeit corrosive, power. Some of this footage, in the style of Dziga Vertov’s constructivism, is attributed to Albrecht Viktor Blum, who had been designated to direct Harbor Drift before he was replaced (because of illness) by Leo Mittler, an unknown Austrian theatre director. Blum had been the center of controversy when his 1928 compilation film Im Schatten der Maschinen (In the Shadow of Machines) incorporated whole passages from Vertov’s 1928 documentary The Eleventh Year. (Ironically, during a visit to Berlin in 1929, it was Vertov who had to defend himself against charges of plagiarism.)"

"The crime story involving the beggar and prostitute is embedded in a framing story that also features the prostitute. Sitting by herself at an outdoor café, silently soliciting, she is introduced through point-of-view close-ups of her knee-high, tightly laced, high-heeled boots. Nearby, a corpulent bourgeois with a cigar – a caricature straight from the pages of George Grosz – ogles her fetishized legs while pretending to read the paper. Such scenes of sexual commerce were part of urban life in Weimar Germany, where open prostitution was common. A new Law for Combating Venereal Diseases in 1927 had decriminalized prostitution, and it is reported that Berlin had no fewer than 100,000 streetwalkers. As if to tease the viewer, the film draws away from the encounter between prostitute and potential customer, and instead tracks in on the newspaper he holds up to shield his lecherous glances. After scanning many pages and pictures, the camera comes to rest on a brief news item, a mysterious story about an old man who was pulled out of the water, obviously the victim of a crime. The first intertitle had asked: “Millions of newspaper copies every day. Hundreds of thousands of notices … every day. Hundreds of thousands fates … Who gives these any thought between coffee and cigars?” The film answers the question by cutting from the newspaper to a bustling street, the home of the old man, a beggar, whose death occasioned the report. Investigating his fate, the film presents the man’s life as a story that is already past. The end is revealed at the beginning – a narrative technique that reinforces a sense of immutability and predetermination, but also a rhetorical device that encourages a sociological, critical-analytical spectatorial position."

"At the conclusion of the extended flashback, the film returns to the street scene from the beginning as if no time had passed. The man with the cigar puts the newspaper away and finally makes eye contact with the prostitute (whom we recognize from the crime story). Both leave the café without exchanging a word. Shot from an angle that makes her slim body disappear behind the man’s grotesquely protruding abdomen, the film ends with the prostitute and her customer simply walking out of the frame. One final shot shows trash drifting down an empty street. No suicide or melodramatic redemption: the film refuses closure. The prostitute remains a prostitute, and life goes on. The film coolly registers the fact that the forces of the capitalist market are stronger than any desires for change because the desires are themselves defined by capitalism. The critic of the Communist paper Die Rote Fahne rightfully wondered why the film didn’t provide a glimmer of hope, at least for the unemployed worker, to find solidarity in organized class struggle. Harbor Drift, in contrast to Mother Krause, shows no marching towards a new future."

"The most remarkable feature of this film is Friedl Behn-Grund’s innovative camerawork, which appropriates experimental and abstract film techniques and invents new expressionist ways to manipulate light. Dark shadows punctured by splotches of light and eerily lit wind-swept trees set against a black background create a nightmarish atmosphere of fear and premonition. An often unsteady camera seeks unusual angles to display distorted perspectives, and out-of-focus close-ups conjure up a sense of panic. (Stylistically, Harbor Drift has much in common with Ernö Metzner’s experimental short Polizeibericht Überfall, which appeared in April 1929.) The film’s rapid-cut montage sequences follow the Russian School of editing that had become customary for all proletarian filmmaking since Battleship Potemkin’s Berlin premiere in 1926. Harbor Drift uses sex and crime to draw attention to the human cost of capitalism, but in line with the tenets of New Objectivity, it rejects any romantic hope for a social revolution. Its disillusioned and hardened look at the world foreshadows the dark and gritty universe of 1940s American film noir, which unsurprisingly became a haven for Weimar cinema in exile." – ANTON KAES

AA: This movie is much stronger than I remembered, having seen it only once before, in a 16 mm print at Goethe-Institut in Tampere in 1974. 

Made during the most golden years of the silent era, it is a masterpiece of urbanity, its account of the stream of consciousness no less impressive than what Joyce and Woolf were doing. 

The bustling streets and the reflections of water in a North German harbour town are two contrasting visual worlds in the story of the unemployed guy, the streetwalking woman and the professional beggar who lives in a boat permanently anchored by the waterfront. 

There is the harsh reality on the one hand, and the dreams and the illusions on the other. Even movie illusions are mentioned, but "the movie is just more of the same". 

The central illusory object is the necklace, believed precious, actually worthless. Love may be another illusion, crushed mercilessly in the brutal circumstances by the gangster boss who roughs up the woman and throws her birdcage and flower bouquet on the floor. 

Political illusions are ignored. 

Things to remember: - strong blitz montages - the dazzle of the necklace momentarily expressed in a close-up out of focus - the women of the night: "öd und einsam liegt die nächtliche Strasse" - yes, Jenseits der Strasse does belong to the predecessors of film noir - the elegant design of the intertitles - the runs in her stocking, her tired feet, removing her make-up, "der arme Mensch zum Vorschein" - the counter-image to the squalor: the girl with the nice smile facing the boat-home - the other counter-image: the single night of bliss between the man and the woman - the montage of the lonely wandering, "the feet that walk" emphasized by Kracauer - the wild camera angles in the climactic fight and the fire of the boat-home - the empty space on the street where the beggar used to sit. 

Having seen A. W. Sandberg's Dickens adaptation Our Mutual Friend the night before I was struck by similarities in certain of the characters (Gaffer Hexam and the beggar) and themes (the waterfront and its vultures). 

A brilliant print.

