Monday, May 18, 2020

Virtual art tour (inspired by The Art Issue of The New York Review of Books): Félix Fénéon


Paul Signac: Opus 217. Against the Enamel of a Background Rhythmic with Beats and Angles, Tones, and Tints, Portrait of M. Félix Fénéon in 1890, 1890. Museum of Modern Art / Paige Knight / © 2019 Artists Rights Society (ARS), New York / ADAGP, Paris. From: The New York Review of Books, 14 May 2020.

Georges-Pierre Seurat: Model in Profile, 1886. Musée d’Orsay, Paris / RMN-Grand Palais / Adrien Didierjean. From: The New York Review of Books, 14 May 2020.

The New York Review of Books: The Art Issue, 14 May 2020.
Corona lockdown art museum visits.

For the first time in the 125-year old history of the cinema, movie theatres are closed worldwide. The same with museums and galleries. In an innovative way, The New York Review of Books has dedicated an issue for art exhibitions that can be visited online. It's not the same thing but better than nothing! I started two weeks ago with my first one, Gerhard Richter: Painting After All (Met Breuer, New York). The visual quality of the museums' digital tours is high. They are worth visiting on a good television screen.

Following the NYRB Art Issue page by page, my next exhibition is Félix Fénéon, introduced by an essay by Jed Perl: A Rage for Clarity.

Virtual visit:
MoMA, The Museum of Modern Art, New York City. Félix Fénéon. The Anarchist and the Avant-Garde—From Signac to Matisse and Beyond.

MoMA introduction: "Who was Félix Fénéon? The first exhibition dedicated to this extraordinarily influential but little-known figure explores how he shaped the development of modernism. A French art critic, editor, publisher, dealer, and collector, Fénéon (1861–1944) championed the careers of young, avant-garde artists from Georges-Pierre Seurat and Paul Signac to Pierre Bonnard and Henri Matisse, among many others. He was also a pioneering collector of art from Africa and Oceania. A fervent anarchist during a period of gaping economic and social disparities, Fénéon believed in the potential of avant-garde art to promote a more harmonious, egalitarian world."

"This exhibition is currently being presented here as part of our Virtual Views series, as we “museum from home.” Explore Fénéon’s life and the art that inspired him through highlights from MoMA curator Starr Figura, along with art, audio, and video features below." (MoMA introduction)

AA: Félix Fénéon's life story, as told by Jed Perl, is mind-boggling, but for me this tour is interesting as an excursion in pure colourism in art, and in this, Fénéon had soul-mates in Finland such as Sigurd Frosterus, who also loved Signac and Seurat, among others. Like Fénéon, Frosterus was interested in modernism as a transformation of the world. The interest in pure art was thus not a case of "art for art's sake". It may seem paradoxical that, to quote Perl, "what was essential to the new style was the emphasis on stability and timelessness". Fénéon saw that "for Seurat and his cohort, who were interested in new scientific ideas about color perception, 'objective reality is simply a theme for the creation of a higher, sublimated reality, suffused with their own personality.'" The post-impressionists were after "A time outside of time". But this higher reality was not an end in itself.

Saturday, May 16, 2020

Pravo no pamyat / The Right to Memory


Arseny Roginsky in Ludmila Gordon's Pravo no pamyat / Право но память / The Right to Memory (2018). Arseny Roginsky tells how he was born in the GULAG in 1946. My screenshot from YouTube.

Право но память
    RU © 2018 Ludmila Gordon. D: Ludmila Gordon. Cin: Mika Altskan.
    A documentary film. Monologue: Arseny Roginsky.
    English translation: Alexander Altskan.
    96 min
Premiere: Moscow & Perm, 30 March 2018, International Memorial Society.
Corona lockdown viewings.
A free access film on The Right to Memory website / YouTube.
Viewed on a 4K tv set at home, Helsinki, 16 May 2020.

“It is great happiness, to have memory.
But it is arduous work to keep it preserved.
My cause is the work of memory.”
– Arseny Roginsky

Introduction on the film's website: "The Right to Memory is an intimate portrayal of one of Russia's greatest public intellectuals, influential historian and human rights advocate, Arseny Roginsky (1946–2017)."

"In an eloquent and captivating monologue, Roginsky, a co-founder and long-term leader of the Memorial Society, former dissident and political prisoner, reflects on his life and his country’s past, present, and future."

"Оne year before his death, Roginsky revealed, for the first time on film, his innermost thoughts about his birth in the Gulag, the mechanism of mass terror, the historian's duty, and why his countrymen reject the memory of the totalitarian past." (Introduction on The Right to Memory website)

AA: Having read Benjamin Nathans's essay "Profiles in Decency" in The New York Review of Books (23 April 2020 issue) I decided to see Ludmila Gordon's film, the first of the two movies discussed in the piece. The other one, Meeting Gorbachev by Werner Herzog and André Singer, I hope to see, as well.

The Gulag theme is still seriously underrepresented in world cinema compared, for instance, with Holocaust cinema. Ludmila Gordon's movie is a distinguished contribution. It is quite simply the oral history of Arseny Roginsky, author, historian and co-founder and head of Memorial.

Just before his death he agreed to tell his life story on film. It is a devastating story of terror and persecution that has continued over generations, although there have been periods of hope such as the great rehabilitations during the Khrushchev Thaw and most remarkably during the Glasnost of Gorbachev.

It is a sober and lucid story with three great lessons that Roginsky wants to share: 1) don't get killed, 2) maintain self-respect and dignity, and 3) continue work. These kinds of lessons sound familiar from life stories of Nelson Mandela and other heroes of civil courage and disobedience. I have recently been reading Tolstoy and about Tolstoyanism, also relevant here. Roginsky mentions having written a study about the massacre of pacifist Tolstoyans in the context of the 1940s.

The film is divided into five chapters: 1) Place of Birth: SevDvinLag (The Northern Dvina Labor Camp), 2) Forbidden Memory, 3) They Will Be Free, IV Memorial, and V State and Individual. The focus is on the last chapter. The persecution was not about bad people terrorizing innocent people. It was about state terror, and that is the hardest part for Russian citizens to accept.

Because Roginsky did not belong to Komsomol and because he was Jewish, he was not allowed to study in the universities in Russia, but he managed to get into Tartu university where he studied under Yuri Lotman. Soon Roginsky became a dissident intellectual, active in publishing a samizdat journal called Pamyat (Memory) and inevitably landing into the Gulag himself.

The future looked bleak, but the hunger-strike death of the Gulag prisoner Anatoly Marchenko in 1986 changed everything. Practically all political prisoners were set free by Gorbachev. Marchenko's "death was a powerful catalyst". Roginsky gives a resume of the achievements of Memorial. Its significance is huge, since "half of the people of the country do not know where their great-grandfathers are buried". Mass killings leave little traces, and finding out about them is a fight against time.

There are thousands of stories to be told about Gulag, also regarding Finns. Gordon and Roginsky's movie provides a model of how such a story can be told soberly and unflinchingly.

Klaus Wyborny: Hommage an Ludwig van Beethoven (2006)







Hommage an Ludwig van Beethoven (op. 111 und Missa Solemnis).
    DE 2006 Typee Records. © 1972 / 1986 / 2006 Klaus Wyborny. P+D+SC+Cin+ED: Klaus Wyborny.
    M: Ludwig van Beethoven:
    Opus 111: Klaviersonate Nr. 32 in c-Moll (1822), arr. + perf. Klaus Wyborny
    Opus 123: Missa solemnis in D-Dur (1822) – Gloria, Sanctus, Agnus Dei – Arturo Toscanini cond. – NBC Symphony Orchestra – Carnegie Hall, New York, 28 Dec 1940. (Mit z.T. Klaviereinsprengseln von Klaus Wyborny)
    73 min
    Corona lockdown viewings / Beethoven 250.
    Münchner Filmmuseum: Klaus Wyborny retrospective.
    A Vimeo link viewed on a 4K tv set at home, Helsinki, 16 May 2020.

From Klaus Wyborny's homepage:

Versuch der Visualisierung zweier Beethovenscher Spätwerke, in fünf Teilen:

    1. op. 111 – 1
    2. op. 111 – 2
    3. Gloria (aus der Missa Solemnis)
mit Bildern (in der Reihenfolge ihres ersten Erscheinens) vom Lake Baringo, aus Nakuru, Tambach, Ndarawga, Sagana, Kabarnet, Karatina, Kiganjo, Nyahururu, Kapsabet, Chebloch, vom Mount Kenya, aus Mugondoi, Biretwo, Marigat, Naru Moru, Rumuruti, Nyeri, Nandi Hills, Loruk, Subukia und dem Subukia Valley. Das christliche Sentiment fällt über die Hütten Afrikas her und zieht es in seinen Zusammenhang, bis sich in der großen Fuge des Gloria seine andere Natur offenbart: die Musik wirkt auf einmal wie ein riesiges Rad, das Afrika überrollt, das dortige Leben zerquetscht und zum Teil eines gewaltigen Musters macht, gegen das es keine Gegenwehr gibt.

