|
Shoah. The first sequence. Simon Srebnik returns to Chelmno. |
Shoah / Shoah. FR © 1985 Les Films Aleph. PC: Les Films Aleph / Historia Films. Avec la participation du Ministère de la Culture. D+SC: Claude Lanzmann. Direction de la photographie : Dominique Chapuis, Jimmy Glasberg, William Lubchansky, assistés par Caroline Champetier de Ribes, Jean-Yves Escoffier, Slavek Olczyk, Andrès Silvart ‒ negative: 16 mm ‒ original release format: 35 mm ‒ scanned in 2012 in 4K ‒ restored and released in 2012 in 2K. S: Bernard Aubuy, Michel Vionnet (en Israël). Montage: Claude Lanzmann, Ziva Postec, assistés par Geneviève de Gouvion Saint-Cyr, Bénédicte Mallet, Yaël Perlov, Christine Simonot, Anna Ruiz. Montage son : Danielle Fillios, Anne-Marie L’hôte, Sabine Mamou, assistées par Catherine Sabba, Catherine Trouillet. Mixage: Bernard Aubouy. Research assistants: Corinna Coulmas, Irène Steinfeldt-Levi, Shalmi Bar Mor.
Witnesses:
Simon Srebnik (Chelmno / Israel),
Mordechai Podchlebnik (Chelmno / Israel),
Hanna Zaidel (Israel),
Motke Zaidel (Vilnius / Israel),
Itzhak Dugin (Vilnius / Israel),
Jan Piwonski (Sobibor),
Richard Glazar (Treblinka / Switzerland),
Paula Biren (Auschwitz / Cincinnati),
Mrs. Pietyra (Auschwitz),
Mr. Filipowicz (Wlodawa),
Mr. Falborski (Kolo),
Abraham Bomba (Treblinka / Tel Aviv),
Czeslaw Borowi (Treblinka),
Treblinka villagers,
Treblinka railroad workers,
Henrik Gawkowski (Treblinka / Malkinia),
Rudolf Vrba (Auschwitz / New York),
Inge Deutschkron (Berlin / Israel),
Franz Suchomel (Treblinka / BRD),
Filip Müller (Auschwitz / Czechoslovakia),
Joseph Oberhauser (Belzec / Munich),
Alfred Spiess (prosecutor at the Treblinka trial in Frankfurt 1960),
Raul Hilberg (historian, Burlington, Vermont),
Franz Schalling (Chelmno / BRD),
Martha Michelsohn (Chelmno / BRD),
inhabitants of Grabow,
Moshe Mordo (Auschwitz / Corfu),
Armando Aaron (Corfu),
Walter Stier (executive of Germany's Eastern railway traffic during wartime / BRD),
Ruth Elias (Auschwitz / Israel),
Jan Karski (courier of the Polish government during wartime / professor in the USA),
Franz Grassler (deputy commander of the Warsaw ghetto during wartime / BRD),
Gertrude Schneider and her mother (Warsaw ghetto / New York),
Itzhak Zuckermann, "Antek" (Warsaw ghetto / Israel),
Simha Rottem, "Kajik" (Warsaw ghetto / Israel).
Telecast in Finland: 17.8.1994 YLE TV2 (Dokumenttiprojekti).
153 min (I), 120 min (II), 146 min (III), 147 min (IV), total 566 min = 9 hours 26 min
Digitally scanned in 4K and restored in 2K in 2012, supervised by Caroline Champetier, released by Why Not Productions, available with English subtitles.
The DocPoint classic documentary of the year: the choice of Mrs. Iris Olsson, the artistic director of the DocPoint Festival.
Screening introduced by Antti Alanen.
2K DCP with English subtitles sampled at Cinema Orion (DocPoint), 28 Jan 2017.
Why Not Productions: Numérisation et restauration (2012)
"
Le but principal était de respecter l’aspect de la copie 35 mm originale en utilisant les possibilités offertes par le scan numérique du négatif 16 mm original. L’ensemble du processus de numérisation et de restauration a été supervisé par Caroline Champetier, directrice de la photographie et assistante sur Shoah."
"Après de nombreux tests nous avons choisi un scan en résolution 4K, bien que la définition 2K semblait initialement suffisante pour le négatif 16 mm. Les deux principales questions concernant cette numérisation étaient le grain de la pellicule 16 mm des années 1970 et le problème du rendu des couleurs. La difficulté était de conserver le grain comme tel, sans le transformer en bruit numérique ou le supprimer artificiellement. Le 4K permet de rentrer plus profondément « à l’intérieur » du grain. Il offre aussi une plus grande marge de manœuvre pour l’étalonnage et la restauration.
La restauration est restée légère afin de conserver de la vie dans l’image numérique, une image propre qui n’efface pas le passage du temps. Elle a suivi un principe simple: mieux vaut un défaut original qu’un artefact digital."
"Le mix mono original a été respecté, avec une légère correction de l’égalisation."
"Restauration produite par Why Not Productions en 2012, avec le soutien de La Fondation pour la mémoire de la Shoah, du Centre National du Cinéma et de l’Image Animée et la participation de IFC et Criterion. Scan, restauration, et son: L’Immagine Ritrovata, Bologne; Etalonnage, finalisation: Eclair Group, France."
"
I will give them an everlasting name" – Isaiah 56:5
AA: As yesterday was the Holocaust Memorial Day, the timing is appropriate to screen Shoah this weekend. Selected by Iris Olsson, artistic director of the DocPoint festival, as the classic of the year, this is the first screening in Finland of the 2012 digital restoration by Why Not Productions of Shoah. There is capacity audience at Cinema Orion, a perfect space for this intimate epic.
How to express something that exceeds the limits of human understanding? That is the problem faced by every artist who has tried to create an account of the Holocaust. Alain Resnais found a classic solution in Nuit et brouillard (1956), but Claude Lanzmann's approach was more radical. There is no commentary, no soundtrack score music, nor a single historical clip in his 9½ hour Shoah.
In Shoah we only meet the witnesses interviewed by Lanzmann for his film, and we are taken to the landscapes of the tragedy by Lanzmann in the present of the film's production.
A documentary film can achieve heights of tragedy. The theme of Shoah could not be more horrendous. Yet Shoah transcends it by the luminosity of its vision and the profound humanity of its witnesses.
Shoah and Vertigo share a basic theme. Both are about death, a journey to the river of death.
Lanzmann emphasizes the mythical connection by starting his film with Simon Srebnik returning to the river at the former concentration camp of Chelmno. The image immediately evokes ferryman Charon at the river of Styx.
This digital restoration of 2012 has been performed with loving care. For digital, nature is the greatest stumbling block, and Shoah starts with haunting imagery of nature. The visual quality has been preserved with excellent taste and judgment with subtle and refined results. The warm humanity of the witnesses' faces, essential for the spiritual balance of this extraordinary film, has also been perfectly conveyed.
...
P.S. We wanted to invite Claude Lanzmann on the occasion, but heard from Nadège Le Breton at Why Not Productions that " Il se déplace très peu à l'étranger, ayant dépassé l'âge respectable de 90 ans... ". Claude Lanzmann died on 5 July 2018.