Wednesday, October 09, 2013

Die Verrufenen / The Slums of Berlin / [The Outcasts] (2013 restoration, 2K DCP by Deutsche Kinemathek, Berlin)



DIE VERRUFENEN (DER FÜNFTE STAND) Nach Erlebnissen von Heinrich Zille / Viides sääty / (The Slums of Berlin) [I malfamati (Il quinto livello) / The Outcasts (The Fifth Estate)] (Gerhard Lamprecht-Produktion der National-Film AG, Berlin, DE 1925) D: Gerhard Lamprecht; SC: Gerhard Lamprecht, Luise Heilborn-Körbitz; DP: Karl Hasselmann; AD: Otto Moldenhauer; C: Bernhard Goetzke (Robert Kramer), Aud Egede Nissen (Emma), Arthur Bergen (Gustav), Mady Christians (Regine Lossen), Eduard Rothauser (Rottmann), Frida Richard (Frau Heinicke), Paul Bildt (padre di/father of Robert), Rudolf Biebrach (mercante di bestiame/ livestock trader), Margarete Kupfer (governante/housekeeper), Robert Garrison (sarto/tailor), Maria Forescu (sua moglie/his wife), Max Maximilian (straccivendolo/rag seller); [2K?] DCP (from 35 mm), 113' (transferred at 18 fps); print source: Deutsche Kinemathek – Museum für Film und Fernsehen, Berlin. Deutsche Zwischentitel. Teatro Verdi (Le Giornate del Cinema Muto, Pordenone), with e-titles in English and Italian, grand piano, digital piano, accordeon and a phonograph record: Donald Sosin, 9 Oct 2013

Rolf Aurich, Wolfgang Jacobsen: "“The engineer Robert Kramer, released from prison, cannot find his way back to civilian life. His father casts him out, his bride has broken up with him and married another. There is no work. Descending ever deeper, he lands in a shelter for the homeless, and wants to end his life, but is held back by Emma, a streetwalker. He finds refuge with her; here he also works, sewing sacks, as he had learned in prison. Then he helps an old photographer. But Robert and Emma are suddenly torn apart. Emma’s brother, a ne’er-do-well who had been in prison with Robert, has to flee because of a new crime in which he has involved his sister, taking Emma with him. Robert succeeds in working his way up again in a factory, until he has a managerial position outside Berlin. When he returns, he learns that Emma is dying. He hurries to her, to whom he owes so much, he, the only one she ever really loved. She dies in his arms.”"

"This was Gerhard Lamprecht’s summary of his film Die Verrufenen (The Outcasts), made in 1925. The text is on one of hundreds of index cards, with which he both documented and facilitated access to his film collection – which included his own films, as well as those he had collected. All important information, including the film’s producer, length of reels, censorship dates, laboratory, or foreign title, was entered by Lamprecht in impressively legible handwriting, almost completely free from error. In a 1965 interview conducted by the Deutsche Kinemathek’s former curator, Gero Gandert, Lamprecht explained that the plot of the film had been inspired by the characters and stories of the artist Heinrich Zille (1858-1929) – especially the character of a certain “Paule”, who, after he had seen the film, complained to Zille that “his life had been so precisely recounted” that “the whole world knew” now “who was meant, and it would damage him greatly”."

"The production of the film, initiated and promoted by Adolf Heilborn, a doctor, popular science author, and personal friend of Zille, as well as the brother of Lamprecht’s screenwriting collaborator Luise Heilborn-Körbitz, was difficult to get started. Both Erich Pommer of Decla and the producers at Gloria had already rejected the material as unpopular. Eventually an ally was found in Franz Vogel, with whom Lamprecht had been acquainted at Eiko-Film, and who in 1925 was a producer for National-Film. The authors’ intention was to depict life realistically within a feature-film plot. Lamprecht and his production manager Ernst Körner looked for extras in the area of Schlesischer Bahnhof (since 1998 once more known as Ostbahnhof). The “physical examinations” of those who were candidates for small parts took place, according to Lamprecht, in a pub run by a film fan. Asked by Gandert whether Die Verrufenen was a film of social criticism, the director resisted, noting that this expression was not current back then: “For those days, the film was so daring that nobody believed it would get past the censor.” Nor did Lamprecht accept the claim that a happy ending had blunted the sharpness of the film’s criticism, saying instead that the film had “an almost documentary truth to it”."

"The international success of the film, which was shown in the United States as The Slums of Berlin and in France under the title Les Deshérités de la vie, rested upon its “humanity”. Contemporary reviews were largely enthusiastic. Though Otto Steinicke in the Communist paper Die Rote Fahne (The Red Flag) complained as expected about the “messed-up Milljöh” (milieu), Werner Bonwitt in the widely-read B.Z. Am Mittag praised the direction for avoiding everything “inauthentic”, and in the liberal Berliner Tageblatt Erich Burger wrote that Lamprecht had “a sure eye for the contrasting shadings of the different types”, but questioned the broad playing of some scenes, which disturbed “the unity of the pictorial composition”. In the Berliner Volks-Zeitung, the critic Fränze Dyck-Schnitzer ennobled Lamprecht’s work as the “second social film”, after Murnau’s Der letzte Mann; in a reference to Murnau’s title, she saw in Lamprecht’s film “a visual work that, without prettifying, but also without disgusting, tells the story of the little people, the ‘last people’, so to speak. Told with love and understanding, with tenderness and a forgiving look also at the ridiculousness of this condition. This work contains great human compassion.”" – Rolf Aurich, Wolfgang Jacobsen

AA: This movie is literally signed by Heinrich Zille whom we see drawing in the beginning, and the drawing comes alive as the movie we see.

Like Berlin Alexanderplatz this is a story about a man who is released from prison and who finds it almost overwhelming to return to normal life again. All doors are closed, everybody is against him.

Like in Jenseits der Strasse the outsider's only true friend is a streetwalker, here called Emma, a truly good human being (Aud Egede Nissen). The scenes we witness with her are unusual. For example she visits a single father, a widower with three little kids ("dad, remember, what you promised to mom"), and turns away.

This is a story of being left outside, finding no place to go in society. Robert's dad is only interested in stamp collecting, not at all in helping his son. We never learn what happened, but Robert has been convicted for perjury (Meineid). "One can commit perjury to keep one's integrity".

But Robert gets an opportunity to show his skill as an engineer, fixing a printing machine before an urgent deadline.