    4. Sanctus (aus der Missa Solemnis)
mit Bildern aus (in der Reihenfolge ihres ersten Erscheinens) Rothwell, von den Liverpool Docks, aus Ravensthorpe, Sheffield, Runcorn, Huddersfield, Bradford, Ashton upon Lyne, Stockport, Manchester, Leeds, Glossop und Keighley. Die Orte, von denen einst die Beherrschung der Welt ausging, werden ein letztes mal heilig gesprochen, doch das stolz vibrierende Sentiment des Benedictus trifft nur auf verfallene Fabrikhallen an zugeschütteten Häfen, auf eine geprügelte Erde, die zum Opfer ihres Ehrgeizes geworden ist.

    5. Agnus Dei (aus der Missa Solemnis)
mit Bildern aus (in der Reihenfolge ihres ersten Erscheinens) Oltepesi, Tigoni, Olepotos, Limuru, Eldoret, vom Lake Magadi, aus Naivasha, Kaptagat, Muguga, Plateau, Chepkorio, Magadi, Equator, vom Lake Elementeita, aus Gilgil und vom Hell's Gate. Neben den Hütten der Einwohner sind nun auch vermehrt Resultate der Europäisierung Afrikas zu sehen: Straßen, ländliche Urbanität und Spuren einer Industrialisierung, die rührend halbherzig und zugleich brutal ist. Empört versucht eine Klaviermusik gegen das Mitgefühl der Beethovenschen Musik anzugehen, bis auch diese in einer Kakophonie ihrer Bestürzung über den Zustand der Welt Ausdruck verleiht.

Stimmen:

"Klaus Wyborny, ein Stammgast des Festivals, lehrt uns in seiner "Hommage an Ludwig van Beethoven", wie man Töne sehen kann und welches Abenteuer die Suche nach Zusammenhängen darstellt – ein enormes, radikales Musikvideo gegen alle Musikvideos, voller Assoziationen über mehr als 200 Jahre Kulturgeschichte, die von Europa nach Afrika reicht. "
– Hans Schifferle, Süddeutsche Zeitung vom 25. Okt. 2006 anläßlich der Premiere auf der Viennale in Wien

"Der Film beginnt mit einer Visualisierung von Beethovens Sonate Nr. 32 c-moll op 111, und um ein Haar wäre Wyborny fast am ersten Satz gescheitert. Ja, fast hätte ihn das "wilde, kahle Feuer" (Kaiser) dieser letzten Beethovenschen Sturmmusik in Stücke gerissen. Wer sich nämlich hier, wenn das aggressive Allegro explodiert (nachdem die Sonate zunächst so gespreizt mit einer ausdrücklich "falschen" Adresse im altertümelnd französichen Ouvertürenrhythmus begonnen hatte), auf jeden Bruch und alle Extreme einlässt; wer diese dialektischen Spanungspole unbedingt in feinsten agogischen Abstufungen herausarbeiten, die Tempokontraste kantig modellieren will, den zerreißt es. Wyborny zog sich, Beethoven hätte das bekanntlich ebenso gemacht im Ernstfall, improvisatorisch an den eigenen Haaren aus dem Abgrund. Im Publikum haben wohl viele von dem Drama nichts bemerkt. Andere merkten es, erschraken, fassten sich, atmeten auf – und waren dann überwältigt von der genialen Lösung."

"Im zweiten Satz, dem langsamen, muss sich das Wunder der Arietta ereignen. Er ist noch schwerer zu spielen als der erste. Wie ein Kinderlied floss diese einfache Gesangesrede aus Wybornys Fingern und floss durch seine Bilder hindurch. Sehr hell, sehr leicht. Nicht zu langsam, nicht zu schnell, keine Geheimnistuerei, kein Geraune. Einfach nur so ein Lied. Landet im Zeitraffer und verdichtet sich von Variation zu Variation, ohne dabei den Kinderblick zu verlieren oder aufzuschrecken aus dieser altersweisen Schildkrötenruhe."

"Es ist ja schon viel geschrieben worden über diese Melodie und ihre überirdischen Verirrungen, ihren Swing, ihr Tinnitusglockenklingeln, ihren Stillstand und ihr Nicht-Enden.Wollen, von Thomas Mann, von Igor Strawinsky und Milan Kundera, und das alles unbedingt treffend, wahr und so weiter. Und müssen doch alles wieder vergessen in dem Moment, wenn die Musik neu an uns vorübergeht. Zwanzig Minuten, ungefähr, dann hört das hell und leicht wieder auf, der Pianist klatschnass, wir alle in Tränen.
"
– E. B. im Standard

Aufsatz von Dietrich Kuhlbrodt (aus "Schnitt", Dez 2006).

AA: Klaus Wyborny dives deep into the late music of Beethoven. During his last years the composer was not well, he suffered from a loss of hearing, and yet he composed some of his greatest music, including also the late string quartets and the choral symphony.

Wyborny's exploration is music-driven. The director plays the keyboards himself and lets us listen to a classic 1940 recording of Arturo Toscanini conducting the Missa solemnis with Zinka Milanov, soprano, Bruna Castagna, alto, Jussi Björling, tenor and Alexander Kipnis, bass.

This film belongs to the radical experimental current of visual music. The images have no obvious connection with the music, but the rhythm and the tempo are based on Beethoven, which reminds us that the sense of rhythm and tempo was always engaging and engrossing in Beethoven. Wyborny even observes Beethoven's characteristic "dotted rhythms".

Thus, Wyborny not only plays the keyboards, he plays the editing table with blitz montages, visual barrages, tintings, psychedelic colour mutations and superimpositions. Sometimes the blinking is on the verge of accelerating beyond perception.

This brings us back to the genesis of flash montage in films by Griffith, Gance and Eisenstein, and of course of these three it was Abel Gance who was particularly obsessed with Beethoven, and not only in his films The Tenth Symphony and Beethoven's Great Love.

The green hills of Africa seem far away from Beethoven's age of revolution and counter-revolution. The African imagery is an extreme distancing effect, as is the distortion of the music on the soundtrack. Like in Mauricio Kagel's Ludwig van, the distortion helps us identify with Beethoven's struggle to hear, and the victory of the spirit he finally achieved.

The Goat (Buster Keaton, 1921)


Buster Keaton and Virginia Fox on the poster for The Goat (1921). Photo: Internet Movie Database.

Syntipukki / Syndabocken / Pulmallisessa asemassa / Malec l'insaisissable.
    US 1921. PC: Joseph M. Schenck Productions / Buster Keaton Productions. Original distributor: Metro Pictures Corporation. P: Joseph M. Schenck. D+SC: Buster Keaton, Malcolm St. Clair. Cin: Elgin Lessley – 35 mm – b&w – 1,37:1 – silent with English intertitles. Technical D: Fred Gabourie.
    C: Buster Keaton (The Goat), Virginia Fox (the police chief's daughter), Joe Roberts (Police Chief), Malcolm St. Clair (Dead Shot Dan), Edward F. Cline (cop by telephone pole), Jean C. Havez, Kitty Bradbury, Joe Keaton, Louise Keaton, Myra Keaton.
    Loc: Los Angeles (914 S. Alvarado Street, Inglewood Train Station).
    23 min
    US premiere: 18 May 1921 – distributor: Metro Pictures.
    Helsinki premiere: 10 May 1923 Apollo – released by Adams Filmi Oy.
    Robert Israel composed the score for the 1995 re-release.
    Lobster Films restoration (2015) with a Mont Alto Orchestra music compilation.
    Corona lockdown viewings.
    Lobster Films 2015 restoration viewed at home, Helsinki, 16 May 2020.

AA: The Goat was Buster Keaton's eighth independent production. During his first nine months in independent productions, starting in September 1920, he released eight short films, all great.

Virginia Fox was Keaton's leading lady in ten short comedies. After them, in 1924, she married the producer Darryl F. Zanuck who would become the Vice President of Production for Twentieth Century-Fox when it was founded in 1935 in a merger of Fox Film Corporation and Twentieth Century Pictures. She became the mother of Richard D. Zanuck and two other children.