Meanwhile, Emma has been used as a decoy in a robbery which turns violent. Emma is convicted, and after her prison term she falls fatally ill. "I had many men. Robert I loved." "She was the only one who saved me from ruin".

The miserable games of poor children are a refrain in this movie. "Armut, Elend, Laster, und Alkohol" (poverty, squalor, vice, and alcohol) bring these human beings outside society.

Robert has now a secure path, but he has not forgotten. He is deeply restless and concerned about the world separate from others which we do not try to fix.

The earliest film in Lamprecht's naturalistic Berlin cycle has a Zolaesque passion for observations of reality and comes close to a documentary. The performances are realistic and subdued.

The bitter observations about outcasts are still relevant. "If one really wants to work one finds work" is still being claimed.

Expert restoration from a 35 mm source from Moscow and from a 16 mm source from Germany, HD ARRI 2013. There were slight DCP hickups in the presentation.



Wednesday, June 29, 2016

Takový je život / So ist das Leben / Such is Life (2016 digital restoration Národní filmový archiv etc.)


Valeska Gert and Theodor Pištěk in Takový je život / So ist das Leben / Such is Life. Please click to enlarge the image.

Sellaista on elämä [Finnish tv YLE TV1 1971] / Telle est la vie / [Così è la vita]. CZ/DE. Year of production: 1929. Year of premiere: 1930. D+SC: Carl Junghans. Cinematography: László Schäffer. AD: Ernst Meiwers. C: Vera Baranovskaja (la lavandaia), Theodor Pištěk (il marito), Máňa Ženíšková (la figlia), Wolfgang Zilzer (il corteggiatore), Jindřich Plachta (il sarto), Manja Kellerová (la moglie del sarto), Eman Fiala (il pianista), Valeska Gert (la cameriera), Uli Tridenskaja (amica della lavandaia), Betty Kysilková (cassiera). P: Star-Film, Carl Junghans-Filmproduktion. DCP. B&w. 63 min
    Restored in 2016 from a 35 mm safety print and a 35 mm safety internegative at the Hungarian Filmlab under the supervision of the Národní filmový archiv. Digital restoration of this film was kindly supported by a grant from Iceland, Liechtenstein and Norway and co-financed by the ministry of Culture of the Czech Republic.
    Il Cinema Ritrovato, Bologna
    DCP from: Národní filmový archiv
    ♪ Grand piano Maud Nelissen – alla batteria: Frank Bockius
    Introduce Gian Luca Farinelli, Volker Schlöndorff & Jeanne Pommeau
    Ritrovati e restaurati
    Czech intertitles with English subtitles
    Cinema Lumiere – Sala Officinema/Mastroianni, 29 June 2016

Jeanne Pommeau (Bologna catalog): "Carl Junghans’s film captures the tragic story of an aging laundress, whose drudgery and toil support a licentious and abusive alcoholic husband. Following the wave of social realism in European cinema, the film tries to be true to life, refusing embellishment or sentimentalism. In this way, it distinguished itself from the other films produced during this period in Prague. German social cinema and the cinematic expression of Soviet cinema (some shots are only two frames long) influenced Carl Junghans and are not only present in the style of the film itself, but also in the casting which included personalities who had already played in decisive films that influenced its genesis. The choice of Vera Baranovskaja as the main character is a reference to the sacrifice and the moral integrity of Pudovkin’s Mother. The performance of Valeska Gert, who plays a waitress liberated from the usual confinement of female repertoire, is essential not only for the characterization of the waitress, but also to associate the film with avant-garde ideas and aesthetics and to set it apart from mainstream productions."

"A few weeks after its initial release in Berlin’s Ufa-Theater, some shots, considered too obviously sexually explicit and indecent, were censored in Czechoslovakia: a customer touching the manicurist’s knee, the lovers’ scene, a man carrying his bedpan, a doctor proposing a price for an abortion, a drunken husband heading to the toilet."

"So far, no original print of the silent version has been found in the world. A 1950’s print – made from a print dating most likely from the first release in Germany in 1930 that included all the censored sequences – was the best source available for the digitization. The Czech intertitles, produced in the 1950s probably for a sound version, are more concise than in the original Czech version that did not survive. All the other existing film materials have been made from this print. We were determined to preserve its integrity throughout the digitization process." – Jeanne Pommeau

AA: Revisited after 45 years a classic of Czech and German Neue Sachlichkeit, a refined and moving film about poverty and the working class, with affinities with Die freudlose Gasse, Mutter Krausens Fahrt ins Glück, Jenseits der Strasse, Phil Jutzi, Gerhard Lamprecht, Werner Hochbaum, Slatan Dudow, et al. The associative and lyrical montages also bring to mind contemporary French masterpieces such as Rien que les heures and Ménilmontant.

The film is divided into chapters with headlines such as: 1. The Daily Wages, 2. The Day of Rest, 3. Blue Monday, 4. The Day of Feast, 5. The Day of Woe, 6. The Day of Destiny, and 7. The Day of Grief. The headlines are accompanied with proverbs such as "sloth is the mother of sin" and "misfortune seldom comes alone". The proverb concept was adopted by R. W. Fassbinder in his tv series Berlin Alexanderplatz, set in the same period.

Such Is Life is a naturalistic, at times even animalistic, film based on crisp and sober observation. The cinematography by László Schäffer is first-rate. The editing by the director Carl Junghans himself is sharp and intelligent. Beyond naturalism, the film also displays a robust Formwille, complete with homages to Eisenstein (a statue montage). It also has a strong cast, including Vera Baranovskaya, famous from Pudovkin's Mother. Moreover, Such Is Life belongs to the films where there are no bit parts: all characters are colourful and meaningful.

The incredible Valeska Gert (1892-1978) was introduced in the screening by Volker Schlöndorff who made a fine portrait documentary on her: Nur zum Spass, nur zum Spiel (1977), covering her career from Pabst (Die freudlose Gasse, Tagebuch einer Verlorenen, Die 3-Groschen-Oper) and Renoir (Nana) to Fellini (Giuliette degli spiriti) and Schlöndorff himself (Der Fangschuss). And that was just the film part of her career.

The husband (the great Theodor Pištěk, also a production manager for the film) is the sloth who gets fired when he is late from work. The daughter, too, is fired from her job as a manicurist when she resists advances from a "gentleman" customer. Valeska Gert is the saloon girl with a thick skin to whom the husband escapes, spending the family's household money on her. In Pudovkin's Mother Baranovskaya played the victim of oppression who rises against her condition. Such Is Life is a melancholy film which ends in her submission, injury, and death.

The last chapters are lyrical, elegiac, and tragic. Only the wind blows over her, and she is gone. The close-ups of the members of the funeral service are expressive. Their faces and eyes are soulful. It is an unforgettable portrait gallery. Such is life. There is no "The End" title.

In this purely visual movie the pictorial quality of the DCP is often very good. A fine job of restoration of an important film.

Friday, March 01, 1974

MARCH 1974, TAMPERE

Executive Suite / Arpa on heitetty. US 1954. D: Robert Wise. tv
Повесть пламенных лет / Liekehtivän taivaan alla / Chronicle of the Flaming Years. SU 1961. D: Julia Solntseva. SEA Tampere
El tigre saltó y mató, pero morirá... morirá... / Tiikeri hyppäsi ja tappoi, mutta se kuolee... kuolee... CU 1973. D: Santiago Álvarez. SEA Tampere
HUNGARIAN SHORTS. Vanha nainen (1970), Barbaarien aika (1970), Koncertissimo (1970), Tiettyjä ennusteita (1967), Ovela pikku laiva, 5 minuuttia murhia (1966), Pidä kiirettä kone (1973), Auringon ja kuun vangitseminen (1967), Hautajaiset (1970), Tarina koppakuoriaisesta (1963), Tandem (1971), Jetin laulu (1970), Sillan vihkiminen (1969), Aallonpituuksia (1970), Muotokuva (1971), Kalendarium (1972), Linja on varattu (1970), Kolme jänistä, Strip Tease (1970), Elämäntyö (1971). Teku
Goya / Goya. DD 1971. D: Konrad Wolf. Donatas Banionis. Monroe
Турксиб / Turksib. SU 1929. D: Viktor Turin. SEA Tampere
Jenseits der Strasse / Kadun tuolla puolen. DE 1929. D: Leo Mittler. Goethe-Institut
Duel in the Sun / Kaksintaistelu auringossa. US 1946. D: King Vidor. Jennifer Jonoes, Gregory Peck, Joseph Cotten. tv
Madárkák / Tipuset / Birdies. HU 1971. D: Géza Böszörményi. tv
Sujut / [Even]. TVM. FI 1974. D: Veli-Matti Saikkonen. Veijo Meri. Vesa Mäkelä. tv
Sól ziemi czarnej / Mustan maan maku / Salt of the Black Earth. PL 1969. D: Kazimierz Kutz. tv
Это сладкое слово — свобода! / Suloinen sana vapaus / That Sweet Word: Liberty!. LT-SU 1973. D: Vytautas Žalakevičius. Pirkka
Sacco e Vanzetti / Julma kierre. IT/FR 1971. D: Giuliano Montaldo. Joan Baez. Gian Maria Volontè. Kino-Palatsi
Igy jöttem / Kotiinpaluu / My Way Home. HU 1965. D: Miklós Jancsó. Teku

Tuesday, January 01, 2013

My best films of 2012


Sakari Kirjavainen: Hiljaisuus / Silence (FI 2011).

THE BEST NEW FILMS I SAW IN 2012 IN THE ORDER I SAW THEM
Hiljaisuus ([Silence], FI 2011, Sakari Kirjavainen)
Canned Dreams (IE/NO/PT/FR/FI 2011, Katja Gauriloff)
Carnage (FR/DE/PL/ES 2011, Roman Polanski)
Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy (GB/FR/DE 2011, Tomas Alfredson)
Hugo (US 2011, Martin Scorsese)
A Dangerous Method (DE/CA 2011, David Cronenberg)
Shame (GB 2011, Steve McQueen)
Soundbreaker (FI 2011, Kimmo Koskela)
Eräänlainen rakkaustarina (My Little Window, FI 2011, Lauri-Matti Parppei)
Sodankylä ikuisesti 1-4 (Sodankylä Forever, FI 2010-2011, Peter von Bagh)
Cave of Forgotten Dreams (CA/US/FR//DE/GB 2010, Werner Herzog)
The Descendants (US 2011, Alexander Payne)
Les Neiges du Kilimandjaro (The Snows of Kilimanjaro, FR 2011, Robert Guédiguian)
The Pirates! In an Adventure with Scientists! (GB/US 2012, Peter Lord)
Dark Shadows (US 2012, Tim Burton)
A Torinói ló (The Turin Horse, HU/FR/DE/CH/US 2011, Béla Tarr)
Mario Ruspoli, prince des baleines et autres raretés (FR 2011, Florence Dauman)
Side by Side (US 2012, Chris Kenneally; Keanu Reeves)
Carlos I-III (FR/DE 2010, Olivier Assayas) the long version in three episodes, totalling 330 min
Barbara (DE 2012, Christian Petzold)
Cosmopolis (FR/CA/PT/IT 2012, David Cronenberg)
Terraferma (IT/FR 2011, Emanuele Crialese)
Beasts of the Southern Wild (US 2012, Benh Zeitlin)
Moonrise Kingdom (US 2012, Wes Anderson)
Holy Motors (FR/DE 2012, Leos Carax)
Margaret (US 2008/2011, Kenneth Lonergan)
Urbanized (US/GB 2011, Gary Hustwit)
1 Plus 1 Plus 1 - Sympathy for the Decay (FI 2012, Ilppo Pohjola)
Searching for Sugar Man (SE/GB 2012, Malik Bendjelloul)
Sinivalkoinen valhe (When Heroes Lie, FI 2012, Arto Halonen)
Palme (SE/DK 2012, Maud Nycander, Kristina Lindström)
Akkaansilta ([The Akkaansilta Bridge], FI 2011, Juha Rinnekari)
De rouille et d'os (Rust and Bone, FR/BE 2012, Jacques Audiard)