I was intrigued to see The Goat at last, having read Imogen Sara Smith's wonderful book Buster Keaton: The Persistence of Comedy (2013). The Goat was for her the film that opened her eyes to the genius of Keaton. As for me, I possibly saw The Goat for the first time today. I became a convert to Keaton when Raymond Rohauer visited Finland in November 1971 with his big touring Keaton retrospective. I saw many of his prints on the screen, and the rest of his package on television in the next years. But we have never mounted nor have I have ever seen a complete retrospective of Keaton's shorts, not even in home viewing. With the corona lockdown I may have no excuse...

The surprise of The Goat (the title means: "Scapegoat") is in its freedom from logic and plausibility. It is an adventure in the absurd, in the realm of dreams, with an acute sense of the nightmare. It is a surrealist film made before the Surrealist Manifesto (which was published in 1924). It may be one of the films that actually inspired surrealists (who were very big film buffs).

Some shots are justly famous: Keaton's close-up behind the window bars of the photographer's studio (causing a mix-up with the convicted murderer Dead Shot Dan). His head growing rapidly from a long shot into a close-up on the cowcatcher of an approaching steam engine (prefiguring The General, 1926). Hilarious gags include his trying to hide on top of a clay model of a horse statue (with his signature "sentinel gesture" of holding a hand over the eyes).

The Goat is very much a chase film. The policemen chasing Buster have already a similar nightmarish presence as in Cops (1922). The final chase in the police chief's house takes place in the staircase and the elevator shaft, with a fantastic final gag in which Buster manipulates the elevator's control switch.

Some of the acrobatics of the chases border on the incredible like Buster's panther leap over the dinner table and through a narrow window over the door to escape the police chief who is also the father of his sweetheart.

There is a Kafkaesque dimension. Thanks to the wanted poster, everybody recognizes Buster and knows only one thing: he is guilty. During the chase Keaton, too, starts to think that he might be guilty: he might have accidentally killed the man who scolded Virginia rudely when she was walking her dog and the man stumbled upon the leash.

Although the plot defies logic and credibility, each set and action has been designed with mathematical perfection.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: SYNOPSIS FROM WIKIPEDIA:

Beethoven 250: Piano Sonata No. 5 (Stephen Kovacevich, 1998)


Julius Schmid (1854–1935): Beethoven plays the piano.

Beethoven: The Complete Works (80 CD). Warner Classics / © 2019 Parlophone Records Limited. Also available on Spotify etc. I bought my box set from Fuga at Helsinki Music Centre.
    Ludwig van Beethoven 1770–1827.
    Beethoven 250 / corona lockdown listening.

From: CD 18/80  Piano Sonatas Nos. 4–7
Der Gräfin Anna Margarete von Browne gewidmet.
Stephen Kovacevich, 1998.

Opus 10 Nr. 1: Klaviersonate Nr. 5 in c-Moll (1798)
Erster Satz: Allegro molto e con brio, c-Moll, 3/4 Takt, 284 Takte
Zweiter Satz: Adagio molto, As-Dur, 2/4 Takt, 112 Takte
Dritter Satz: Finale. Prestissimo, c-Moll, alla breve, 122 Takte

AA: My progress in listening to Beethoven's piano sonatas keeps getting slower, not because I'm listening less, but because I'm listening more and focusing increasingly on a single sonata for several days.

A particularly revelatory source has been the lecture cycle of András Schiff on the sonatas. Schiff performed the complete Beethoven piano sonatas at Wigmore Hall in 2004–2006, quoting the Wigmore Hall website:

"to overwhelming critical acclaim, with the editor of the Guardian, Alan Rusbridger, describing one particular performance as ‘a riveting mixture of erudition, analysis, passion, wit and memory’."

"On the day before each of the eight recitals in the series, the world-renowned pianist, pedagogue and lecturer gave a lecture-recital in which he explored the works to be performed. Deeply engaging and insightful, these thought-provoking lecture-recitals, recorded live at the Hall, are available below as eight audio lecture-recitals.
" (Wigmore Hall homepage).

As somebody who is not a music connoisseur I recommend these lectures to everybody because of their artistic and cultural value. For instance, the lecture about the fifth piano sonata takes over 50 minutes, while the sonata itself is only 16 minutes long in Kovacevich's recording.

Schiff demonstrates Beethoven's here by now great difference to Mozart and Haydn and describes some general characteristics of him: the generosity, the warmth and the fullness of his approach, his way of writing "for the fist", his very strong sense of rhythm and tempo and yet the capacity of flexibility in performance while always obeying a sense of order. According to Schiff Beethoven was the first composer who was quite meticulous in his notations.

Schiff has a penchant for the humoristic aside. Commenting on the dedications on the piano sonatas he observes that the dedicatees were usually music lovers. "Let's not forget that the amateur, amatore, means somebody who actually loves music – and that is not always the case with professionals".

In the third movement there is an anticipation of the Fifth Symphony and its Schicksals-motive. Also an anticipation of the Tempest sonata is mentioned by Schiff. In the beautiful Adagio I felt an affinity with the Romanze Op. 50, also from 1798.

Besides the Stephen Kovacevich and András Schiff interpretations I listened to several others, admiring the lyrical and tender touches of Claudio Arrau and the profound concentration of Emil Gilels whose slow movement is much slower than Kovacevich's, conveying a sense of endlessness. Schiff in his lecture talks about Beethoven's fondness for a singing quality in slow movements, notes that cannot be long enough. Gilels certainly achieves such a quality.

Wednesday, May 13, 2020

Capital in the Twenty-First Century (the movie)



FR/NZ © 2019 GFC (Capital) Limited & Upside SAS. PC: General Film Corporation / Upside Production. P: Yann Le Prado, Matthew Metcalfe.
    A documentary film.
    D: Justin Pemberton. SC: Matthew Metcalfe, Justin Pemberton, Thomas Piketty – from the book Le Capital au XXIe siècle (2013) by Thomas Piketty. Cin: Jacob Bryant, Darryl Ward – colour – release: digital. M: Jean-Benoît Dunckel. S: Steve Finnigan. ED: Sandie Bompar.
    Featuring: Ian Bremmer, Lucas Chancel, Bryce Edwards, Rana Foroohar, Francis Fukuyama, Simon Johnson, Paul Mason, Suresh Naidu, Paul Piff, Thomas Piketty, Faisa Shaheen, Joseph Stiglitz, Gillian Tett, Kate Williams, Gabriel Zucman.
    In English and French with English subtitles.
    103 min
    Festival premiere: 13 June 2019 Sydney Film Festival.
    Corona lockdown viewings.
    Vimeo link viewed on a 4K tv set at home in Helsinki, 13 May 2020.

Studiocanal synopsis: "Adapting one of the most groundbreaking and powerful books of our time, Capital in the 21st Century is an eye-opening journey through wealth and power, that breaks the popular assumption that the accumulation of capital runs hand in hand with social progress, shining a new light on the world around us and its growing inequalities. Traveling through time from the French Revolution and other huge global shifts, to world wars and through to the rise of new technologies today, the film assembles accessible pop-culture references coupled with interviews of some of the world's most influential experts delivering an insightful and empowering journey through the past and into our future." —Studiocanal

Kino Marquee synopsis: "Based on the international bestseller by rock-star economist Thomas Piketty (which sold over three million copies worldwide and landed Piketty on Time's list of most influential people), this captivating documentary is an eye-opening journey through wealth and power, a film that breaks the popular assumption that the accumulation of capital runs hand in hand with social progress, and shines a new light on today’s growing inequalities. Traveling through time, the film assembles accessible pop-culture references coupled with interviews of some of the world’s most influential experts delivering an insightful and empowering journey through the past and into our future."

AA: Justin Pemberton has created a high profile documentary film based on Thomas Piketty's book Le Capital au XXIe siècle, a modern classic of political economy. There is a sterling roster of commentators, and the historical scope is wide, starting from the 18th century and continuing to our days. Even for those who have read Piketty's books (also his newer one, Capital et idéologie, 2019), a dramatized summary can be welcome.

Unfortunately, Pemberton does not succeed in finding a form for his film. He offers a little bit of everything from statements by talking heads (they are the strongest asset), newsreel footage from the 125 years of film history, and a lot of clips from fictional films. There are illuminating animations and relevant pop music clips, too.

It does not work, but this film is exciting as a showcase of the possibilities of this kind of film project. I would look forward to a television series based on these premises.

Visually and aesthetically I had a feeling of an "uncanny valley" at times, a Photoshopped quality in the talking heads. Colorization of historical documents does not make them look more convincing to me. On the contrary, I am turning increasingly critical to the cavalier attitude to historical documents even in the most revered achievements of compilation film. I would welcome annotation and source criticism / information evaluation in serious documentary films. That would not turn them more boring.

We are living in a time of change, and Piketty's books have been welcomed as key statements across political demarcation lines.