AN INTRIGUING YEAR IN BLOCKBUSTERS
Hunger Games (US 2012, Gary Ross)
The Amazing Spider-Man (US 2012, Marc Webb)
The Dark Knight Rises (US/GB 2012, Christopher Nolan)
Skyfall (GB/US 2012, Sam Mendes)
The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn - Part 2 (US 2012, Bill Condon).
Isn't this a strange list of names for some of the most popular films of the year?
Good directors, experimental elements, bleak visuals, dystopian visions, deranged and broken protagonists, anti-heroes, monsters as identification figures. The Twilight Saga is the most desolate of them all, a turning-point in the mainstream cinema's horror fiction: the identification figure is a monster, the plot is about saving the monster child, and there is practically no "normality" in the story. I was puzzled about the suicide wish fantasy, but I am apparently the only person in the world who sees it that way. - Epic fraud and social injustice were recurrent themes in the year's movies, including Arbitrage (US 2012, Nicholas Jarecki). - Superstorm Sandy seemed prefigured in The Turin Horse, and "after us the flood" imagery appeared in Moonrise Kingdom and Beasts of the Southern wild.

DIGITAL WAS GETTING BETTER
A cold, bleak, and lifeless look was predominant, but there were exceptions. Margaret, Beasts of the Southern Wild, and Moonrise Kingdom were shot on 16 mm, and the warm photochemical quality was successfully sustained in the digital intermediate. Skyfall was the first James Bond film shot digitally, but it had a richer look than the two previous ones that had gone through a bleak digital intermediate process.

3D
My best 3D experiences were: Stefan Drössler's updated magisterial illustrated lecture on the history of the 3D, The Amazing Spider-Man, Step Up Revolution, and Life of Pi. I'm still processing The Hobbit in HFR: the image was bright and clear in Tennispalatsi 1 where 3D has often been too dark.

MY FAVOURITE COMEDY PERFORMANCE
Ellen Page as Monica "who knows one line from every poem" in To Rome with Love (US/IT/ES 2012, Woody Allen). I like the combination of satire and tenderness.
AN ANTHOLOGY PIECE IN A COMEDY
Sacha Baron Cohen's speech in defense of dictatorship in The Dictator (US 2012, Larry Charles)

BOOKS OF THE YEAR
David Bordwell: Pandora's Digital Box (E-book, Madison, Wisconsin: The Irvington Way Institute Press, 2012).
Torkell Sætervadet: FIAF Digital Projection Guide. Brussels: FIAF, 2012.

NEW RESTORATIONS AND TOPICAL RETROSPECTIVES
Stefan Drössler: The History of 3D (his touring illustrated lecture, 2012 update)
Universal Pictures Centenary: our tribute was to screen nine Robert Siodmak masterpieces from his film noir cycle
Die Weber (The Weavers, DE 1927, Friedrich Zelnik, 2012 restoration)
Magde dhaka tara (The Cloud-Capped Star, IN 1960, Ritwik Ghatak, 2012 restoration)
Komedie om geld (The Trouble with Money, NL 1936, Max Ophuls, newly restored)
Kalpana (Imagination, IN 1948, Uday Shankar, 2012 restoration)
Lewat djam malam (After the Curfew, ID 1954, Usmar Ismail, 2012 restoration)
Phono-Cinéma-Théâtre (FR 1900, Paul Decauville, 2012 restoration)
Vor fælles Ven / Our Mutual Friend (DK 1921, A.W. Sandberg, 2012 restoration)
Moi syn ([My Son], SU 1928, Yevgenii Cherviakov; Anna Sten, 2011 study dvd)
The Spanish Dancer (US 1923, Herbert Brenon; Pola Negri, newly restored)
The Jiří Trnka 2012 touring show from Naródni filmový archiv (Prague)
Die freudlose Gasse (Joyless Street, DE 1925, G.W. Pabst, the 2012 colour print from Filmmuseum München)
Kevade (Spring, EE-SU 1970, Arvo Kruusement) the Estonian Film 100 touring show in 2012
Pohjalaisia ([The People from Pohjanmaa] / [The People from the Plains], FI 1925, Jalmari Lahdensuo) 2012 restoration

FURTHER DELIGHTS IN FESTIVALS AND ARCHIVAL SCREENINGS
David Golder (FR 1931, Julien Duvivier)
Olivier Assayas retrospective: it is very rewarding to view his films within a short period
The Making Over of Mother (US 1916, Christie Film Co., Horace Davey; Neal Burns and Betty Compson)
Prostoi sluchai (A Simple Case, SU 1932, Vsevolod Pudovkin)
Jenseits der Strasse (Harbour Drift, DE 1929, Leo Mittler)
A Woman of Affairs (US 1928, Clarence Brown; Greta Garbo) with the Carl Davis score
Bab el hadid (Central Station, EG 1958, Youssef Chahine)
Il cammino della speranza (The Way of Hope, IT 1950, Pietro Germi)

Sunday, October 14, 2012

My highlights in Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (Pordenone, 2012)


Georges Méliès: Les Aventures de Robinson Crusoé (FR 1902) with Georges Méliès as Robinson Crusoe. Photo from Wikipédia.

This year Le Giornate del Cinema Muto was at its best, with discoveries every day, either unknown / forgotten / neglected works, or new and better versions, prints or presentations. This is mildly incredible, as the heyday of the silent feature film lasted only 16 years, and the GCM has been going on already for 31 years. These are years of maturity at the GCM, the complex machine working very well thanks to the dedication of the great festival team. Promisingly, children (Striking a New Note) and young newcomers (the Collegium) keep emerging as gray panthers fade away.