Piketty is critical of capitalism, but there is also a sense in which he is defending capitalism – from itself. Like in the 1870s and the 1930s, a radical change is imminent because otherwise capitalism will self-destruct.

Read the books – they are more engrossing and even entertaining than this film that is striving too hard to please.

Women Make Film 11: Tension, Stasis, Leave Out


Women Make Film: Chapter 29: Tension: Selma / Ava DuVernay, GB/US 2014. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website. A classic scene about passive resistance.

Women Make Film: Chapter 30: Stasis: Les Rendez-vous d'Anna / The Meetings of Anna / Chantal Akerman, FR/BE/DE 1978. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website.

Women Make Film: Chapter 31: Leave Out: Wadjda / وجدة / Haifaa Al-Mansour, SA/NL/DE/JO/AE/US 2012. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website.

Women Make Film. A New Road Movie Through Cinema
Women Make Film. Uusi matka elokuvaan
    GB © 2019 How To Make A Movie Ltd. PC: Hopscotch Films. P: John Archer. EX: Clara Glynn, Tilda Swinton. Assistant P: Sonali Choudhury. Associate P: Carl Beauchamp, Catherine Glynn Benkaim, Barbara Timmer.
    D+SC: Mark Cousins. Sound mixing: Diane Jardine. S: Joe Harfield. ED+script consultant: Timo Langer. Online: Chas Chalmers. Edit assistant: Scott Bilsbrough. P coordinator: Mhairi Valentine. P team: David Brown, Rowan Ings, Raja Kryda. World Sales: Dogwoof. Head of sales: Ana Vicente. Legal: David Burgess.
    https://www.womenmakefilm.com/
    14 hours – HD – 16:9
    Festival premiere: 1 Sep 2018 Venice Film Festival
    Finnish telepremieres of the 14 episodes: 3.3.2020, 10.3.2020, 17.3.2020, 24.3.2020, 1.4.2020, 8.4.2020, 15.4.2020, 22.4.2020, 29.4.2020, 6.5.2020, 13.5.2020, 20.5.2020, 27.5.2020, 3.6.2020
    Corona lockdown viewings / Women Make Film.
    Yle Areena: viewed on a 4K tv set at home in Helsinki, 13 May 2020.

Episode 11/14: Tension, Stasis, Leave Out
Jakso 11/14: Jännitystä ja pysähtyneitä hetkiä
Narrator: Thandie Newton
Finnish / Swedish subtitles: Tiina Kähkönen / Sari Östman

Chapter 29. Tension / Jännitystä ilmassa

Demon Lover Diary / Joel DeMott, dok, US 1980 [unreleased in Finland]
Dreams of a Life / Carol Morley, dok, GB/IE 2011 [unreleased in Finland]
Archipelago / Joanna Hogg, GB 2010 [unreleased in Finland]
Blue Steel / Kylmää terästä / Kathryn Bigelow, US 1990
Hotell / Hotel / Lisa Langseth, SE/DK 2013 [unreleased in Finland]
Évolution / Evolution / Lucile Hadžihalilović, FR/BE/ES 2015 [unreleased in Finland]
Ung flukt / The Wayward Girl / Nuoret syntiset / Edith Carlmar, NO 1959
The Peacemaker / Rauhantekijä / Mimi Leder, US 1997
De Stilte Rond Christine M. / A Question of Silence / Marleen Gorris, NL 1982 [unreleased in Finland]
Selma / Selma / Ava DuVernay, GB/US 2014
Astenicheski sindrom / Астенический синдром / The Asthenic Syndrome / Asteeninen oire / Kira Muratova, SU 1990

Chapter 30. Stasis / Levollisuus / Stillhet

Plätze in Städten / Places in Cities / Angela Schanelec, DE 1998 [unreleased in Finland]
Brownian Movement / Nanouk Leopold, NL 2010 [unreleased in Finland]
Astenicheski sindrom / Астенический синдром / The Asthenic Syndrome / Asteeninen oire / Kira Muratova, SU 1990
Colour Poems: Terra Firma / Margaret Tait, exp., c.m. GB 1974
Kid / Fien Troch, BE/NL/DE 2012 [unreleased in Finland]
De Stilte Rond Christine M. / A Question of Silence / Marleen Gorris, NL 1982 [unreleased in Finland]
Les Rendez-vous d'Anna / The Meetings of Anna / Chantal Akerman, FR/BE/DE 1978 [unreleased in Finland]
Double Tide / Sharon Lockhart, dok, US/AT 2009
Hamaca paraguaya / Paraguayan Hammock / Paz Encina, AR/NL/Paraguay/AT/FR/DE 2006 [unreleased in Finland]
Khamosh pani / خاموش پانی / ਖਮੋਸ਼ ਪਾਨੀ / Silent Waters / Hiljaiset vedet / Sabiha Sumar, PK/FR/DE 2003
Marlina si Pembunuh dalam Empat Babak / Marlina the Murderer in Four Acts / Mouly Surya, ID/FR/MY/TH 2017 [unreleased in Finland]

Chapter 31. Leave Out / Pois jättäminen

Chekhovskie motivy / Чеховские мотивы / Chekhov's Motifs / Tshehovilaistunnelmissa / Kira Muratova, UA/RU 2002
Je tu il elle / Chantal Akerman, FR/BG 1974 [unreleased in Finland]
Baby ryazanskie / Бабы рязанские / Women of Ryazan / Rjazanin naiset / Olga Preobrazhenskaya, SU 1927
Wadjda / وجدة / Vihreä polkupyörä / Haifaa Al-Mansour, SA/NL/DE/JO/AE/US 2012
Khake sar beh mohr / خاک مهر شده / The Sealed Soil / Marva Nabili, IR 1977 [unreleased in Finland]
The Day I'll Never Forget / Kim Longinotto, dok, GB 2002 [unreleased in Finland]
Baxter, Vera Baxter / Marguerite Duras, FR 1977 [unreleased in Finland]
Proof / Sokeat todisteet / Jocelyn Moorhouse, AU 1991
Povest plamennykh let / Повесть пламенных лет / The Story of the Flaming Years / Liekehtivän taivaan alla / Yuliya Solntseva, SU 1961

AA: In Episodes 9 and 10 of Women Make Film, Mark Cousins started to discuss genre, but having presented comedy, melodrama, science fiction and horror he abruptly stops. Most genres are left out: war, musical / rock / pop, biopic, epic, Western, gangster / crime / thriller / film noir, adventure... including one of the most interesting in this context: romance. Of animation, experimental, and documentary film there seem to be no chapters, either.

In a way, Chapter 29: Tension is still relevant to genre, as discussed in the previous chapter. Joel DeMott's Demon Lover Diary (1980) is one of the earliest examples of the "found footage" horror trend best known from Blair Witch Project made 19 years later.

I need to see Marleen Gorris's De Stilte Rond Christine M. / A Question of Silence, also relevant to horror, and also to Auli Mantila's The Collector, as an account of a raging rampage of a female protagonist.

This episode contains some of the most disturbing samples of the series. Here we have one of the silent cinema's most powerful rape sequences, in Women of Ryazan: the lesson, like in Fritz Lang's M, made three years later: the less shown, the more disturbing it gets. In Kim Longinotto's The Day I'll Never Forget the topic is female genital mutilation. Again, nothing is shown, and our imagination fills in the blanks.

The series is increasingly erratic, the argument hard to follow. In Chapter 29: Tension I would have expected Lois Weber and Phillip Smalley's Suspense (1913), an early masterpiece of the genre. But it's better to learn to stop worrying and love the samples we get. Some of them would have been at home in Chapter 19: Sex such as the clips from Angela Schanelec's Plätze in Städten, Nanouk Leopold's Brownian Movement and Chantal Akerman's Je tu il elle.

I have been recently studying Leo Tolstoy and the cinema. A great relevant sequence, worthy of the cavalry sequence in Gandhi, is in Ava DuVernay's Selma, a film about Martin Luther King's civil rights movement based on passive resistance. Black Selma voters sit down on the lawn in front of the courthouse where they have arrived to register, ignoring police orders to disperse.

Friday, May 08, 2020

Café Society (2016)



Kristen Stewart is at her most appealing in Woody Allen's Café Society (2016). Photo: Sabrina Lantos.

Woody Allen: Café Society (2016). Woody Allen, Kristen Stewart and Jesse Eisenberg promoting the movie.

Café Society / Café Society.
    US © 2016 Gravier Productions, Inc. An Amazon Studios release of a Gravier Productions presentation of a Perdido production. P: Letty Aronson, Stephen Tenenbaum, Edward Walson.
    D+SC: Woody Allen. Cin: Vittorio Storaro – digital: AXSWM, SRMemory – Sony Cinealta F65 – colour: ACES – 2.00:1 – digital intermediate 4K – release: D-Cinema. PD: Santo Loquasto. AD: Michael E. Goldman, Doug Huszti. Set dec: Regina Graves, Nancy Haigh. Cost: Suzy Benzinger. Makeup: Stacey Panepinto. Hair: Christine Fennell. SFX: Phillip Beck. VFX: Brainstorm Digital. Soundtrack listing beyond the jump break.* S: Robert Hein. ED: Alisa Lepselter. Casting: Patricia DiCerto, Juliet Taylor.
    C from Wikipedia:
    Jesse Eisenberg as Bobby Dorfman
    Kristen Stewart as Veronica "Vonnie" Sybil
    Steve Carell as Phil Stern
    Blake Lively as Veronica Hayes
    Parker Posey as Rad Taylor
    Corey Stoll as Ben Dorfman
    Jeannie Berlin as Rose Dorfman
    Ken Stott as Marty Dorfman
    Anna Camp as Candy
    Paul Schneider as Steve
    Sheryl Lee as Karen Stern
    Tony Sirico as Vito
    Stephen Kunken as Leonard
    Sari Lennick as Evelyn Dorfman
    Laurel Griggs as Evelyn Dorfman's daughter
    Max Adler as Walt
    Don Stark as Sol
    Gregg Binkley as Mike
    Woody Allen (uncredited) as Narrator (voice)
Films that Bobby and Vonnie see: The Woman in Red (1935) and Libeled Lady (1936).
Loc: Los Angeles, Pasadena, New York City.
Typeface: Windsor Light Condensed.
96 min
    Festival premiere: 11 May 2016 Cannes Film Festival.
    Premiere: 13 July 2016 New York City.
    Finnish premiere: 7 Oct 2016, distributed by Finnkino.
    Corona lockdown viewings.
    Yle Teema broadcast with Finnish subtitles by Jaana Wiik viewed on a 4K tv set at home, Helsinki, 8 May 2020.

AA: Whoever designed the poster of Café Society deserves credit, but poster designers are usually not credited anymore. The stylized image of a woman with a golden tear sums up a key theme of the movie.

Much of the film is reassuringly familiar: the 1930s oldie jazz favourites, the Windsor Light Condensed typeface, familiar names in the opening credits (missing here: Jack Rollins, who had just died at age 100).

Much is new: this is Woody Allen's first digitally captured film (but since Midnight in Paris his films had been processed via digital intermediate) and his first film shot by the Italian maestro Vittorio Storaro. Café Society is also Allen's most expensive film by far, and it shows.

No director in the history of the cinema has had more fantastic casts than Woody Allen, and here Kristen Stewart (Veronica "Vonnie"), Blake Lively (Veronica Hayes), Jeannie Berlin (Rose Dorfman), Anna Camp (Candy) and Sheryl Lee (Karen Stern) make their Woody Allen debuts. This is a film about warm and tender love, and Stewart and Lively are glowing and radiant as the two Veronicas of this romance. This is the most beautiful performance of Kristen Stewart I have seen, and it changes my view about her.

Jesse Eisenberg is in the male leading role as Bobby, creating an original incarnation of the Allenian schlemiel protagonist. Steve Carell's Uncle Phil starts as a stock character: a married man, a big boss with a young "back street" girlfriend. But during the movie Phil grows in complexity, humanity and dignity, and he finally keeps his promise to his girlfriend. Like all great comedy since Molière, Allen starts from cliché and then twists it around.

The themes are familiar. All great themes are familiar. The treatment is fresh and new. In Midnight in Paris the theme of "everything was better in the past" was explored with a time travel fantasy device. Here the theme is "the grass is greener".

Café Society is light entertainment on the surface and philosophical at the core. Towards the finale we hear Leonard sum up: "Socrates said, 'The unexamined life is not worth living.' But the examined one is no bargain". Because "life has its own agenda".

In the first part of the movie Vonnie gives Bobby the classical Hollywood tour complete with a sight-seeing of the stars' homes. The stars are bigger than life, but Vonnie confesses that she is happy to be life-size.

Comedy is the most merciless genre: either you laugh or you don't. We laughed out loud many times, but I look forward to revisiting Café Society after the corona lockdown to hear a cinema audience reacting to its anthology pieces. Among them is one of the most memorable scenes of prostitution in the history of the cinema. The lonely Bobby has booked an appointment with Candy (Anna Camp), but even commercial love remains unrequited in this poignant and human scene.

More devastatingly, Bobby's romance with Vonnie ends with her choosing another man. Together in Hollywood Bobby and Vonnie had satirized industry talk, small talk, "name-dropping and backstabbing". When years later Bobby meets Vonnie, "the former girlfriend is now an aunt", and she has also become a master of "name-dropping and backstabbing". In Allen's comédie humaine Vonnie now belongs with Monica (Ellen Page) who "knows one line from every poem" in To Rome with Love.

Café Society belongs to Allen's films with a strong Jewish presence, featuring a Hollywood uncle and a New York gangster, Bobby's big brother Ben Dorfman (Corey Stoll, who played Hemingway in Midnight in Paris). The last straw for the Dorfman family is that on death row Ben converts to Christianity: "First a murderer, and now a Christian!".

New Year is being celebrated both in New York and Hollywood. Bobby and Vonnie never stop loving each other, but they have decided that it is better not to see each other any more. As everybody else joins in "Auld Lang Syne", a faraway look is noticed in Bobby's eyes in New York and Vonnie's in Hollywood. There is no "The End" card.

I think that Bobby and Vonnie have stopped looking for the greener grass in romance, and the faraway look has a deeper meaning. When they were together, they were dreaming of a better life than Hollywood backstabbing and New York café society. They still are.

The cinematography by Vittorio Storaro and the production design by Santo Loquasto got rave reviews, and the look of the movie is impressively glossy even viewed at home. I also sensed a digital unreality, like in the Coen Brothers' Hail, Caesar! (2016) made in the same year. Maybe it is an intentional aesthetic choice in both cases.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: SYNOPSIS FROM WIKIPEDIA:

Beethoven 250: Piano Sonata No. 4, "Grande Sonate" (Stephen Kovacevich, 1999)


Engraving of a painting by Albert Graefle (1807-1899): Die Intimen bei Beethoven. With Anton Schindler, Sigmund Anton Steiner, Abbé Stadler and Gottfried von Swieten. From: Pinterest from: sjsu.edu.

Beethoven: The Complete Works (80 CD). Warner Classics / © 2019 Parlophone Records Limited. Also available on Spotify etc. I bought my box set from Fuga at Helsinki Music Centre.
    Ludwig van Beethoven 1770–1827.
    Beethoven 250 / corona lockdown listening.

From: CD 18/80  Piano Sonatas Nos. 4–7
Opus 7: Klaviersonate Nr. 4 in Es-Dur (1797)
"Grande Sonate"
"Die Verliebte"
Widmung: Babette Gräfin von Keglevich de Buzin
The first piano sonata to which Beethoven gave an opus number of its own.
    Stephen Kovacevich, piano, 1999

AA: I'm slowing down in my Beethoven project. From the piano sonatas I knew already mainly the usual ones, and I have kept re-listening to the first four, with which I need to get properly acquainted in the first place. They are no apprenticeship works of the 25–27-year old but already personal masterpieces in the classical idiom. The fourth piano sonata is even more original than the first three. Having found the András Schiff lectures I have listened to them and rotated different interpretations of the fourth piano sonata, including, besides Schiff and Kovacevich, also Schnabel, Kempff, Arrau, and a particular favourite, Maurizio Pollini (thank you for the tip, Esa Salovaara!). Somehow Pollini sustains a most consistent vigorous flow during the entire 26 minutes. They all have something original to say. Claudio Arrau conveys the beauty of the third movement most tenderly and subtly, without missing anything from the sinewy argument. I agree with Arrau that that movement is a confession of love and that the appellation "Die Verliebte" is deserved.

The nobility is emphasized in Sviatoslav Richter's interpretation.

Listening to the symphonies, the piano concertos and the violin concerto that open this edition of Beethoven's complete works I was thinking about Goethe, Wilhelm Meister and the Bildungsroman.

With the piano sonatas I am reminded that Beethoven was the contemporary of the golden age of German philosophy. All the four greats – Kant, Fichte, Schelling and Hegel – published their keyworks during Beethoven's lifetime. Hegel (1770–1831), for instance, was almost an exact contemporary. Terms such as absolute idealism, the phenomenology of the spirit, Weltseele and the world-historical individual ring a bell with Beethoven. Hegel saw in philosophy, art and religion manifestations of the absolute spirit. More eloquent evidence than Beethoven is hardly possible to imagine.