Selig Polyscope 1-4. Curated by Andrew Erish, an important retrospective covering a major motion picture company. "William Selig established the first movie studio in Los Angeles and launched the first Western series with real Native Americans and actual cowboys, most importantly Tom Mix. Selig also established the jungle adventure genre, using footage actually shot in Africa and building a zoo of his own, which became the first movie studio theme park. In partnership with W. R. Hearst Selig produced the first successful American newsreel. Selig also was a pioneer of longer and more complex narratives: among fiction films, The Coming of Columbus was the first 3-reel movie distributed by General Film in America; The Adventures of Kathlyn (believed lost), the first action-adventure serial produced in America; and The Spoilers, the first 2-hour fiction feature film made by an American producer. In Selig's movies, Kathlyn Williams became the first American action heroine and serial queen in jungle adventures; also a convincing Queen Isabella in the Columbus epic." (This summary based on the introduction by Andrew Erish). -- I was struck by the audacity of the vision of society in these "on the road to Hollywood" movies. Columbus is brought back to Spain in chains because he has failed to provide enough gold for Queen Isabella. The West is really wild in Selig's movies, and so are the North (The Spoilers) and the South (the Panama of Ne'er-Do-Well). The breakdown of justice is total in the Alaska of The Spoilers where law and order can be bought, and fair-playing gold-miners are evicted from their lucrative claims just like that. -- Interesting is the recurrent figure of the strong woman, in all the Kathlyn Williams movies, and also in the Tom Mix Western Legal Advice, where civilization is represented by a female attorney. -- The art of film direction and flair in cinematic expression is not particularly highly developed in the movies produced by Selig. Selig had strong concepts, he found good material and exciting performers, but a truly irresistible cinematic drive was missing in the films he produced.

Opening Gala Concert Les Aventures de Robinson Crusoe (Georges Méliès) - Maud Nelissen's quartet: the joy of music to a newly discovered full version of a major Méliès movie made soon after Le Voyage dans la Lune (but perhaps not as inspired as it).

Opening Gala Concert The Patsy (King Vidor / Marion Davies) - Maud Nelissen and FVG Mitteleuropa Orchestra. A delightful and warmly humoristic score in good synch with the bright comedy which picks up in inspiration towards the ending, including Marion's funny series of parodies of Hollywood stars.

Prostoi sluchai / A Simple Case (Vsevolod Pudovkin). A major Pudovkin movie I had never seen before, as strong as his most famous works, and exploring new ground, although there is a great unsolvable problem in the fundament (the mediation between the political and the private is not really worked out). As a work of visual poetry it is superb, a movie about encountering the shock of the new. There are shots with starkly reduced composition, extreme close-ups cropped in surprising ways, lyrical passages of nature, blitz montages of war and urbanity, and enigmatic images. Devices include slow motion, reverse motion, and time lapse. The railway station sequence has montages that are indistinguishable from abstract avantgarde. The keyword is ellipsis. And there is a sense of something inscrutable, sinister, and uncanny going on beyond the optimistic hurrah facade.

German Animation, 1910-1930, 1-2. Curated by Annette Grosche, an excellent series of animations, mostly commercials, done in such an irreverent way that the attitude to the message of the miraculous might of the commodities can be seen as an intentional parody. Some of the animations are famous pieces by Ruttmann, Reiniger, et al., but the others have often an equally high quality, making this a treasury of discoveries. I have never seen better prints of these movies.

Striking a New Note 2012: Concert of the orchestras of children of Pordenone and Cordenons playing to We Faw Down and Liberty (Laurel & Hardy / Leo McCarey). The children's playing had a special feeling of delight and determination. For instance there was a memorable touch in the way they played "The Star Spangled Banner" to the opening of Liberty (Washington... Lincoln... Laurel and Hardy in striped clothes running for their life, chased by the police).

Anna Sten discoveries, curated by Peter Bagrov: Zemlya v plenu / The Earth in Chains (Fyodor Ozep): oppressed by big land-owners, the young mother forced to serve the landlord's family; Torgovtsky slavoi / The Merchants of Glory (Leonid Obolenski): the first Marcel Pagnol film adaptation, a satirical concept worthy of Capra and Sturges; Provokator / Agent Provocateur (Viktor Turin): the first movie of both Turin and Sten, a tragedy of student rebels haunted by stool pigeons and agents provocateurs of the secret police; Stürme der Leidenschaft (Robert Siodmak): Anna Sten together with Emil Jannings in a movie prefiguring film noir (the French version Tumultes starred Charles Boyer and Florelle).

"Oh! Mother-in-Law!": curated by Elif Rongen-Kaynakçi, an inspired show of early comedies based on the oldest joke in the world (according to James Frazer and Margaret Mead even jungle tribes know it). My favourites: La Garçonnière de Rigadin (D: Georges Monca), Finalmente soli (D: Ernesto Vaser), and The Making Over of Mother (P: Al Christie).

Zvenigora (Aleksandr Dovzhenko). Used to seeing our nonlinear, nonsensical Helsinki print it was a revelation to see this linear, easy-to-follow print from Vienna.

The Jonathan Dennis Memorial Lecture: David Sproxton. Insights in the secrets of animation revealed by one of the major figures in Aardman Animation. "Do we see what we believe or do we believe what we see?": reflections on the art of illusion and the psychology of visual perception dedicated to the memory of Richard Gregory. "The uncanny valley": ROBOT - ANDROID - HUMAN. We accept a doll, a robot, a matchstick man, and a cartoon figure as figures of fantasy and artifice. But if we move towards greater photorealistic illusion, we land into the uncanny valley where imitation starts to feel disgusting.

The Spanish Dancer (Herbert Brenon / Pola Negri): newly reconstructed and restored, a magnificent print of the Paramount version of the Victor Hugo story simultaneously filmed by Ernst Lubitsch for Mary Pickford as Rosita. A fine romantic adventure story, and an exhilarating guitar-flavoured live music performance.

Moi syn / My Son (Yevgenii Cherviakov / Anna Sten). Pyotr Bagrov has resurrected the memory of a major Russian director, Yevgenii Cherviakov, whose entire legacy was destroyed during the siege of Leningrad - until a print of Moi syn emerged from Museo del Cine Pablo Ducrós Hicken (Buenos Aires) which also gave us the complete Metropolis. Stark, laconic images, and performances which are forceful without exaggeration.

Seminar: Torkell Sætervadet: Are You Ready for Digital Projection? The Norwegian author of the projectionist's bible has now written a digital update, forthcoming in November 2012. Six main reasons to be cheerful for D-cinema: 1. Colour range. 2. Bit depth. 3. Virtual losslessness. 4. Consistency. 5. Content. 6. Cost (prices now rapidly coming down, next generation projectors only cost a third of the recent ones). Problems covered: resolution (4K recommended, it does not get better than that in projection), archival frame rates (already acknowledged but not yet implemented), sound (beware of white papers), 3D (a lot of light needed), DCP problems (keep them SMPTE compliant), how often do you need a new projector: every 10 years; warranty packages are expensive but essential.

A. W. Sandberg's Charles Dickens adaptations: screened in Pordenone's Charles Dickens retrospective this year: Vor fælles Ven / Our Mutual Friend, Little Dorrit, Stora Forventninger / Great Expectations. Not shown this time: David Copperfield. Having seen Sandberg's Great Expectations and David Copperfield before I was aware that they have probably been conscious or unconscious models for David Lean's and George Cukor's later, definitive sound film adaptations of the novels. Of equally high quality was Our Mutual Friend, with a fine sense of the uncanny in a story which might have been a good subject for Alfred Hitchcock in his The Lodger mode. I look forward to seeing Little Dorrit another time.

Jenseits der Strasse / Harbour Drift (Leo Mittler).  Much stronger than I remembered, a masterpiece of urbanity, the account of the stream of consciousness no less impressive than what Joyce and Woolf were doing, with an acute sense of the contrast between reality and illusions.

Phono-Cinéma-Théâtre: Visions animées des artistes célèbres. A magnificent reconstruction in colour and with sound partly from the original sound cylinders, partly reconstructed perfectly live by John Sweeney. An essential showcase of the performing arts and their greatest artists during la Belle Époque, made for the Paris World's Fair in 1900. An unforgettable evening.

Die freudlose Gasse / The Joyless Street (G. W. Pabst): The first screening of a new colour print of the latest Munich restoration from sometimes heartbreakingly duped sources. The magnificent feeling of the epoch and the society enhanced by the full detail and the care taken with the images, all part of a vital, organic, vibrant whole.

Late Thanhouser: A Modern Monte Cristo, Fires of Youth (Émile Chautard / Jeanne Eagels) In true Thanhouser fashion there is a plain, sober, and mature approach to the storytelling regardless of how wild the plot turns may be. Jeanne Eagels in one of her earliest film roles gives a natural and realistic performance.

Premio Jean Mitry: Pierre Étaix - his silent acceptance speech.

Closing Gala Concert A Woman of Affairs (Clarence Brown / Greta Garbo) - music composed and conducted by Carl Davis, inspired by Franz Liszt, played by FVG Mitteleuropa Orchestra. The bestselling novel The Green Hat turned into a tragedy of the lost generation, Douglas Fairbanks, Jr. dying of alcohol, Greta Garbo speeding towards death, yet protecting the honour of her loved one with dignity, John Gilbert in an understated role. Clarence Brown is in full command as a silent cinema storyteller. The Carl Davis score is refined.

MOVIES I MISSED AND LOOK FORWARD TO SEEING ANOTHER TIME: Oliver Twist (1922, Frank Lloyd / Jackie Coogan, Lon Chaney), The Corrick Collection Vol. 6, Little Dorrit (A.W. Sandberg), The Viking (Technicolor), A Tale of Two Cities (Frank Lloyd, 1917), The Only Way (Herbert Wilcox, 1926).

GREAT MOVIES I HAD SEEN BEFORE AND SKIPPED THIS TIME: The Goose Woman, Devushka s korobkoi / The Girl with the Hatbox, Hands Up!, Die Weber / The Weavers, La Passion de Jeanne d'Arc, Great Expectations (A. W. Sandberg).

This year for the first time archival 2K DCPs were screened in Le Giornate del Cinema Muto: Phono-Cinéma-Théâtre (from prints with a special Parnaland perforation), Provokator (from Oleksandr Dovzhenko National Centre, Kiev), and two A. W. Sandberg movies from the Danish Film Institute in Copenhagen (Our Mutual Friend, Little Dorrit). The change is not abrupt since we have seen prints of classic movies made via digital intermediates since the 1990s.

Monday, October 04, 2021

Gheongchun-eui sipjaro / Crossroads of Youth


Ahn Jong-hwa: 청춘의 십자로 / Gheongchun-eui sipjaro / Crossroads of Youth (KR 1934) starring Lee Won-yong (Young-bok) and Sin Il-sung (Young-ok).

Lee Gyu-seol: 근로의 끝에는 가난이 없다 / Geulloui kkeuteneun ganani eopda / If You Work Hard, There Will Be No Poverty (KR, ca 1925–1929).

Korea Prog. 2: The Legacy of Korean Silent Cinema
Le Giornate del Cinema Muto (GCM), Pordenone. Corona emergency security: half programming, half capacity, COVID certificate required, temperature measured, hand hygiene, face masks, distancing.
    Musical interpretation: Daan van den Hurk.
    Viewed at Teatro Verdi with e-subtitles in English and Italian, 4 Oct 2021.

"These two cultural films, If You Work Hard, There Will Be No Poverty, discovered at Gosfilmofond of Russia in 2019, and Crossroads of Youth (1934), collected in Korea in 2007, are a precious testament to Korean silent cinema." – Sungji Oh

근로의 끝에는 가난이 없다 / GEULLOUI KKEUTENEUN GANANI EOPDA [Per chi lavora duramente non vi sarà povertà/If You Work Hard, There Will Be No Poverty] (KR, ca 1925–1929)
regia/dir: Lee Gyu-seol. photog: Ota Hitoshi. cast: Park Soon-bong (Park Bok-geol), Kim Won-bo (Song Hyo-wan). prod, dist: Tokunaga Kumaichiro. copia/copy: DCP, 19 min; did./titles: KOR/JPN.  fonte/source: Korean Film Archive, Seoul.
    2020 preservation in 4K, stemming from Gosfilmofond.

Sungji Oh (GCM 2021): "A cultural film in the form of a fiction narrative, If You Work Hard, There Will Be No Poverty is an important discovery that fills a gap in the history of early Korean cinema. Found at Gosfilmofond of Russia in 2019, it was originally produced for the purpose of educating and enlightening the public under Japanese colonial rule; its director and cast were Korean."

"The plot is simple. Park Bok-geol and Song Hyo-wan are neighbors; Park ekes out a living by repairing shoes, Song by collecting and selling firewood. One day Park finds a wallet on the road. He takes it to the police and earns a reward, which then prompts him to work harder. He becomes busy and successful, and makes regular deposits at the local Post Office savings bank. Park comes to his neighbor’s rescue when Song loses his money. The two men reap the benefits of their conscientious work. This short yet entertaining film contains animation, various camera shots, special effects, and slapstick comedy."

"The film was produced and distributed by Tokunaga Kumaichiro, a prominent figure in the entertainment world of Korea under Japanese colonial rule, and directed by Lee Gyu-seol, who had previously directed Nongjungjo (1926) and played the father of the protagonist Young-jin in Na Wun-kyu’s Arirang (1926). That Ota Hitoshi, who had shot Korea’s first feature film Weolha-ui Mangseo (The Vow Made Below the Moon, 1923, directed by Yun Baek-nam) took part as the cinematographer shows that the film was the result of collective effort by several representative filmmakers of Korean silent cinema during the period of Japanese colonial rule. A cameo appearance by director Lee Gyu-seol makes it even more valuable.
" – Sungji Oh (GCM 2021)

청춘의 십자로 / CHEONGCHUN-EUI SIPJARO (Crossroads of Youth) [Crocevia della giovinezza] (KR 1934)
regia/dir, scen, mont/ed: Ahn Jong-hwa. photog: Lee Myeong-u. cast: Lee Won-yong (Young-bok), Sin Il-sung (Young-ok), Park Yeon (Gae-cheol), Kim Yeon-sil (Gye-soon), Moon Kyung-sim (Bong-seon). prod: Lee Hyeong-won. copia/copy: DCP, 75 min; did./titles: ENG by Sungji Oh and Stefan Drössler.  fonte/source: Korean Film Archive, Seoul.   

Sungji Oh (GCM 2021): "The oldest silent feature film in the KOFA collection, Crossroads of Youth was Ahn Jong-hwa’s third directorial work. In 2007, KOFA acquired 9 reels of the original nitrate negative – kept by a family that had run a theatre after liberation – and restored all but one, which had severe deterioration. In 2012, the film was designated a national cultural asset for its historical value as a primary source of Korean silent cinema."

"The film depicts the joys and sorrows of a group of young people at the crossroads of fate. A disillusioned young man named Young-bok leaves his village for Gyeongseong (Seoul) after his fiancée is seduced and abandoned by Myeong-gu. There he meets Gye-soon, who works in a gas station and looks after her ailing father. Meanwhile, Young-bok’s younger sister Young-ok starts working in a bar, where she meets Jang Gae-cheol, an unscrupulous friend of Myeong-gu who takes advantage of naïve women. Both Gye-soon and Young-ok become victims of their wiles, leading to Young-bok seeking revenge."

"Lee Won-yong, who plays Young-bok, was one the most popular Korean action stars of the time. Park Seung-pil and Lee Gu-young, who ran the Danseongsa, Korea’s first movie theatre, in Seoul, discovered him in the Joseon Budokan (martial arts hall) around 1927, during their search for a Korean Richard Talmadge. Sin Il-sung (Young-ok), rose to stardom at age 15 for her performance in the legendary film Arirang (1926). She sought to make a comeback with Crossroads of Youth after marriage, but received some unfavorable reviews: “She must’ve had confidence in her old acting skills, but is too old to play a girl.” (Dong-a Ilbo [East Asia Daily], 21 September 1934) Gye-soon was played by Kim Yeon-sil, who turned to acting in 1927 under the influence of her older brother, a silent-film narrator (byeonsa); she also had a singing career after 1930, and eventually defected to North Korea, where she continued acting."

"The film is an exquisite combination of melodrama and action, peppered with comedic elements. As a mark of its widespread popularity, the film came in sixth on the list of the top ten films – silent and sound – voted for by Korean audiences in November 1938."

"At the time of its initial release in 1934, Crossroads of Youth drew some favorable reviews. Two are quoted here: “The film achieves excellence in many aspects, including editing and acting. There are minor flaws here and there, but there’s no such thing as perfection after all…The unique techniques that herald a departure from the Joseon films of the past are much to the director’s credit.” (Chosun Ilbo [Korea Daily News], 28 Sept.‒3 Oct. 1934) “In terms of adapting, directing, acting, filming and editing, this film is a step ahead of all the other previous films – a commendable achievement for Korean cinema.” (Chosun JoongAng Ilbo [Korea JoongAng Daily News], 1-3 Dec.1934)
" – Sungji Oh (GCM 2021)

AA: A fascinating Korean double bill. I believe these are the first Korean silent films I have seen.

If You Work Hard, There Will Be No Poverty, the first movie, is like an educational film for children, a lesson in life, about the spirit of enterprise. Poverty will never leave the protagonist alone, and he already starts hallucinating in his hunger, but he is not a quitter and decides to work harder than ever. Good deeds pay themselves forward. Laughter overcomes tears. Friendship is above all. Naive, absolutely, but sincere and with conviction. There are Tolstoyan nuances in some turns of this cinematic lesson, shades of Polikushka when the poor shoemaker finds a stranger's purse and loses his own.

Crossroads of Youth surprises with poetic and experimental qualities. This copy, a daring experiment, is based on outtakes, and the version we see is to a great degree a creative interpretation with newly minted intertitles. The solutions by Sungji Oh and Stefan Drössler feel convincing and faithful to the spirit of the original. The visual approach brings to mind some of the most advanced poetic achievements of French (Ménilmontant) and German cinema (Jenseits der Strasse) and also early Josef von Sternberg: The Salvation Hunters.

The impressionistic approach, the ellipses, the unusual camera angles, the vision of the big city, the affinities with the city symphonies, the reflections on the water, the lyricism of nature, the verismo, the associative montage, the montages of extreme close-ups.

The characters are stereotyped, and there is a feeling of social engagement and social indignation in this saga of class society and exploitation. The movie is about standing up for your rights and transcending exploitation.

Memorable movies.