Thursday, May 07, 2020

Filmfarsi


Sampled in Ehsan Khoshbakht's Filmfarsi (2019): Syamak Yasami: Leyli and Majnoon / لیلی و مجنون  (Iran 1970). The speech bubble: "Manouchehr? Iraj? Tell me who you are!".

The Dancer of the City star Forouzan on the cover of Film va honar [Film & Art] magazine.

Actress pop singer Googoosh and Behrouz Vossoughi behind the scene of The Companion, Masoud Asadollahi, 1975

An Iranian outing, stars Marjan (left) and Nasser Malek Motie.

Fardin and Pouri Banai in a scene from Hell plus Me on the cover of Film and Art magazine.

The most versatile method actor of both filmfarsi and arthouse films, Behrouz Vossoughi now living in exile in the US. Photos and captions: Ehsan Khoshbakht.

فیلمفارسی
    IR/GB © 2019 Distorto. P+D+SC+narrator: Ehsan Khoshbakht. M: Naiel Ibarrola, Lander Macho. S: John Coshen, Rob Szeliga. ED: Niyaz Saghari, Abolfazl Talooni.
    Black and white and colour – 16:9 – HD.
    "In VHS-Scope".
    The clips are in Persian with subtitles in English, the narration is in English.
    84 min
    Festival premiere: 26 July 2019 Cinema Rediscovered (UK).
    Corona lockdown viewings.
    A private Vimeo link viewed on a 4K tv set at home in Helsinki, 7 May 2020.

AA: Ehsan Khoshbakht goes beyond all acclaimed waves of Iranian art cinema to explore a trend of popular Iranian cinema called Filmfarsi that started in 1953 and ended in 1979.

The dates are historical: the year 1953 was that of the coup financed by American and British oil companies to oust the democratically elected leader Mohammad Mosaddegh and replace him with a puppet dictator called Shah Reza Pahlavi who enforced his rule in tandem with the CIA and his secret police called SAVAK with a "history of torture which is beyond belief" (Amnesty International). 1979 was the year of the Islamic revolution.

During the bloody rule of the Shah flowered a trend of lowbrow cinema called Filmfarsi, "several letters below B". Khoshbakht explores this trend which has remained practically unknown in the Western world. Since the 1980s it has been also on the verge of falling into oblivion in Iran itself because all what is available are copies of copies of VHS tapes made in the 1970s and the 1980s of once-popular films. Improbably enough, Khoshbakht's entire film is based on these VHS tapes. There are samples from some one hundred titles.

From premises like this we might expect a series of easy (or uneasy) laughs at clumsy movies, and, indeed, an incredulous mood sets in the beginning of this strange survey. But our perspective keeps subtly changing, and our horizon keeps expanding.

The low budget circumstances, the lack of artistic pretense and the openly sensationalist bias created an ambience in which a return of the repressed could take place.

Because the producers could not afford to build sets, the films were often shot on location. Because there was no written dialogue, the lines were improvised. The Filmfarsi phenomenon turns out to be a case of what Amos Vogel called "subversive cinema". Khoshbakht's movie is an odyssey into the unconscious of the Shah's Iran.

Somehow the low definition of the surviving home video samples becomes expressive of the Quixotic nature of the quest into a lost world of dreams, nightmares and escapism. The visual quality becomes an expression of a fading memory on our "journey into lost time".

Khoshbakht's project has been compared with "opening Pandora's box" and identified as a novel approach in the archaeology of the cinema. His mission has nothing in common with fads of cult movies, B movies or golden turkeys ("so bad that they are good"). Instead, Khoshbakht's project is identical with the Henri Langlois tradition of international cinematheques to present the anti-canon, the film maudit, the aforementioned "subversive" currents.

In Finland a parallel is Peter von Bagh as a film-maker. He revelled in discoveries made outside the "film of quality" not only in his film historical compilations. He also expressed weighty arguments of cultural history with such findings. A turning-point was The Year 1952, covering the same historical moment in Finland that was the incubation period of Filmfarsi.

A rich menu of entertainment was on display in Filmfarsi: dance, song, melodrama and crime, and surprisingly frank sexuality and nudity. The uninhibited side of Iranian life was revealed. Foreign films targeted for rip-offs included West Side Story, Sabrina, I vitelloni, Gilda, Vertigo, James Bond and A bout de souffle. After the Shah had divorced Princess Soraya, she appeared in a Michelangelo Antonioni film. Darius Mehrjui, the director of the award-winning art classic The Cow, directed a James Bond spoof before that. Abbas Kiarostami created art credit title sequences for Filmfarsi. Orson Welles received Iranian funding for F for Fake and The Other Side of the Wind thanks to his collaboration with the Shah in "the 2500th anniversary celebration of the Persian empire". (Footage of which, complete with our President Kekkonen in top hat and tails, appears in Chris Marker's Le Fond de l'air est rouge).

Freeze frames were a recurrent device in tragic moments of Filmfarsi. Khoshbakht includes also key documentary shots of real Iranian tragedy such as the 1953 trial and exile of Mosaddegh. We learn that cinema was one of the first victims of the 1979 revolution. 372 martyrs died in an arson attack of Cinema Rex in Tehran showing Masoud Kimiai's The Deer (Gavaznha). The tragedy of history was superimposed with the tragedy of cinema.

I love Ehsan Khoshbakht's Filmfarsi which can be warmly recommended for programs of Iranian history and film history. It is funny and devastating, irreverent and profound, a masterpiece of the montage film. Three years ago I saw samples of Khoshbakht's Filmfarsi programme in Bologna's Il Cinema Ritrovato. I was not converted, but certainly a film such as Samuel Khachikian's Delhoreh (Anxiety, 1962) is a striking display of lurid pulp energy. I need to see more, for instance from Masoud Kimiai.

Filmfarsi homepage.
Ehsan Khoshbakht interview.

Betoniyö / Concrete Night


From Women Make Film: Chapter 18: Bodies: Betoniyö / Concrete Night / Pirjo Honkasalo, FI/SE/DK 2013. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website. The brothers Simo (Johannes Brotherus) and Ilkka (Jari Virman) are sunbathing at an oil refinery in Laajasalo, Helsinki.

Betongnatt.
    FI / SE / DK 2013. Oy Bufo Ab / Platform Produktion AB / Magic Hour Films ApS. P: Misha Jaari, Mark Lwoff.
    D: Pirjo Honkasalo. SC: Pirjo Honkasalo, Pirkko Saisio – based on the novel (1981) by Pirkko Saisio. Cin: Peter Flinckenberg – digital – Arri Alexa Studio, Hawk C- and V-Series Lenses – SxS Pro – black & white with brief colour sequences – 2,35:1 – Hawk Scope anamorphic – digital intermediate 2K. PD: Pirjo Honkasalo, Peter Flinckenberg. Lighting cesign: Jani Lehtinen. AD: Pentti Valkeasuo. Cost: Saija Siekkinen. Makeup: Pia Mikkonen. VFX: 3-D Trix Finland Oy. Underwater cinematography: Meriturva / Jyrki Arnikari. M: Frid & Frid [Karl Frid, Pär Frid]. S: Jan Alvermark, Robert Sörling. ED: Niels Pagh Andersen. Graphic design: KingHill Advertising Oy.
    C: Johannes Brotherus (Simo), Jari Virman (Ilkka, ”Ile”), Anneli Karppinen (Mother), Juhan Ulfsak (Man), Alex Anton (Jusa), Iida Kuningas (Veera), Pauli Poranen (taxi driver), Mauno Paajanen (Twiggy), Rea Mauranen (Woman), Teijo Eloranta (Man with grey hair), Timo Välisaari (Tsali, Twiggy's assistent), Hannele Nieminen (Waitress).
    Locations: Helsinki: details: see beyond the jump break.*
    96 min
    Premiere: 1 Nov 2013 – released by Oy Cinema Mondo Ltd.
    Corona lockdown viewings / Women Make Film.
    Viewed from Draken with Swedish subtitles by Frej Grönholm on a 4K tv set at home in Helsinki, 7 May 2020.

AA: After Leijonasydän I watched another remarkable Finnish film of the 2010s, Betoniyö / Concrete Night, that I had missed during the first run. It garnered excellent reviews and was internationally recognized as a great work of art. It was Pirjo Honkasalo's first fiction film in 15 years, and like the previous one, Fire-Eater (1998), written by her partner, the prominent author and theatre veteran Pirkko Saisio.

Having seen the trailer of Concrete Night in 2013 I hesitated to see the film. The general digital look of the current releases made me think that if I were a child seeing films for the first time, I would never become a cinephile. In black and white I loved the creamy and velvety touch of photochemical film. I remembered how even in Sylvester Stallion action blockbusters in the 1990s colour cinematography evoked oil paintings of Dutch masters.

I admire Pirjo Honkasalo as a great cinematographer capable of dramatic lighting and lush, vivid and juicy imagery, her footage throbbing with life. The dead black and white look of the trailer of Concrete Night looked depressing, in extreme contrast to the vibrant Nine Ways to Approach Helsinki, which is not an idealized film either: it's a film about a fighting spirit, among other things. At the time I was looking for life in the cinema, not death.

The milieu: "betonilähiö", "concrete suburb", "concrete hood". The vision of Helsinki looks like a dystopia. In a similar way Jean-Luc Godard saw Paris as Alphaville. "Capital de douleur" could be the watchword even here.

Honkasalo is a veteran in filming Helsinki. With Jörn Donner and Pekka Lehto she shot some of the most unforgettable views of the Finnish capital for Nine Ways to Approach Helsinki (1982), its footage featuring prominently also in Peter von Bagh's compilation film Helsinki Forever (2008).

Pirkko Saisio original text has been acclaimed as a novel (1981) and a play (1982), but Pirjo Honkasalo's movie is pure cinema, not filmed literature or theatre. It is oneiric, nightmarish, in dream mode on many levels. There are dream sequences, but when we wake up, we remain in hallucination.

There is a broken home, two fatherless sons, and an alcoholic mother. The big brother Ilkka is about to go to prison because of a drug conviction. The little brother Simo is dazed and confused.

Alone at night in the sandbox on the courtyard he "makes angels" as we say in Finland: lying on his back and moving his arms to create a pattern of angel wings in the sand.

A male photographer from the opposite house invites him to have some tea and to listen to a record of Anne Sofie Otter. He photographs him, but when he comes too close, Simo hits him with results fatal for both.

The dialogue is crude and naturalistic. On the other hand it is spiritual and philosophical. The brutalized Ilkka teaches Simo that the only thing to fear is hope. The one without hope is strong. Only scorpions can survive a nuclear holocaust. Ilkka humiliates and degrades his ex-girlfriend Veera. The photographer teaches the opposite. There are only two things: love and fear. Love is to be followed. Who loses himself will find himself. But Ilkka and Simo are on their way to drown in a world without love.

Concrete Night is an exceptional visual experience. It turns the digital unreality into a means of expression. Most of the film is exaggerated in high contrast in a dark register in a way that looks underexposed. But after Simo returns from his cleansing experience by a surging forest stream the register turns bright and dazzling. The gloomy home is flooded by sunlight in a way that looks overexposed. Water is the element in the dreamscape of the prologue and the epilogue. An element of birth and death.

Ehsan Khoshbakht's Filmfarsi was created in "VHS-Scope". Concrete Night is in DeathScope.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: DATA FROM ELONET:

Wednesday, May 06, 2020

Women Make Film 10: Melodrama, Sci-Fi, Horror and Hell


From Chapter 26: Melodrama: Døden er et kjærtegn / Death is a Caress / Edith Carlmar, Norway 1949. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website.

From Chapter 27: SciFi: The Handmaid's Tale: Offred / Reed Morano, tv series episode, US 2017. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website.

From Chapter 28: Horror and Hell: A Girl in the River: The Price of Forgiveness / ਨਦੀ ਵਿੱਚ ਇੱਕ ਕੁੜੀ :ਮਾਫ਼ ਕਰਨ ਦੀ ਸਜ਼ਾ / Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, USA / Pakistan 2015. Screenshot from the Women Make Film website.

Women Make Film. A New Road Movie Through Cinema
Women Make Film. Uusi matka elokuvaan
GB © 2019 How To Make A Movie Ltd. PC: Hopscotch Films. P: John Archer. EX: Clara Glynn, Tilda Swinton. Assistant P: Sonali Choudhury. Associate P: Carl Beauchamp, Catherine Glynn Benkaim, Barbara Timmer.
    D+SC: Mark Cousins. Sound mixing: Diane Jardine. S: Joe Harfield. ED+script consultant: Timo Langer. Online: Chas Chalmers. Edit assistant: Scott Bilsbrough. P coordinator: Mhairi Valentine. P team: David Brown, Rowan Ings, Raja Kryda. World Sales: Dogwoof. Head of sales: Ana Vicente. Legal: David Burgess.
    https://www.womenmakefilm.com/
    14 hours – HD – 16:9
    Festival premiere: 1 Sep 2018 Venice Film Festival
    Finnish telepremieres of the 14 episodes: 3.3.2020, 10.3.2020, 17.3.2020, 24.3.2020, 1.4.2020, 8.4.2020, 15.4.2020, 22.4.2020, 29.4.2020, 6.5.2020, 13.5.2020, 20.5.2020, 27.5.2020, 3.6.2020
 
Episode 10/14: Melodrama, Sci-Fi, Horror and Hell
Jakso 10/14: Lajityyppien salat
Narrators: Sharmila Tagore, Thandie Newton
Finnish / Swedish subtitles: Jaana Wiik / Anna-Sofi Pettersson

Chapter 26. Melodrama

Shoes / Lois Weber, US 1916
Døden er et kjærtegn / Death is a Caress / Rakkaus on kuolemaksi / Edith Carlmar, NO 1949
Chekhovskie motivy / Чеховские мотивы / Chekhov's Motifs / Tshehovilaistunnelmissa / Kira Muratova, UA/RU 2002
Ty i ya / Ты и я / You and Me / Sinä ja minä / Larisa Shepitko, SU 1971
Tiefland / Lowlands / Alamaa / Leni Riefenstahl, DE 1940–1944 / 1954
Zabitá neděle / Squandered Sunday / Drahomíra Vihanová, CZ 1969 [unreleased in Finland]
A byahme mladi / А бяхме млади / We Were Young / Binka Zhelyazkova, BG 1961 [unreleased in Finland]
Koibumi / 恋文 / Love Letter / Kinuyo Tanaka, JP 1953 [unreleased in Finland]

Chapter 27. Sci-Fi

The Matrix / Matrix / Andy Wachowski, Larry Wachowski > Lana Wachowski, Lilly Wachowski, US 1999
Wonder Woman / Wonder Woman / Patty Jenkins, US 2017
Jupiter Ascending / Nouseva Jupiter / The Wachowskis = Lana Wachowski, Lilly Wachowski, US/AU 2015
Tank Girl / Tank Girl / Rachel Talalay, US 1995
The Handmaid's Tale: Offred (Season 1, Episode 1, April 26, 2017) / The Handmaid's Tale – Orjattaresi / Reed Morano, tv series episode, US 2017
Unsichtbare Gegner / Invisible Adversaries / Valie Export, AT 1977 [unreleased in Finland]
Az én XX. századom / My 20th Century / Minun 20. vuosisatani / Ildikó Enyedi, HU/DE/DU 1989

Chapter 28. Horror and Hell

Huis-clos / No Exit / Suljetut ovet / Jaqueline Audry, FR 1954
Ellen / Mahalia Belo, tv, GB 2016 [unreleased in Finland]
Earth / अर्थ / Jaettu maa / Deepa Mehta, IN/CA 1998
Astenicheski sindrom / Астенический синдром / The Asthenic Syndrome / Asteeninen oire / Kira Muratova, SU 1990
Takhté siah / تخته سیاه  / Blackboards / Liitutaulut / Samira Makhmalbaf, IR/IT/JP 2000
Tore tanzt / Nothing Bad Can Happen / Katrin Gebbe, DE 2013 [unreleased in Finland]
Safe / Tillflykten / Antonia Bird, GB 1993
NabelFabel / Mara Mattuschka, AT 1984 [unreleased in Finland]
A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night / A Girl Walks Home Alone at Night / Ana Lily Amirpour, US 2014
Mossane / Safi Faye, DE/SN 1996 [unreleased in Finland]
A byahme mladi / А бяхме млади / We Were Young / Binka Zhelyazkova, BG 1961 [unreleased in Finland]
The Babadook / The Babadook / Jennifer Kent, AU/CA 2014
Archipelago / Joanna Hogg, GB 2010 [unreleased in Finland]
Swimmer / Lynne Ramsay, c.m., GB 2012
A Girl in the River: The Price of Forgiveness / ਨਦੀ ਵਿੱਚ ਇੱਕ ਕੁੜੀ :ਮਾਫ਼ ਕਰਨ ਦੀ ਸਜ਼ਾ / ਏ ਗਰਲ ਇਨ ਦਾ ਰਿਵਰ: ਦਾ ਪਰਾਈਸ ਆਫ਼ ਫੌਰਗਿਵਨੈਸ / Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy, 40 min, dok, US/PK 2015
Samt el qusur / صمت القصور  / The Silence of the Palaces / Palatsin hiljaisuus / Moufida Tlatli, TN 1994
Lore / Lore / Cate Shortland, DE/AU/GB 2012
Outrage / Ida Lupino, US 1950 [unreleased in Finland]
Huis-clos / No Exit / Suljetut ovet / Jaqueline Audry, FR 1954

AA: In Episode 9 of Women Make Film Mark Cousins started his genre survey with comedy. In this episode he discusses melodrama, science fiction and horror.

My reaction is again deeply divided. The samples are wonderful, and they are the raison d'être of this series: it is a goldmine of treasures and discoveries. The clips from Lois Weber's Shoes, Kinuyo Tanaka's Love Letter, Valie Export's Unsichtbare Gegner, Ildiko Enyedi's My 20th Century, Jacqueline Audry's Huis clos and Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy's A Girl in the River are memorable and revelatory. Sexual violence is portrayed in Edith Carlmar's Death Is a Caress, Ida Lupino's Outrage and Moufida Tlatli's The Silences of the Palaces, among others.

But the film historical survey across genres is erratic and half-baked.

Here we have melodrama, the most important genre in this context. It was called "woman's film" for a reason, and I think for an important reason. Melodrama, together with comedy and pornography, is the most physical genre. In the golden age of melodrama (before postmodernism) people went to the cinema to cry together. I have childhood memories of this phenomenon which has become rare or subdued in the Western world. Many memoirs testify that during wartime women cried out loud in the cinemas. The films gave them an excuse to cry, and they needed to. The directors may have been male, but those films were star vehicles: Lillian Gish, Mary Pickford, Bette Davis, Joan Crawford and Barbara Stanwyck were international stars, and every country had its own local stars and identification figures. It was a big deal.

Another clue is given by Robert Warshow in his essay "The Gangster as Tragic Hero". He discusses melodrama in one sentence, writing about "the continually reasserted strain of hopelessness that often seems to be the real meaning of soap opera". What lies at the bottom of this is a sense of a constitutional injustice, a world that is rigged so that women are bound to lose and fail. Melodrama recognizes this and at least provides a way to channel untold suffering and disappointment.

Cousins zigzags in the melodrama chapter and avoids issues. Science fiction has never been a women's genre, and Cousins does not manage to convince me otherwise. Kathryn Bigelow, yes, and the dystopia of A Handmaid's Tale, definitely yes. Fantasy is a genre of its own, and experimental film is a different approach entirely. The Wachowskys were brothers when they made the Matrix trilogy.

Horror certainly is relevant from a "women make film" viewpoint. Female Gothic has a profound place in fiction. Like melodrama, it channels huge issues. Home (already discussed in a chapter of its own in this series) is the feminine space par excellence, and female gothic provides devastating angles to the theme. The young and innocent woman enters the house of her husband, and it turns out to conceal sinister secrets. The man turns into a stranger, and the woman becomes a stranger in her own home. Such themes are missing in Cousins's chapter.

Women film directors have made important contributions to horror, including Kathryn Bigelow, Mary Lambert, Antonia Bird, Mary Harron, Julia Ducournau, Jennifer Kent and Ana Lily Amirpour, well represented here. Reflecting on Finnish cinema it is worth remembering The White Reindeer: Erik Blomberg is credited as the sole director but he always insisted that he should have shared equal billing with his wife Mirjami Kuosmanen. In their team Erik was in charge of production and photography, Mirjami of the screenplay and direction of actors. The concept of The White Reindeer was Mirjami Kuosmanen's who also starred in the film. Another Finnish film that might be relevant in this context is Auli Mantila's The Collector. This series only focuses on directors; influential producers in genre cinema have been Debra Hill (with John Carpenter and others) and Gale Anne Hurd (with James Cameron etc.).

Vampire romance fiction would have deserved acknowledgement: Anne Rice and Stephenie Meyer have revived a big trend of horror fiction. Not forgetting the mother of Gothic horror, Mary Shelley.

The horror chapter blends with tales of real-life hell. Personally, I see a fundamental difference: horror fiction shapes experience via dreamwork. It is nightmare cinema.

Tuesday, May 05, 2020

Leijonasydän / Heart of a Lion



Lejonhjärtat.
    FI 2013. PC: Helsinki-filmi Oy / Anagram Produktion Ab / Film i Väst AB. P: Aleksi Bardy. EX: Miia Haavisto, Annika Sucksdorff.
    D: Dome Karukoski. SC: Aleksi Bardy. Cin: Hena Blomberg. AD: Antti Nikkinen. Cost: Anna Vilppunen. Makeup: Kata Launonen. VFX: Sean Wheelan. M: Jean-Paul Wall. "Sivullinen" by and perf. Jenni Vartiainen. S: Christian Holm, Niklas Skarp. ED: Harri Ylönen.
    C: Peter Franzén (Teppo Salminen), Laura Birn (Sari), Jasper Pääkkönen (Harri Salminen), Yusufa Sidibeh (Rhamadhani, ”Ramu”, ”Papu”), Jussi Vatanen (Kulmala), Timo Lavikainen (Olli), Pamela Tola (Tölli), Mikko Neuvonen (Daniel), Niko Vakkuri (Reko), Jani Toivola (Salif, Ramun isä), Stan Saanila (Aleksi Rämö, Akin isä), Eeva Litmanen (teacher), Deogracias Masomi (Ahmed, owner of a hot dog stand).
    Loc: Kotka (Finland).
    104 min
    Premiere: 18 Oct 2013, distributed by Scanbox Entertainment Finland Oy.
    Corona lockdown viewings / Dome Karukoski.
    Blu-ray released by Scanbox viewed on a 4K tv screen at home in Helsinki, 5 May 2020.

AA: I saw now for the first time Leijonasydän, one of the best Finnish films of the 2010s. It is based on a strong screenplay by Aleksi Bardy, it has been directed vigorously by Dome Karukoski, and it has a great cast. Peter Franzén and Jasper Pääkkönen appear in career-changing roles as Neo-Nazi brothers.

The delicate and inflammatory subject has been treated without squeamishness. There are affinities in the direct and frontal address with Samuel Fuller (The White Dog) and Roger Corman (The Intruder). The white supremacy mumbo-jumbo can seem farcical: Hitler salutes are accompanied with calls "for a white Finland". But this gang of Neo-Nazis is dangerous. They demolish the hot dog stand of an African-Finn. They destroy a Romani camp.

The brothers Teppo and Harri Salminen are outcasts of society, coming from a broken home. Teppo cannot get a job because of his criminal record. Harri is discarded from military service because of his asocial behaviour. Their strong "humpadelic" drive, or excessive testosterone flow, brings them back to society. It is not love at first sight between Teppo and Sari (Laura Birn). It is sex at first sight, but the meeting of two turbocharged libidos turns to love. This aspect of the narrative brings a special kind of humour into the film, for instance in Teppo's visit to the urologist who has seen a lot but never what the insatiable Sari has accomplished. Jasper Pääkkönen in turn has a chance to participate in the international film stars' schlong race, his contribution no less remarkable than those by Ewan McGregor, Michael Fassbender and Tom Mercier. Dome Karukoski handles this aspect of the film with taste, with just the right balance, without the overdone caution that hampered his Tom of Finland.

The theme of racism is handled with refreshing openness. The neo-Nazis, especially the brother Harri, are aghast when their leader Teppo becomes the father of a black kid. The black kid Rhamadhani (Yusufa Sibideh) and his biological father Salif (Jani Toivola) refuse to be victimized. They take the initiative and target the Nazis with sharp verbal attacks. Rhamadhani goes further. He tries to electrocute Teppo when he is trying to fix the lights in the cellar, and he tries to kill him with rat poison. But instead it is Sari who happens to eat the poisoned food and is hospitalized.

When school bullying becomes overwhelming for Rhamadhani, he gets an unexpected protector from the muscular Teppo. Teppo teaches Rhamadhani self-defense skills. Dome Karukoski knows school bullying. Teachers and psychologists look the other way, defend the bullies and try to evict the victim. This is how it is in schools and at work. Psychologists who should help instead become instruments of the legitimization of the bullying. Leijonasydän presents a tragicomical dream solution: a neo-Nazi as the protector of a black kid.

The production is handsome, the cinematography is eloquent, and the lighting and the mise-en-scène are dynamic. The most impressive achievement of Leijonasydän is a subtle psychological balance in an extremely provocative narrative. The story is dramatic, and it deals in extremes, but it is never too exaggerated. There is a believable core in this voyage to the heart of darkness. The humanity of even the worst extremists is recognizable.

BEYOND THE JUMP BREAK: DATA FROM ELONET: